Derivation of Newton's law of gravitation based on a fluidic continuum model of vacuum and a sink flow model of particles

Xiaosong WangarXiv 2005 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper presents a mechanical interpretation of gravitational phenomena by modeling the vacuum as a fluidic continuum, termed the $\Omega(0)$ substratum. By representing particles as "sinks" within this fluid, the author derives Newton's inverse-square law of gravitation using the principles of classical hydrodynamics. This approach suggests that gravitational interactions are transmitted through a physical medium and implies that the gravitational constant $G$ and particle masses may be slowly evolving over time.

Introduction

Since the inception of General Relativity, gravity has been understood primarily as the geometric curvature of spacetime. While mathematically robust, this phenomenological description leaves several fundamental questions unanswered, particularly regarding the physical mechanism of force transmission. In "Derivation of Newton's law of gravitation based on a fluidic continuum model of vacuum and a sink flow model of particles," Xiao-Song Wang revisits the concept of a "substratum"—a modern iteration of the classical aether—to provide a mechanical foundation for gravity.

The Fluidic Vacuum and the Sink Flow Model

The core of Wang’s theory lies in two fundamental assumptions:

  1. The $\Omega(0)$ Substratum: The vacuum is not empty space but is filled with an ideal fluid that is inviscid (frictionless), incompressible, and irrotational.
  2. Particles as Sinks: Microscopic particles are modeled as "sinks" in this fluid—points where the $\Omega(0)$ substratum is continuously absorbed.

To bridge the gap between macroscopic particles and fundamental physics, the author introduces the "monad" hypothesis. Monads are elementary sinks that constitute all matter. This hypothesis establishes a linear relationship between a particle's mass and its "sink strength" (the rate at which it consumes the vacuum fluid).

Mathematical Derivation of the Inverse-Square Law

The derivation employs the standard toolkit of classical hydrodynamics. By applying Laplace’s equation ($\nabla^2 \phi = 0$) to the velocity potential of the fluid, the author describes the flow field generated by these sinks. Using the Ostrogradsky-Gauss theorem and Reynolds' transport theorem, the author calculates the forces exerted on these sinks by the surrounding fluid.

In this model, gravity is reinterpreted as a pressure gradient. As particles (sinks) absorb the fluid, they create a velocity field. When two particles are in proximity, the interaction of their respective flow fields creates a pressure imbalance in the $\Omega(0)$ substratum, which pushes the particles toward each other. This pressure-driven attraction mathematically mirrors the Newtonian "pull."

The resulting force equation is derived as: $$F_{21} = -G \frac{m_1 m_2}{r^2} \hat{r}_{21}$$

This derivation holds under the assumption that the gravitational constant $G$ and the masses of the particles change so slowly that they can be treated as constants within human observational timescales.

The Evolution of $G$ and Mass

One of the most striking departures from standard Newtonian physics is the prediction that $G$ and mass are time-dependent. Because particles are modeled as sinks that constantly absorb the vacuum fluid, their mass ($m$) must increase over time. Consequently, the gravitational constant $G$ is defined as a function of the fluid density $\rho$ and the sink strength $q$:

$$G(t) = \frac{\rho q_0^2}{4\pi m_0^2(t)}$$

This suggests that the "constants" of nature may actually be dynamic variables reflecting the evolving state of the universe's fluidic substratum.

Implications and Limitations

The hydrodynamic model offers several intriguing insights:

  • Mechanical Equivalence: The equivalence of inertial and gravitational mass emerges naturally from the fluidic force equations.
  • Universal Damping: The theory predicts a minute "universal damping force" acting on any particle moving through the $\Omega(0)$ substratum, proportional to its velocity and mass-accumulation rate.
  • Field Analogies: The paper derives gravitational field equations ($\nabla \times \mathbf{G} = 0$ and $\nabla \cdot \mathbf{G} = -4\pi G \rho_m$) that are mathematically analogous to Gauss's law, providing a fluid-mechanical basis for classical field theory.

However, the theory faces significant hurdles. The "slow change" assumption regarding $G$ and $m$ must be reconciled with high-precision astronomical data. Furthermore, the physical nature of the $\Omega(0)$ fluid remains undefined, and the model currently focuses on the Newtonian limit, leaving relativistic effects—such as the bending of light—for future investigation.

Conclusion

By applying the principles of continuum mechanics to the vacuum, Wang provides a provocative alternative to the purely geometric interpretation of gravity. While experimental verification of time-varying constants and damping forces remains a challenge for the future, this hydrodynamic approach offers a tangible mechanical medium for gravitational interaction, potentially opening new avenues for unifying classical and quantum perspectives.

Summary updated

Abstract

The main purpose of this paper is to seek a mechanical interpretation of gravitational phenomena. We suppose that the universe may be filled with a kind of fluid which may be called the $Ω(0)$ substratum. Thus, the inverse-square law of gravitation is derived by methods of hydrodynamics based on a sink flow model of particles. The first feature of this theory of gravitation is that the gravitational interactions are transmitted by a kind of fluidic medium. The second feature is the time dependence of gravitational constant $G$ and gravitational mass. Newton's law of gravitation is derived if we introduce an assumption that $G$ and the masses of particles are changing so slowly that they can be treated as constants.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2005derivation,
  author = {Xiaosong Wang},
  title = {{Derivation of Newton's law of gravitation based on a fluidic continuum model of vacuum and a sink flow model of particles}},
  year = {2005},
  eprint = {physics/0506062},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0506062},
}
Figure