Distributed Weak Independent Sets in Hypergraphs: Upper and Lower Bounds

Duncan Adamson, Will Rosenbaum, Paul G. Spirakis

TL;DR

This paper provides the first comprehensive look at the distributed complexity of finding weak independent sets in hypergraphs. The authors establish both lower bounds (proving certain versions are fundamentally "hard") and upper bounds (providing new algorithms), including a surprising "zero-round" randomized approach for specific parameter ranges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In a standard graph, an Independent Set (IS) is a collection of nodes where no two nodes share an edge. In distributed computing, finding a Maximal Independent Set (MIS) is a classic "symmetry breaking" problem used to elect leaders or allocate resources.

However, many real-world networks are better represented as hypergraphs, where an "edge" can connect any number of vertices ($r$), not just two. The authors explore weak independent sets, where we relax the rules:

  1. k-weak independent set: An edge can contain up to $k$ members of the set (instead of just one).
  2. ($\alpha, \beta$)-independent set: A new variant where an edge can have up to $\beta$ members, but every vertex in the graph must be "covered" by at least one edge containing $\alpha$ members.

The core challenge is determining the round complexity: how many rounds of local communication are required for nodes to agree on these sets without global knowledge of the network?

Methods

The authors employ several sophisticated theoretical tools:

  • Lower Bound Reductions: They prove certain problems are hard by showing that if you could solve them quickly, you could also solve the standard MIS problem faster than theoretically possible.
  • Lovász Local Lemma (LLL): They use the LLL to prove that these weak independent sets exist under certain conditions and then apply the distributed Moser-Tardös algorithm to find them efficiently.
  • Defective Coloring: A primary algorithmic strategy involves finding a coloring where no hyperedge contains too many nodes of the same color. By iterating through these color classes, nodes can greedily decide whether to join the independent set.
  • LOCAL Model: All algorithms are analyzed in the standard LOCAL model of distributed computing, where communication is synchronous and message size is unlimited.

Datasets

As a theoretical computer science paper, no empirical datasets were used. The results are mathematical proofs that apply to all hypergraphs characterized by their rank ($r$, the max nodes per edge) and maximum degree ($\Delta$, the max edges per node).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Slack" Advantage: The paper reveals that the difficulty of the problem depends heavily on the "slack" between $\alpha$ and $\beta$. If you are allowed a lot of members per edge ($\beta$) but only need to guarantee a few for coverage ($\alpha$), the problem becomes much easier.
  • Zero-Round Feasibility: One of the most striking insights is that if the gap between $\beta$ and $\alpha$ is large enough relative to the network size, nodes can decide whether to join the set randomly and independently without any communication at all, and still succeed with high probability.
  • Hypergraph vs. Graph Complexity: While standard MIS on graphs is well-understood, hypergraphs introduce a new dependency on the rank ($r$). The authors show that for some "weak" versions, the complexity depends more on $r$ than on the total number of nodes $n$.

Key Results

  • Lower Bounds: Finding a 1-weak MIS (the strictest version) requires at least $\Omega(\Delta + r + \log^* n)$ rounds. This proves that hypergraph MIS is fundamentally harder than standard graph MIS.
  • Deterministic Algorithms: They provide an algorithm to find an $(\alpha, \beta)$-independent set in $O(\Delta r / (\beta - \alpha + 1) + \log^* n)$ rounds.
  • Improved k-MIS: For large $k$, they present an algorithm that runs in $O(\Delta^2(r-k)\log r + \Delta \log r \log^* r + \log^* n)$ rounds, improving upon previous "trivial" reductions.
  • Randomized Zero-Round: They prove that an $(\alpha, \beta)$-IS can be found in zero rounds if $(\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6c \log n + 6$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gaps in Bounds: There is still a significant gap between the lower bound $\Omega(\Delta + r + \log^* n)$ and the upper bound $O(r\Delta + \log^* n)$ for the 1-weak MIS problem. Closing this gap is a primary direction for future research.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The current algorithms for $k$-MIS are most efficient when $k$ is close to $r$. The authors suggest that finding $k$-weak MIS might become inherently harder as $k$ decreases, but they haven't yet proven a general lower bound for all values of $k$.
  • Coloring Techniques: The authors believe that more advanced "edge-defective" coloring techniques could further optimize these round complexities.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem of finding weak independent sets in a distributed network represented by a hypergraph. In this setting, each edge contains a set of r vertices rather than simply a pair, as in a standard graph. A k-weak independent set in a hypergraph is a set where no edge contains more than k vertices in the independent set. We focus two variations of this problem. First, we study the problem of finding k-weak maximal independent sets, k-weak independent sets where each vertex belongs to at least one edge with k vertices in the independent set. Second we introduce a weaker variant that we call (\alpha, \beta)-independent sets where the independent set is \beta-weak, and each vertex belongs to at least one edge with at least \alpha vertices in the independent set. Finally, we consider the problem of finding a (2, k)-ruling set on hypergraphs, i.e. independent sets where no vertex is a distance of more than k from the nearest member of the set. Given a hypergraph H of rank r and maximum degree \Delta, we provide a LLL formulation for finding an (\alpha, \beta)-independent set when (\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 \log(16 r \Delta), an O(\Delta r / (\beta - \alpha + 1) + \log^* n) round deterministic algorithm finding an (\alpha, \beta)-independent set, and a O(\Delta^2(r - k) \log r + \Delta \log r \log^* r + \log^* n) round algorithm for finding a k-weak maximal independent set. Additionally, we provide zero round randomized algorithms for finding (\alpha, \beta) independent sets, when (\beta - \alpha)^2 / (\beta + \alpha) \geq 6 c \log n + 6 for some constant c, and finding an m-weak independent set for some m \geq r / 2k where k is a given parameter. Finally, we provide lower bounds of \Omega(\Delta + \log^* n) and \Omega(r + \log^* n) on the problems of finding a k-weak maximal independent sets for some values of k.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adamson2025distributed,
  author = {Duncan Adamson and Will Rosenbaum and Paul G. Spirakis},
  title = {{Distributed Weak Independent Sets in Hypergraphs: Upper and Lower Bounds}},
  booktitle = {ALGOWIN},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-032-09120-8\_1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure