Enhancing Postgraduate Taught Students’ Engagement

Yiduo Wang, Zhizhuo Su, Di WangJournal of PGR Pedagogic Practice 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Postgraduate Taught Students are a significant part of our student community. To enhance their learning experience and facilitate their learning more efficiently, a storytelling pedagogical approach conducted by postgraduate teaching assistants (GTAs) could be a way to accelerate this process. Postgraduate researchers (PGRs) are important members of the Higher Education teaching community as they provide a unique perspective, from both students and teaching staff. Some of them have a fresh memory of their learning experiences and thus could better understand the students’ concerns. This paper reports the experience of PGRs and GTAs regarding sharing personal stories to help students understand and overcome their challenges in academic writing. The storytelling pedagogy in practice indicates a significant effect in supporting not only academic study but also students’ engagement and reflection. The usage of storytelling pedagogy also aids in the concept explanation of technical elements in texts by offering succinct and tangible instances, which assist students in developing their critical thinking skills and individualised understanding of factual material.

Introduction

Postgraduate Taught (PGT) students, particularly those enrolled in intensive master's programs, often face a steep learning curve regarding academic writing and research ethics. For many international students, these topics can feel ponderous and abstract, often perceived as bureaucratic hurdles rather than essential research foundations. Traditional lecture-style delivery frequently fails to foster the deep engagement necessary to internalize the gravity of ethical breaches or the nuances of academic standards.

Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) at the University of Warwick identified a need for a pedagogical bridge to make these technical requirements feel immediate and "real." By leveraging their "dual identity" as both active researchers (PhDs) and teachers, GTAs can transform abstract concepts into relatable, high-stakes narratives.

Methodology: The Storytelling Framework

The pedagogical approach is rooted in Constructivism, the theory that learners build knowledge by reconciling new information with existing experiences. To operationalize this, the authors implemented McKillop’s (2005) storytelling model within a module serving over 1,000 master's students.

The method involves two primary phases: narrative delivery and facilitated response. GTAs share a "lived experience" story—such as a mishap during an interview or an ethical dilemma regarding participant incentives—and then guide students through four specific response types to deepen their reflection.

The McKillop (2005) storytelling model used to facilitate student responses.

As illustrated in the model above, students engage with the initial story through:

  • Viewpoint: Forming an opinion on the characters' actions.
  • Wonder if: Exploring alternative outcomes and "what-if" scenarios.
  • Similar story: Relating the narrative to their own past experiences.
  • What learnt: Reflecting on the takeaway for their own future research.

Key Insights and Results

The GTA Advantage

GTAs occupy a unique "near-peer" space. Because they are currently active researchers, their memories of learning these concepts are fresh. This makes their stories feel authentic and less prescriptive than those of senior faculty, helping to "close the relationship" between teacher and student.

Stories as Cognitive Anchors

Narratives serve as powerful cognitive anchors because they are wrapped in emotion. A story about a student nearly failing a dissertation due to an ethical oversight is significantly more memorable than a slide listing informed consent guidelines. This approach moves the curriculum from dry factual material to an individualized understanding.

Impact on Engagement and Critical Thinking

The implementation of this pedagogy resulted in several qualitative improvements:

  • Increased Engagement: Personal scenarios led to "heated" and active seminar discussions, moving beyond passive participation.
  • Improved Critical Thinking: Students demonstrated the ability to explore the complexity of research design through "wonder if" responses, grappling with nuances like verbal versus written consent.
  • Strategy Adjustment: In the "what learnt" phase, students reported adjusting their own research strategies, such as rethinking participant recruitment methods after hearing about the risks of financial incentives.

Limitations and Future Directions

While effective, storytelling pedagogy presents specific challenges. Stories are inherently subjective, requiring GTAs to work diligently to present them neutrally to allow for independent student interpretation. Furthermore, the approach demands significant preparation overhead; teachers must be ready to adapt the narrative based on real-time student reactions.

Ethical boundaries are also paramount. Teachers must ensure they do not violate the confidentiality of past colleagues or students while maintaining a "safe space" for current students to share their own mistakes. Future work should focus on training the wider PGR community to use storytelling as a formal teaching strategy, potentially developing standardized frameworks for story-based seminars in STEM fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Postgraduate Taught Students are a significant part of our student community. To enhance their learning experience and facilitate their learning more efficiently, a storytelling pedagogical approach conducted by postgraduate teaching assistants (GTAs) could be a way to accelerate this process. Postgraduate researchers (PGRs) are important members of the Higher Education teaching community as they provide a unique perspective, from both students and teaching staff. Some of them have a fresh memory of their learning experiences and thus could better understand the students’ concerns. This paper reports the experience of PGRs and GTAs regarding sharing personal stories to help students understand and overcome their challenges in academic writing. The storytelling pedagogy in practice indicates a significant effect in supporting not only academic study but also students’ engagement and reflection. The usage of storytelling pedagogy also aids in the concept explanation of technical elements in texts by offering succinct and tangible instances, which assist students in developing their critical thinking skills and individualised understanding of factual material.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022enhancing,
  author = {Yiduo Wang and Zhizhuo Su and Di Wang},
  title = {{Enhancing Postgraduate Taught Students’ Engagement}},
  journal = {Journal of PGR Pedagogic Practice},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.31273/jppp.vol2.2022.1230},
}
Figure