Developing the mathematics model textbook based on storytelling with real-life context - Focusing on the coordinate geometry contents -

Yujung Kim, Jisun Kim, Sang Eui Park, Kyoo-Hong Park, Jaesung LeeCommunications 2013 · DOI

Abstract

This study explores the development of a model mathematics textbook for high school coordinate geometry that utilizes storytelling and real-life contexts. By framing mathematical concepts within a narrative conflict between a teacher and a villain, the researchers aimed to improve student engagement and their perception of mathematical utility. The results from a pilot study indicate that while the narrative approach significantly improved students' understanding of the practical applications of geometry, the fictional elements required refinement to better suit the maturity level of high school students.

Introduction

Mathematics education, particularly in South Korea, is often criticized for its heavy emphasis on abstract logic and memorization, which frequently leads to "math phobia." Students often fail to see the connection between complex formulas and real-world applications. To address this, researchers developed a textbook unit for "Equations of Figures" (coordinate geometry) based on the principles of Realistic Mathematics Education (RME), weaving mathematical discovery into a cohesive narrative.

Methodology and Narrative Design

The model textbook replaces traditional lecture-based proofs with a story featuring "Professor Descartes" and two students, Abel and Galois. They must solve mathematical challenges to thwart a villain named "X-Man." This narrative structure was used to introduce key concepts through specific "missions."

Lesson 1.1: Using local geography to teach the Pythagorean theorem and coordinate utility.

As shown in the lesson outlines, the curriculum was divided into specific real-life scenarios:

  1. Maps and Distance: Students calculated the shortest path between Olympic Park Station and Mongchontoseong Station, using the Pythagorean theorem to find the distance between two points on a coordinate plane.
  2. Bomb Finding and Division Points: The narrative of locating hidden bombs was used to teach the concepts of internal and external division points.
Lesson 1.2: Bomb-finding activities for internal and external division points.
  1. Physical Tools: Abstract concepts were mapped to physical objects, such as using a set square (triangle ruler) to visualize slopes and derive the equations of lines. This helped students transition from a physical tool they had used since childhood to the abstract formula $y - y_1 = m(x - x_1)$.

Key Findings

The textbook was tested with 25 students in an after-school program in Seoul. The pilot study revealed several significant insights:

  • Shift in Utility Perception: The most notable result was the change in how students viewed the subject. Before the study, 58.8% of students agreed that coordinate geometry is useful in real life; after the storytelling lessons, this figure jumped to 86.5%.
  • Improved Conceptual Clarity: Understanding of how to derive the equation of a line using a slope and a point rose from 29.4% to 58.8% in the "strongly agree" category.
  • The "Cringe" Factor: While engagement was high, many high school students found the hero-vs-villain plot somewhat childish. This suggests that for older learners, "real-life context" should focus more on authentic professional data (e.g., GPS, architecture) rather than fictionalized adventures.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The storytelling approach successfully transformed abstract proofs into active discovery missions, making mathematical formulas feel intuitive rather than arbitrary. However, the researchers noted that creating a narrative that is both mathematically rigorous and age-appropriate is a significant challenge. Future work should focus on aligning these storytelling methods with standardized assessments and involving professional writers to create more sophisticated, realistic plots that resonate with high school students.

Summary updated

Abstract

본 연구는 실생활과 연계된 소재를 사용한 스토리텔링 수학 교과서의 도형의 방정식 단원 개발 사례에 대한 논의를 목적으로 한다. 이를 위하여 먼저 실생활 연계형 스토리텔링 교과서의 의미를 규정하고, 개발된 스토리의 개요와 차시별 개발 사례를 논의한다. 본 연구에서는 실생활 연계형 스토리텔링 교과서를 학생들의 현실 또는 실생활과 연관이 있는 상황을 스토리의 소재로 사용하여 수학적 개념들을 탐구하고 정리하는 활동들로 구성된 교과서로 정의한다. 개발된 스토리텔링 기하 교과서는 지도와 삼각자라는 실생활 소재를 이용하였는데, 지도는 좌표평면 단원 구성에, 삼각자는 직선의 방정식 단원 구성에 사용되었다. 스토리의 흥미를 높이기 위해 선생님과 두 학생, 그리고 악당의 대결구도로 이야기를 전개했다. 개발된 모델 교과서의 타당성을 검증하기 위해 적용 실험을 시행하였다. 연구에 참여한 서울 시내의 한 자율형 사립 고등학교 학생 25명 중 17명이 사전과 사후 설문 조사에 응답하였다. 학생들의 답변은 스토리텔링을 접목시킨 기하 교과서가 학습에 도움이 되었고, 지도와 삼각자와 같은 실생활 도구가 관련된 수학 개념의 이해를 도왔지만, 개발된 스토리텔링 교과서의 스토리는 개선될 필요가 있음을 시사하였다. The purpose of this study was to discuss the example that developed geometry model textbook based on storytelling using real-life context. To achieve this purpose, we first elaborated the meaning of the textbook based on storytelling with real-life context, and then we discussed the outline of the story and the summary of each lesson. This study defined the storytelling textbook with real-life context as the textbook consisting of activities that explored and organized mathematical concepts by using real-life situations as materials of stories. The geometry textbook we developed employed two real-life materials, a map and a set square: we used a map for the coordinate geometry and a set square for the equation of a line. To attract students' interest, we introduced confrontation between a teacher and two students and a villain. We implemented experimentation with the textbook based on storytelling in order to verify its validity. The participants were 25 students that were enrolled in a high school in Seoul. Among them, 17 participants were surveyed. Students' answers from the survey questionnaire suggested that the geometry textbook we developed based on storytelling helped them learn mathematics and that the instruments such as a map and a set square helped them understand mathematical concepts. However, their opinion implied that the story of the textbook needed to be improved so that the story reflected more realistic contexts that were familiar with students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2013developing,
  author = {Yujung Kim and Jisun Kim and Sang Eui Park and Kyoo-Hong Park and Jaesung Lee},
  title = {{Developing the mathematics model textbook based on storytelling with real-life context - Focusing on the coordinate geometry contents -}},
  booktitle = {Communications},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.7468/jksmee.2013.27.3.179},
}
Figure