Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic is causing mass disruption to our daily lives. We integrate mobility data from mobile devices and area-level data to study the walking patterns of 1.62 million anonymous users in 10 metropolitan areas in the United States. The data covers the period from mid-February 2020 (pre-lockdown) to late June 2020 (easing of lockdown restrictions). We detect when users were walking, distance walked and time of the walk, and classify each walk as recreational or utilitarian. Our results reveal dramatic declines in walking, particularly utilitarian walking, while recreational walking has recovered and even surpassed pre-pandemic levels. Our findings also demonstrate important social patterns, widening existing inequalities in walking behavior. COVID-19 response measures have a larger impact on walking behavior for those from low-income areas and high use of public transportation. Provision of equal opportunities to support walking is key to opening up our society and economy.
Introduction
Physical inactivity was a global health crisis long before 2020, contributing significantly to mortality and non-communicable diseases. While early pandemic reports noted a general decline in movement, they often relied on small-scale, self-reported surveys that couldn't distinguish between the motivations behind walking. This study addresses a critical gap: understanding the spatio-temporal dynamics of different types of walking (utilitarian vs. recreational) across diverse socio-demographic groups. By doing so, it highlights how policy responses to a biological threat can inadvertently exacerbate social "fault lines," creating a "tale of two pandemics" where the burden of inactivity falls hardest on the most vulnerable.
Methodology
The researchers employed a "big data" approach to human mobility, integrating several massive datasets:
- Cuebiq Mobility Data: Anonymized GPS records from 1.62 million users across 10 US metropolitan areas (NYC, LA, Chicago, Boston, Miami, Dallas, SF, Seattle, Philly, and DC).
- Foursquare POI Database: 1.5 million points of interest used to classify walk destinations.
- U.S. Census ACS (2013–2018): Provided area-level demographics (income, race, age, public transit use).
- CDC 500 Cities & City Health Dashboard: Provided health indicators (obesity) and environmental factors (park access).
Using geolocalized pings, they identified walking "bouts" (speeds up to 2 m/s). A destination-based algorithm classified these: walks ending at Points of Interest (POIs) like shops or offices were labeled utilitarian, while those ending in parks or residential areas without specific commercial destinations were labeled recreational.
Results: The Great Decoupling
The pandemic caused a massive divergence in walking types. Following the March 2020 national emergency declaration, the number of walking bouts dropped by approximately 70%, and average distance walked fell by 50%.
By late June 2020, total walking distance remained 18% below pre-pandemic levels. However, this total masks a "Great Decoupling": utilitarian walking saw a dramatic and sustained decline (-72.3% initially, remaining 39.2% lower by June), while recreational walking proved resilient, eventually surpassing pre-pandemic levels as people sought outdoor escape.
Socio-Economic Disparities
The impact was not uniform across the population. A neighborhood's reliance on public transportation was the strongest predictor of declining walking, as the collapse of commuting decimated utilitarian walking. Furthermore, a significant "flexibility gap" emerged based on income.
High-income populations were able to substitute lost commute walks with leisure walks, with leisure walking in the highest income quintiles increasing by 49%. In contrast, low-income populations, often living in environments with fewer parks and higher density, saw a net loss in total physical activity. Access to green space became a primary driver of recovery; areas with high park access saw walking levels rebound much faster than those without.
Discussion
The authors acknowledge limitations, including the use of mobile phone data as a proxy and the reliance on area-level demographics (census tracts), which can lead to the "ecological fallacy." Additionally, the study identifies the increase in leisure walking but does not capture the qualitative experience of these walks.
To prevent temporary declines in utilitarian walking from becoming permanent, the authors suggest that "tactical urbanism"—such as pedestrianizing streets and expanding cycle lanes—is essential. Provision of equal opportunities to support walking is key to opening up society and the economy while addressing widening health inequalities.
Summary updated