DiffDec: Structure-Aware Scaffold Decoration with an End-to-End Diffusion Model

Junjie Xie, Sheng Chen, Jinping Lei, Yuedong Yang

TL;DR

This paper introduces DiffDec, a novel end-to-end diffusion model for molecular scaffold decoration that leverages 3D protein pocket information. DiffDec generates structure-aware R-groups, leading to molecules with improved binding affinities and interactions compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Drug discovery often involves optimizing existing molecules by decorating their core structures (scaffolds) with various chemical groups (R-groups). While deep generative models have shown promise in this area, they often rely on ligand information and don't fully utilize the 3D structure of the target protein's binding pocket. This limits their ability to design molecules that precisely fit and interact with the target, potentially leading to suboptimal drug candidates. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that explicitly incorporates 3D protein pocket information into the R-group generation process.

Methods

DiffDec employs a modified diffusion technique, building upon the denoising diffusion probabilistic model (DDPM) framework. The core idea is to iteratively add noise to R-group data and then train a neural network to reverse this process, effectively learning to generate R-groups conditioned on the scaffold and the 3D protein pocket. A key innovation is the "fake atom mechanism," which allows for the end-to-end generation of R-groups of varying sizes without needing a separate module to predict their size. The model uses an E(3)-equivariant graph neural network (EGNN) for processing molecular structures, ensuring that the generated R-groups respect the 3D geometric and physical properties of the protein pocket.

Datasets

The study utilizes two newly constructed 3D scaffold decoration datasets derived from the CrossDocked dataset. These datasets are based on three-dimensional protein-ligand complex structures and are split into single R-group and multi R-group decoration tasks. The training set consists of 100,000 protein-ligand pairs, and the test set comprises 100 complexes, with a split based on 30% protein sequence identity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure-Aware Decoration: Explicitly conditioning R-group generation on the 3D protein pocket is crucial for designing molecules with better binding.
  • End-to-End Size Generation: The "fake atom" approach elegantly handles R-groups of different sizes within a single generative framework, simplifying the process.
  • Anchor Identification: DiffDec can automatically identify "growth anchors" on the scaffold for R-group attachment, making it applicable even when these attachment points aren't pre-defined.
  • Improved Binding Interactions: The generated R-groups not only fit the pocket but also form more favorable interactions, leading to higher binding affinities.

Key Results

DiffDec demonstrated state-of-the-art performance across various metrics:

  • Single R-group decoration: Achieved a recovery rate of 69.67% (vs. 37.33% for the best baseline) and a similarity of 0.86.
  • Multi R-group decoration: Achieved a recovery rate of 45.34% (vs. 26.85% for the best baseline) and a similarity of 0.80.
  • Binding Affinity: Generated molecules showed significantly better average docking scores (e.g., -8.25 kcal/mol for DiffDec vs. -8.10 kcal/mol for LibINVENT in single R-group tasks) and a higher percentage of molecules with improved affinity compared to reference ligands.
  • Pocket Interaction: DiffDec generated R-groups with fewer clashes with the protein pocket, indicating better geometric complementarity.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two main limitations:

  1. Bond Inference: The current output of DiffDec is a 3D atomic point cloud, and covalent bonds are inferred using an external tool (OpenBabel). The accuracy of this bond inference step impacts the overall validity and recovery rates. Optimizing this bond generation process is a direction for future work.
  2. Computational Intensity: The step-by-step denoising process in diffusion models is computationally intensive, limiting sampling efficiency. The authors suggest combining distributed CPU and GPU computations to address this.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In molecular optimization, one popular way is R-groups decoration on molecular scaffolds, and many efforts have been put to generate R-groups based on deep generative models. However, these methods mostly use information of known binding ligands, without fully utilizing target structure information. In this study, we proposed a new method, DiffDec, to involve three-dimensional pocket constraints by a modified diffusion technique for optimizing molecules through molecular scaffold decoration. For an end-to-end generation of R-groups with different sizes, we designed a novel fake atom mechanism. DiffDec was shown able to generate structure-aware R-groups, and simultaneously generate multiple R-groups for one scaffold on different growth anchors. The growth anchors could be provided by users or automatically determined by our model. DiffDec achieved R-group recovery rates of 69.67% and 45.34% in the single and multiple R-group decoration tasks, respectively, and these values were significantly higher than competing methods (37.33% and 26.85%). According to the molecular docking study, our decorated molecules obtained better average binding affinity than baseline methods. The docking pose analysis revealed that DiffDec could decorate scaffolds with R-groups that exhibited improved binding affinities and more favourable interactions with the pocket. These results demonstrated the potential and applicability of DiffDec in real-world scaffold decoration for molecular optimization.
BibTeX
@article{xie2024diffdec,
  author = {Junjie Xie and Sheng Chen and Jinping Lei and Yuedong Yang},
  title = {{DiffDec: Structure-Aware Scaffold Decoration with an End-to-End Diffusion Model}},
  journal = {Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jcim.3c01466},
}

Loading related content...

Figure