Editorial: Digital learning innovations in education in response to the COVID-19 pandemic

Lucas Kohnke, Mark B. Ulla, Haoran XieFrontiers in Education 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Since the emergence of COVID-19 in 2020, educational institutions worldwide have undergone a massive shift toward online and synchronous learning. This editorial synthesizes research from a special issue of Frontiers in Education, exploring the transition from "emergency remote teaching" to sustainable digital innovation. It highlights the pedagogical shifts, technological advancements, and socio-emotional challenges encountered by educators and students globally.

From Emergency Response to Sustainable Innovation

The pandemic acted as a catalyst, forcing educators to venture outside their comfort zones and adopt new digital tools. Research by Ulla and colleagues emphasizes that hybrid teaching—distinct from blended or remote teaching—is here to stay. During this transition, educators have integrated advanced technologies like Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR). For instance, Batool found that AR applications improved student attitudes and confidence, while Thuận et al. investigated the use of 3D technology in professional sports training in Vietnam. However, the latter study also noted that the forced transition led to significant burnout and exhaustion among trainers who were previously inexperienced with online delivery.

Global Perspectives on Performance and Equity

The effectiveness of digital learning is often context-dependent. In Israel, Elalouf et al. observed that while student satisfaction was high in both modes, online learners performed better on written exams, whereas face-to-face learners excelled in oral examinations.

Crucially, the pandemic exposed deep-seated inequities. Studies in Thailand (Poungjinda & Pathak) and Indonesia (Turana et al.) revealed that academic success was closely tied to the availability of high-speed internet, laptops, and quiet study spaces. This "digital divide" remains a primary hurdle for the sustainability of online education, as students without these resources face significant mental and academic challenges.

Psychological Support and Student Engagement

Maintaining student motivation in a virtual environment requires innovative pedagogical strategies. Har utilized the game-based system BadaBoom! to increase engagement among students in Hong Kong, while Petousi et al. used interactive storytelling to promote historical empathy.

Beyond engagement, the psychological well-being of students has become a focal point. Carthy et al. demonstrated the efficacy of a five-week online Emotional Intelligence (EI) coaching program in Ireland, which helped students manage stress and improved their academic success. Conversely, research in Vietnam by Bui et al. found that prolonged online learning and privacy concerns contributed to academic burnout, highlighting the need for robust community support structures.

Data Analytics and Course Optimization

To improve digital learning, educators are increasingly turning to data. While Jones (UK) cautions that simple metrics like page clicks are insufficient to determine performance, Foung and Chen (Hong Kong) showed that "big data" analytics involving thousands of students can provide deep insights into course design and skill development. In the United States, Guskaroska et al. proposed designing student-friendly environments by increasing communication channels and reducing unnecessary tasks, which significantly improved time-management skills and course efficiency.

