Digital learning experience of engineering students in the pandemic

Di Wang, Yiduo Wang, Zhizhuo SuJournal of PGR Pedagogic Practice 2022 · DOI

Abstract

During the unprecedented world crisis of COVID-19, traditional offline courses were forced to be delivered online. Most students struggled with this change of delivery approach due to difficulties in accessing online resources, overwhelming and independent work, communication and concentration, isolation and longlines issues in online learning. Therefore, providing a positive digital learning experience for students was an important concern in UK Higher Education. Graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) are an indispensable part of the teaching community at the University of Warwick to deliver modules and facilitate WMG engineering students’ learning. Owing to the dual identity of student and teaching staff, doctoral researchers have a unique perspective in investigating students' digital learning experiences. As students, doctoral researchers empathise with the affective impact and physical constraints of online learning that hinder the student experience and learning. And as tutors, doctoral researchers recognise the pedagogical strategies that the digital tools enable, such as peer learning or reflection. This paper provides a reflective evaluation of how effective digital tools, and their uses are supporting the constructive alignment of learning while benefiting the student experience, such as Vevox, Padlet, and Microsoft Teams. In sharing a reflexive account of experiences with digital tools for learning and teaching, guidance is provided on how students’ digital learning experiences can be improved.

Introduction

The sudden pivot to fully online learning during the pandemic was more than a technical hurdle; it represented a pedagogical crisis. Engineering students, particularly those within the Warwick Manufacturing Group (WMG), faced significant challenges including isolation, information overload, and the complexities of digital communication. While universities provided essential tools like Moodle and Microsoft Teams, a disconnect often existed between the provision of these tools and the actual student experience.

Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) occupy a unique "dual identity" that bridges this gap. As doctoral researchers, they are "peer-like" enough for students to share their honest struggles, yet they possess the institutional authority to implement meaningful changes. This paper utilizes a reflective evaluation of teaching practices within the "Study, Professional & Analytical Skills" (SPA) module, involving over 1,200 postgraduate students, to identify friction points and propose pedagogical solutions.

Challenges in Digital Learning

Through the lens of the Seven Elements of Digital Literacy, the authors identified several critical barriers to effective online learning. These challenges were not merely technical but impacted the students' ability to engage with the curriculum effectively.

Common challenges identified in digital learning platforms.

Key friction points included:

  • Moodle Navigation: Students often struggled with "information gravity," finding it difficult to navigate through 36 sessions of content to find specific materials.
  • Network Latency: Connectivity issues in Microsoft Teams created barriers to inclusivity, often leading to "Zoom fatigue" and disengagement.
  • Software Unfamiliarity: Interactive tools like Vevox and Padlet, while pedagogically useful, initially presented a high barrier to entry for students unfamiliar with the software.
  • Device Diversity: The variety of hardware used by students—from high-end laptops to small-screen mobile phones—created inconsistent visual experiences.

Strategies for Improvement

To mitigate these issues, the GTAs implemented a series of reflective best practices designed to improve both ICT literacy and broader digital scholarship.

Implemented strategies to mitigate digital learning barriers.

For Moodle, the team developed a Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) list and an A-Z topic index, allowing students to bypass complex searches. To address network latency, they prioritized audio stability by advising students to turn off cameras and conducted pre-session connectivity tests. Software unfamiliarity was tackled through low-stakes icebreaker activities that encouraged participation in a safe environment. Finally, all teaching materials were cross-checked on multiple mobile devices to ensure that fonts, colors, and typesetting remained accessible regardless of screen size.

Conclusion and Future Work

The distinction between ICT literacy (knowing how to use a tool) and digital literacy (knowing how to evaluate and integrate information) is vital. While students may be technically proficient, they often require guidance in navigating the ethical and analytical complexities of digital information.

Future efforts will focus on moving from reactive troubleshooting to proactive education. The authors plan to design Digital Literacy Workshops for master’s students, focusing on high-level skills such as the assessment and ethical implementation of digital information, while collaborating with other GTAs to share these lessons across the university.

Summary updated

Abstract

During the unprecedented world crisis of COVID-19, traditional offline courses were forced to be delivered online. Most students struggled with this change of delivery approach due to difficulties in accessing online resources, overwhelming and independent work, communication and concentration, isolation and longlines issues in online learning. Therefore, providing a positive digital learning experience for students was an important concern in UK Higher Education. Graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) are an indispensable part of the teaching community at the University of Warwick to deliver modules and facilitate WMG engineering students’ learning. Owing to the dual identity of student and teaching staff, doctoral researchers have a unique perspective in investigating students' digital learning experiences. As students, doctoral researchers empathise with the affective impact and physical constraints of online learning that hinder the student experience and learning. And as tutors, doctoral researchers recognise the pedagogical strategies that the digital tools enable, such as peer learning or reflection. This paper provides a reflective evaluation of how effective digital tools, and their uses are supporting the constructive alignment of learning while benefiting the student experience, such as Vevox, Padlet, and Microsoft Teams. In sharing a reflexive account of experiences with digital tools for learning and teaching, guidance is provided on how students’ digital learning experiences can be improved.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022digital,
  author = {Di Wang and Yiduo Wang and Zhizhuo Su},
  title = {{Digital learning experience of engineering students in the pandemic}},
  journal = {Journal of PGR Pedagogic Practice},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.31273/jppp.vol2.2022.1232},
}
Figure