Distributed weak independent sets in hypergraphs: Upper and lower bounds

Duncan Adamson, Will Rosenbaum, Paul G. Spirakis

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem of finding weak independent sets in a distributed network represented by a hypergraph. In this setting, each edge contains a set of $r$ vertices rather than simply a pair, as in a standard graph. A $k$-weak independent set in a hypergraph is a set where no edge contains more than $k$ vertices in the independent set. We focus on two variations of this problem. First, we study the problem of finding $k$-weak maximal independent sets, $k$-weak independent sets where each vertex belongs to at least one edge with $k$ vertices in the independent set. Second, we introduce a weaker variant that we call $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent sets where the independent set is $\beta$-weak, and each vertex belongs to at least one edge with at least $\alpha$ vertices in the independent set. Finally, we consider the problem of finding a $(2, k)$-ruling set on hypergraphs, i.e., independent sets where no vertex is a distance of more than $k$ from the nearest member of the set. Given a hypergraph $H$ of rank $r$ and maximum degree $\Delta$, we provide a Lovász Local Lemma (LLL) formulation for finding an $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent set when $(\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 \log(16 r \Delta)$, an $O(\Delta r / (\beta - \alpha + 1) + \log^* n)$ round deterministic algorithm finding an $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent set, and a $O(\Delta^2(r - k) \log r + \Delta \log r \log^* r + \log^* n)$ round algorithm for finding a $k$-weak maximal independent set. Additionally, we provide zero-round randomized algorithms for finding $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent sets, when $(\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 c \log n + 6$ for some constant $c$, and finding an $m$-weak independent set for some $m \geq r / 2k$ where $k$ is a given parameter. Finally, we provide lower bounds of $\Omega(\Delta + \log^* n)$ and $\Omega(r + \log^* n)$ on the problems of finding a $k$-weak maximal independent sets for some values of $k$.

Introduction

In the realm of distributed computing, the Maximal Independent Set (MIS) problem is a cornerstone for symmetry breaking, used extensively for leader election and resource allocation. While standard graph models (where edges connect exactly two vertices) are well-studied, many complex systems are better modeled as hypergraphs. In a hypergraph, an edge (or hyperedge) can contain an arbitrary number of vertices, denoted by the rank $r$.

This research provides a comprehensive analysis of the distributed complexity of finding weak independent sets in hypergraphs. By relaxing the strict requirements of a standard independent set—where no two adjacent nodes can both be in the set—the authors explore the trade-offs between the "weakness" of the set and the communication rounds required to find it.

Problem Definitions

The authors investigate several variants of independent sets tailored for hypergraphs:

  1. $k$-weak Independent Set: A subset of vertices such that no hyperedge contains more than $k$ members of the subset.
  2. $k$-weak Maximal Independent Set (k-MIS): A $k$-weak independent set where every vertex in the graph is "covered"—specifically, every vertex must belong to at least one hyperedge that contains exactly $k$ members of the set.
  3. $(\alpha, \beta)$-Independent Set: A generalization where the set is $\beta$-weak (no edge has $>\beta$ members), but every vertex must be in an edge with at least $\alpha$ members. This variant highlights the "slack" between coverage requirements and independence constraints.
  4. $(2, k)$-Ruling Set: A set where no two members are adjacent, and every vertex is within distance $k$ of some member of the set.

The primary goal is to determine the round complexity in the LOCAL model, where nodes communicate in synchronous rounds and have no limits on message size, but only local knowledge of the network topology.

Methodology

The research utilizes a combination of probabilistic methods and combinatorial algorithms:

  • Lovász Local Lemma (LLL): The authors use the LLL to prove the existence of these sets under specific conditions related to the degree $\Delta$ and rank $r$. They then leverage the distributed Moser-Tardös algorithm to find these sets efficiently.
  • Defective Coloring: A key algorithmic strategy involves partitioning the vertices into color classes such that no hyperedge is "overloaded" with nodes of the same color. By processing these color classes sequentially, nodes can greedily decide their membership in the independent set.
  • Lower Bound Reductions: To establish the fundamental difficulty of these problems, the authors use reductions from known hard problems in distributed computing, showing that solving certain hypergraph MIS variants quickly would imply faster-than-possible solutions for standard graph MIS.