Conclusion

The insights gained from this global shift will help educators respond more effectively to future disruptions. By focusing on equity, emotional intelligence, and data-driven course design, the educational community can move forward with greater certainty, maximizing digital opportunities to provide a high-quality, resilient learning experience for all students.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the emergence of COVID-19 in 2020, education institutions worldwide have moved their teaching and learning programmes online and used synchronous online conferencing systems (e.g. Zoom, Microsoft Teams, Google Meet). This sudden shift in learning mode required teachers to update their pedagogical beliefs and attitudes towards technology (Gao & Cui, 2022), overcome contextual challenges (Jelińska & Paradowski, 2021) and leverage digital innovations to maximise student success (Kohnke, 2022a,b). Teachers initially found themselves unprepared and ill-equipped to cope with the daunting transition to online, blended and HyFlex learning (Moorhouse & Kohnke, 2021a;Moorhouse & Kohnke, 2021b). They had to venture outside their comfort zones and explore alternative ways to educate their students (Adedoyin & Soyka, 2020;Kohnke & Jarvis, 2021).In our call for papers for this special issue on Digital Learning Innovations in Education in Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic, we set out to explore 'innovations that have been made, challenges that have been conquered and practices that are worth keeping as educators move from emergency to sustainability'. Our call was answered by authors whose articles add to the burgeoning literature on digital education in the wake of the pandemic. Notably, this special issue sheds light on how educators from various fields (e.g. English, medicine, physical education) served students when face-to-face teaching and learning were impossible. Ulla and colleagues discuss how hybrid teaching methodology differs from blended, online and remote teaching by analysing the practices of teachers from Thailand. They argue that hybrid education is here to stay; during the transition to post-COVID-19 teaching and learning, we should implement the best practices learnt during the pandemic. This could include, for example, using augmented reality (AR) to supplement face-to-face learning. Batool found that the use of an AR applications increased students' confidence and improved their attitudes toward learning. Similarly, Thuận et al. investigated the use of new technologies such as virtual reality (VR) and 3D technology in fully online and blended courses in the context of professional sports training. They found that most sports trainers in Vietnam had rarely taught online before the pandemic. Therefore, many of them experienced burnout, exhaustion and low professional efficacy when forced to do so. Generally, the transition to online learning has increased the innovative teaching practices in various fields of education, as illustrated by Deng and colleagues.When implementing technology, it is vital to consider the Technology Acceptance Model (see Davis, 1989) and examine usefulness, ease of use and intentions, as in a study performed by Tukiran et al. at an Indonesian university. In addition, we should explore the skills that are best suited to online and face-to-face learning, respectively. Elalouf et al. found that online and face-to-face learners in Israel were equally satisfied with their lecturers' performance. However, online learners performed better on written examinations and face-to-face learners performed better on oral examinations. It is also important to consider teachers' readiness for online teaching, as discussed by Antwi-Boampong, who tested and validated a faculty blended learning adoption model. Poungjinda and Pathak researched law students at a local Thai university. They found that the availability of online resources, fast bandwidth and laptops had a significant impact on student academic success. This raises essential questions about equity in online learning as not all students have access to high-speed internet, laptops and a quiet space to study. In their study on medical schools in Indonesia, Turana and colleagues discussed the forced transition to online learning and the mental challenges it presented for students with inadequate access to the internet and laptops. Similarly, Bui et al. examined physical and psychological academic burnout at a Vietnamese university, finding that privacy concerns, prolonged online learning and a lack of community support contributed significantly to academic burnout among learners. The results of these studies imply that we should consider how to develop students' emotional intelligence (EI) and thus support their learning. Carthy et al. examined the efficacy and impact of a 5-week online EI coaching programme for Irish university students. The findings suggested that the participants' EI increased, enabling them to manage stress more effectively and increasing their academic success.Engaging and motivating students are also essential elements of effective online teaching. Har used the game-based student-response system BadaBoom! to help students at a Hong Kong university to overcome their writing difficulties while participating in online learning and increase their engagement with the course content. Another way to engage students is to change the course delivery format. In a history education course, Petousi et al. promoted historical empathy through collaborative, interactive storytelling set in the ancient Athenian agora and using decision/branching for dialogues.But when we incorporate digital technology in teaching, we must analyse the data to understand how students use it and what can be improved. Jones, in a UK-based study, examined the relationship between undergraduate student performance, engagement and attendance in Canva (a learning management system). He warns that it is too simplistic to use page clicks, views and video duration to determine students' performance in an online learning environment. However, in a 'big data' study involving 4,500 students at a Hong Kong university, Foung and Chen, found that analytics can provide insight into course design, language use and skills in need of improvement. Guskaroska et al. proposed a way to design student-friendly online learning environments based on their study of a composition course in the United States. Incorporating optional synchronous video sessions, multiplying communication channels and reducing unnecessary tasks increased schedule flexibility, improved time-management skills and made course delivery more efficient.Pandemics come and go. The insights gained in this special issue will help educators respond promptly should another pandemic befall us and use digital technology to provide students with the best possible educational experience. We will be able to move forward with greater certainty about how we can maximise digital learning opportunities even if we cannot engage in face-to-face teaching and learning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kohnke2023editorial,
  author = {Lucas Kohnke and Mark B. Ulla and Haoran Xie},
  title = {{Editorial: Digital learning innovations in education in response to the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Education},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feduc.2023.1165417},
}
Figure