Experimental assessment of the effect of surfacecondition on aged adhesive joint performance

R. Vervaeke, Josef Weiland, Frank Buysschaert, Stijn Debruyne, Dirk Vandepitte, Alexander Schiebahn, David MoensResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Industries such as aerospace are very interested in the use of structural adhesives as a joining technique. Compared to riveting, they offer better stress distribution, eliminating stress peaks which can be quite problematic with thin sheet materials. The ability to bond different materials allows for a wider range of material combinations that result in weight reduction. Aluminium and other metals are popular in the aerospace industry, but their reactivity to water molecules compromises the bond strength. This presents problems for manufacturers in predicting and monitoring service life. This study addresses degradation at the interface and the importance of proper surface treatment. Two different adhesive types (epoxy and methylacrylate) and adherent materials (AW 5754 H111 and AISI 1.4301) result in four different sample configurations. Several pretreatments are applied, all using different mechanisms to improve adhesion. After surface treatment, the contact angle with de-ionised water is measured, which is directly related to surface energy. The samples are tested for residual lap shear strength after being subjected to an ageing trajectory for one week. Statistical analysis is used to establish a relationship between surface energy and residual lap shear strength. The importance of surface treatment is established, but there is no direct relationship between contact angle and joint durability. Corrosion protection appears to be important, and the adherent material and adhesive type determine the optimum surface treatment.

Introduction

In the aerospace and automotive sectors, structural adhesives are increasingly favored over traditional mechanical fasteners like rivets. Adhesives offer superior stress distribution, eliminating the stress concentrations common in thin-sheet materials and enabling the bonding of dissimilar materials for significant weight reduction. However, the long-term reliability of these joints is often compromised by environmental factors, specifically moisture. Water molecules can penetrate the adhesive interface, leading to interfacial degradation—a process where the bond effectively "unzips." This study investigates which surface pretreatments best "future-proof" joints against moisture-induced aging and evaluates whether common industrial metrics, such as contact angle, are reliable predictors of service life.

Experimental Methodology

The experimental matrix utilized two substrates: Aluminum (AW 5754 H111) and Stainless Steel (AISI 1.4301), paired with two adhesive types: a 2K structural epoxy (TPE 1671) and a 2K methylacrylate (DP 8405). A wide array of surface pretreatments was evaluated, including grit blasting, chemical etching, oxidizing flames, primers, Argon plasma, DELO-SACO (silicate coating), Pyrosil, and Laser treatment.

Schematic of the Single Lap Shear (SLS) specimen used for mechanical testing.

Performance was assessed using Single Lap Shear (SLS) specimens (Figure 1). To simulate long-term environmental exposure, samples were subjected to an aggressive aging trajectory: one week at 70°C and 95% relative humidity. Residual lap shear strength was then measured and compared against unaged reference samples.

Key Insights and Results

The Contact Angle Fallacy

A common industrial practice is to use contact angle measurements to calculate surface energy, assuming that higher surface energy (lower contact angle) correlates with better bonding and durability.

Measurement of the contact angle (θ) of a de-ionised water drop to determine surface energy.

As shown in Figure 2, the researchers measured the contact angle of de-ionized water on treated surfaces. While treatments like Pyrosil and Argon plasma significantly increased surface energy, this did not consistently translate to improved durability. In fact, high surface energy can sometimes attract water molecules more aggressively, accelerating interfacial degradation. The study found no direct linear relationship between contact angle and joint durability, challenging its use as a primary quality assurance metric.

The Role of Corrosion Protection

The most effective treatments were those that provided a stable, moisture-resistant barrier rather than just high initial adhesion.

  • Laser Treatment: For aluminum, laser cleaning proved to be the "gold standard." By dissolving grain boundaries and creating a stable oxide layer, it produced bonds that, even after aging, retained 110.7% of their original strength.
  • DELO-SACO: This silicate coating treatment provided excellent aging resistance across most configurations. For example, epoxy-steel joints treated with DELO-SACO retained 69.9% of their strength, a massive improvement over standard grit-blasted steel, which retained only 16.7%.

Statistical analysis (ANOVA) confirmed that the interaction between the adhesive type and the specific surface treatment is critical (p-value = 0.0003). This suggests that surface treatments must be tailored to the specific chemistry of the adhesive used.

Conclusion

This research establishes that surface energy is not a definitive predictor of adhesive joint durability in humid environments. Instead, the ability of a pretreatment to provide corrosion protection at the interface is the primary driver of long-term performance. While laser treatment and specialized silicate coatings like DELO-SACO show great promise, the selection of a surface treatment must be carefully matched to both the substrate and the adhesive chemistry. Future research should explore the combined effects of cyclic mechanical loading and environmental aging to better replicate real-world service conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Industries such as aerospace are very interested in the use of structural adhesives as a joining technique. Compared to riveting, they offer better stress distribution, eliminating stress peaks which can be quite problematic with thin sheet materials. The ability to bond different materials allows for a wider range of material combinations that result in weight reduction. Aluminium and other metals are popular in the aerospace industry, but their reactivity to water molecules compromises the bond strength. This presents problems for manufacturers in predicting and monitoring service life. This study addresses degradation at the interface and the importance of proper surface treatment. Two different adhesive types (epoxy and methylacrylate) and adherent materials (AW 5754 H111 and AISI 1.4301) result in four different sample configurations. Several pretreatments are applied, all using different mechanisms to improve adhesion Drozdziel2022 \cite{Ebnesajjad2015} Marques2020. After surface treatment, the contact angle with de-ionised water is measured, which is directly related to surface energy \cite{Ebnesajjad20151}. The samples are tested for residual lap shear strength after being subjected to an ageing trajectory for one week. Statistical analysis is used to establish a relationship between surface energy and residual lap shear strength. The importance of surface treatment is established, but there is no direct relationship between contact angle and joint durability. Corrosion protection appears to be important, and the adherent material and adhesive type determine the optimum surface treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vervaeke2024experimental,
  author = {R. Vervaeke and Josef Weiland and Frank Buysschaert and Stijn Debruyne and Dirk Vandepitte and Alexander Schiebahn and David Moens},
  title = {{Experimental assessment of the effect of surfacecondition on aged adhesive joint performance}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4227420/v1},
}
Figure