Developing a Decolonial Mindset for Indigenising Computing Education (CE)

J. Jenny Li, Yin Paradies, Trina Myers, Robin Doss, Armita Zarnegar, Jack Reis

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Decolonial Mindset Stack (DMS), a seven-layer conceptual framework designed to help computing educators move beyond tokenistic diversity efforts. By integrating Indigenous methodologies with critical pedagogy, the DMS provides a structured pathway to transform curricula and pedagogies, ultimately aiming for Indigenous sovereignty in digital spaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite various diversity initiatives, First Peoples remain profoundly underrepresented in computing education (CE). In Australia, for instance, First Nations students make up only 1.8% of higher education students, with even lower participation in STEM.

The authors argue that this isn't just a "pipeline" problem; it is a systemic issue rooted in coloniality. Current computing curricula often prioritize Western computational paradigms (like algorithmic thinking) while sidelining Indigenous epistemologies that value relationality and context. Furthermore, many existing "indigenisation" efforts are superficial—adding a single module without addressing the underlying Eurocentric structures. The paper seeks to provide educators with a tool to shift their mindsets from mere awareness to active support for Indigenous-led technological futures.

Methods

The paper is a position paper that synthesizes two primary theoretical foundations into a new framework:

  1. Freirean Critical Pedagogy: Focusing on conscientisation (developing critical awareness of social realities) and praxis (the cycle of reflection and action).
  2. Indigenous Methodologies: Incorporating concepts like Relationality (interconnectedness), Sovereignty (control over knowledge/data), Two-Eyed Seeing (balancing Indigenous and Western perspectives), and the 8 Ways of Learning (an Aboriginal Australian pedagogical framework).

The authors use these to build the Decolonial Mindset Stack (DMS). Much like the OSI model in networking, the DMS is a layered approach where each stage represents a shift in mindset and a corresponding "relational lens" (e.g., moving from "About Me" to "By Us").

Datasets

As this is a conceptual position paper introducing a framework, it does not utilize a traditional empirical dataset for training or evaluation. However, it cites various demographic statistics from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), Universities Australia, and US-based educational reports to establish the context of underrepresentation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Stack" Metaphor: By framing decolonization as a "stack," the authors speak the language of computing. It suggests that educators cannot simply jump to the "top layer" (Indigenous-led systems) without first building the foundational layers of recognition and reflection.
  • Relational Lenses: Each layer is paired with a lens that defines the educator's relationship with Indigenous communities:
  • Recognition (About Me): Acknowledging personal and historical biases.
  • Reflection (Of Us): Examining common humanity and institutional complicity.
  • Reframing (With Us): Dismantling colonial logic in the syllabus.
  • Reembedding (For Us): Co-creating content that serves community needs.
  • Reciprocity (Between Us): Establishing long-term, ethical partnerships.
  • Reclamation (Like Us): Respectfully adopting Indigenous ways of knowing.
  • Resurgence (By Us): Supporting Indigenous-led and governed digital infrastructures.
  • Two-Eyed Seeing: A core insight is that indigenising CE isn't about replacing Western science, but about using the strengths of both Indigenous and Western knowledge systems "for the benefit of all" without creating a hierarchy.
  • Beyond Tokenism: The paper highlights that "syllabus surgery" (critically reviewing code for bias) and "design jams" with Indigenous partners are more effective than simply adding a "cultural" slide to a lecture.

Key Results

The primary result is the DMS framework itself. While the paper does not present quantitative experimental data, it provides:

  • A Roadmap for Educators: A clear, non-linear path for transforming a computing curriculum.
  • Stakeholder Benefit Mapping: A qualitative analysis (Figure 2) showing how indigenisation benefits not just students, but also universities (reputation), industry (diverse talent), and government (social justice).
  • Practical Activities: The paper suggests concrete actions for each layer, such as "Yarning Circles" for reflection and "on-country learning modules" for reembedding knowledge.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conceptual Nature: The authors acknowledge that the paper is currently theoretical. The next step is empirical validation through pilot projects in specific CE departments to measure impact on student engagement and community relationships.
  • Institutional Barriers: The paper notes that "institutional inertia" and underfunding are significant risks. Even a willing educator may be stymied by a university system that values symbolic policy over structural change.
  • Local Adaptation: While developed with reference to First Peoples in Australia, the authors stress that the DMS must be adapted to the specific cultural and historical contexts of the local Indigenous communities where it is applied. It is not a "one-size-fits-all" checklist.

Summary updated

Abstract

The underrepresentation of First Peoples in computing education reflects colonial legacies embedded in curricula, pedagogies, and digital infrastructures. This paper introduces the \textbf{Decolonial Mindset Stack (DMS)}, a seven-layer framework for educator transformation: \textbf{Recognition, Reflection, Reframing, Reembedding, Reciprocity, Reclamation}, and \textbf{Resurgence}. Grounded in Freirean critical pedagogy and Indigenous methodologies, the DMS aligns with relational lenses of ``About Me,'' ``Between Us,'' and ``By Us.'' It fosters self-reflexivity, relational accountability, and Indigenous sovereignty in computing education, reframing underrepresentation as systemic exclusion. The DMS provides both theoretical grounding and pathways for practice, positioning indigenisation not as an endpoint but as a sustained ethical commitment to transformative justice and the co-creation of computing education with First Peoples.
BibTeX
@misc{li2025developing,
  author = {J. Jenny Li and Yin Paradies and Trina Myers and Robin Doss and Armita Zarnegar and Jack Reis},
  title = {{Developing a Decolonial Mindset for Indigenising Computing Education (CE)}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2509.18509},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.18509},
}
Figure