Key Insights

The Power of Slack

A central finding is that the difficulty of finding an $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent set depends heavily on the gap between $\alpha$ and $\beta$. When the "slack" $(\beta - \alpha)$ is large, the problem becomes significantly easier. This is formalized in the LLL conditions and the round complexities of the proposed algorithms.

Zero-Round Feasibility

Perhaps the most striking result is the existence of zero-round randomized algorithms. The authors prove that if the gap between $\beta$ and $\alpha$ is sufficiently large relative to the total number of nodes $n$, vertices can decide whether to join the set independently and randomly without any communication, and still satisfy the $(\alpha, \beta)$ constraints with high probability.

Hypergraph Complexity vs. Graph Complexity

While standard MIS complexity on graphs is primarily a function of the maximum degree $\Delta$ and the number of nodes $n$, hypergraphs introduce a dependency on the rank $r$. The authors demonstrate that for 1-weak MIS, the complexity is $\Omega(\Delta + r + \log^* n)$, proving that hypergraph variants are fundamentally harder than their graph counterparts.

Summary of Results

  • Deterministic Upper Bounds: The authors provide an algorithm for $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent sets running in $O(\Delta r / (\beta - \alpha + 1) + \log^* n)$ rounds.
  • Improved k-MIS Algorithms: For larger values of $k$, they present an algorithm with complexity $O(\Delta^2(r - k) \log r + \Delta \log r \log^* r + \log^* n)$, which is more efficient than previous naive reductions.
  • Lower Bounds: They establish lower bounds of $\Omega(\Delta + \log^* n)$ and $\Omega(r + \log^* n)$ for finding $k$-weak MIS, highlighting the inherent costs of symmetry breaking in high-rank structures.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work establishes the first systematic landscape of distributed weak independent sets in hypergraphs. However, several open questions remain. There is a notable gap between the lower bound $\Omega(\Delta + r + \log^* n)$ and the deterministic upper bound $O(r\Delta + \log^* n)$ for the 1-weak MIS problem. Additionally, the sensitivity of $k$-MIS complexity to the value of $k$ warrants further investigation, as does the potential for more advanced edge-defective coloring techniques to further reduce round complexity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem of finding weak independent sets in a distributed network represented by a hypergraph. In this setting, each edge contains a set of r vertices rather than simply a pair, as in a standard graph. A k-weak independent set in a hypergraph is a set where no edge contains more than k vertices in the independent set. We focus two variations of this problem. First, we study the problem of finding k-weak maximal independent sets, k-weak independent sets where each vertex belongs to at least one edge with k vertices in the independent set. Second we introduce a weaker variant that we call (\alpha, \beta)-independent sets where the independent set is \beta-weak, and each vertex belongs to at least one edge with at least \alpha vertices in the independent set. Finally, we consider the problem of finding a (2, k)-ruling set on hypergraphs, i.e. independent sets where no vertex is a distance of more than k from the nearest member of the set. Given a hypergraph H of rank r and maximum degree \Delta, we provide a LLL formulation for finding an (\alpha, \beta)-independent set when (\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 \log(16 r \Delta), an O(\Delta r / (\beta - \alpha + 1) + \log^* n) round deterministic algorithm finding an (\alpha, \beta)-independent set, and a O(\Delta^2(r - k) \log r + \Delta \log r \log^* r + \log^* n) round algorithm for finding a k-weak maximal independent set. Additionally, we provide zero round randomized algorithms for finding (\alpha, \beta) independent sets, when (\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 c \log n + 6 for some constant c, and finding an m-weak independent set for some m \geq r / 2k where k is a given parameter. Finally, we provide lower bounds of \Omega(\Delta + \log^* n) and \Omega(r + \log^* n) on the problems of finding a k-weak maximal independent sets for some values of k.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adamson2025distributed,
  author = {Duncan Adamson and Will Rosenbaum and Paul G. Spirakis},
  title = {{Distributed weak independent sets in hypergraphs: Upper and lower bounds}},
  booktitle = {ALGOWIN},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-032-09120-8\_1},
}
Figure