Dissimilar Material Joining of Densified Superwood to Aluminum by Adhesive Bonding

Matt Hartsfield, Bo Chen, Yu Liu, Shuaiming He, Ulrich H. Leiste, W.l. Fourney, Teng Li, Liangbing Hu, Alan A. LuoResearch Square 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Superwood, a densified wood product, offers a renewable and lightweight alternative to metals. Integrating this material into multi-material systems, such as automotive components, requires effective joining techniques with metals like aluminum. This study identifies a methacrylate-based adhesive capable of achieving high lap shear strengths (~7.5 MPa) for aluminum-to-superwood joints. By optimizing surface preparation to re-open pores and facilitate mechanical interlocking, researchers achieved bond strengths 50% higher than natural wood-to-wood joints and comparable to aluminum-to-aluminum joints.

Introduction

The push for sustainable materials in the automotive and structural sectors has highlighted "superwood"—a chemically treated and hot-pressed basswood that reaches triple its natural density. Superwood is half as dense as aluminum alloy 5754 yet possesses twice the tensile strength. However, the densification process collapses the wood's natural pores, making traditional adhesive bonding difficult. This research explores methods to engineer the interface between superwood and aluminum to create structural-grade bonds without the weight and stress concentrations of mechanical fasteners.

Methods

The study utilized superwood and Al5754 aluminum alloy. The primary adhesive selected was Plexus MA832, a methacrylate-based adhesive chosen for its ability to bond non-metals without primers and its room-temperature curing process, which avoids heat-induced damage to wood fibers.

Surface engineering was a critical variable, with four preparations tested:

  1. No Surface Prep (NS): Baseline raw materials.
  2. Oriented Scratches (OS): Transverse sanding with 320-grit paper.
  3. Random Scratches (RS): Random sanding to expose collapsed pores.
  4. Patterning: Creating physical indentations in the aluminum to increase surface area.

Clamping forces of 0 N, 667 N, and 1334 N were applied during curing to optimize adhesive penetration. Joint performance was evaluated using single and double lap-shear tests and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM).

Results and Discussion

The experimental data revealed that surface preparation and clamping force significantly influence joint strength. Random scratching (RS) combined with a moderate clamping force of 667 N yielded consistent high-strength results, though the highest individual average strengths were observed in some "No Surface Prep" samples under specific clamping conditions.

Table 1: Experimental results for superwood-to-aluminum joints under various surface preparations and clamping forces.

The optimized aluminum-to-superwood joints reached a lap shear strength of approximately 7.6 MPa, significantly outperforming natural wood-to-wood benchmarks (~4.5 MPa). SEM analysis confirmed that sanding "re-opens" wood vessels, allowing the adhesive to penetrate approximately 10 microns and create a mechanical interlock. Chemically, the Methyl Methacrylate (MMA) in the adhesive forms hydrogen bonds with wood cellulose and ionic/hydrogen bonds with the aluminum's natural oxide layer.

A "Pressure Paradox" was observed: while 667 N generally improved bonding, 1334 N often reduced strength by squeezing too much adhesive out of the joint, leading to a "starved" interface. The most successful joints exhibited "deep wood failure," where the internal structure of the wood failed before the adhesive bond, indicating the interface strength exceeded the material's bulk strength.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that superwood can be effectively joined to aluminum using optimized adhesive bonding techniques. While patterning aluminum improved load capacity, similar attempts on superwood caused internal fracturing. Future research will focus on "functionally graded superwood" to maintain surface porosity for bonding while preserving core density, and seeking direct chemical evidence of the PMMA-to-cellulose bond.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Superwood is a densified wood product that shows promise as a lightweight and renewable alternative for metallic materials. In order for this high-performance new material to be used in multi-material products, it must be able to be joined with other major materials. For example, joining superwood to aluminum would provide a key enabling technology for its use in automotive components since aluminum is presently a major lightweight material for such applications. In this paper, a methacrylate-based adhesive has been identified to provide high lap shear strength (7.5 MPa) for aluminum-to-superwood joints. The aluminum-to-superwood samples were prepared with different amounts of pre-polishing to create openings to the pores in the superwood so adhesive could penetrate into them and create a mechanical interlock, in addition to the hydrogen/chemical bonding at the surface between the methyl methacrylate (MMA) in methacrylate-based adhesive and the cellulose in superwood. For aluminum samples, a thin layer (typically a few nanometres) of oxide film on the surfaces provides hydrogen/chemical bond to MMA structure in the adhesive layer. The failure strength of the superwood-to-aluminum joint sample is about 50% higher than that of natural wood to natural wood joint sample, and comparable to that of aluminum-to-aluminum joint sample.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hartsfield2023dissimilar,
  author = {Matt Hartsfield and Bo Chen and Yu Liu and Shuaiming He and Ulrich H. Leiste and W.L. Fourney and Teng Li and Liangbing Hu and Alan A. Luo},
  title = {{Dissimilar Material Joining of Densified Superwood to Aluminum by Adhesive Bonding}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3597714/v1},
}
Figure