ОБ УРАВНЕНИЯХ СТАЦИОНАРНОГО ГРАВИТАЦИОННОГО ПОЛЯ В ПОСТ-НЕРЕЛЯТИВИСТСКОМ ПРИБЛИЖЕНИИ

Alec KoppelProceedings of the Academy of Sciences of the Estonian SSR Physics Mathematics 1976 · DOI

Author: A. Koppel
Originally Published: Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences of the Estonian SSR (1976)

Abstract

This work aims to derive the fundamental equations governing a stationary gravitational field (SG-field) within the post-nonrelativistic approximation. A primary focus is the analysis of these equations in the context of a potential "non-Newtonian" non-relativistic limit. The study is restricted to the field equations themselves; the equations of motion for material objects within such fields are excluded from the current scope.

Introduction

In the study of gravitation, the transition from classical Newtonian mechanics to Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) is often bridged by the "Post-Newtonian" expansion. This method involves adding corrections to Newtonian gravity in powers of $1/c$ (the inverse speed of light). However, theoretical investigations in the mid-20th century suggested the existence of a more obscure regime: the "non-Newtonian non-relativistic limit."

In this 1976 paper, A. Koppel explores whether this limit—where certain relativistic effects like space curvature and frame-dragging persist even as $c \to \infty$—is a physically distinct state or merely a mathematical artifact of the approximation process. By deriving the field equations for stationary gravitational fields in the post-nonrelativistic approximation, Koppel provides a rigorous mathematical framework to evaluate these competing interpretations.

Methodology and Geometric Framework

Koppel employs a formal power series expansion of gravitational field variables in terms of $1/c$. The analysis is strictly limited to stationary fields, where the sources and the resulting field do not fluctuate over time.

The author builds upon the earlier work of Keres, utilizing the energy-momentum tensor of an ideal fluid. The gravitational field is decomposed into two primary components:

  1. A Scalar Potential ($\lambda$): Analogous to the Newtonian potential, defining the energy of a test particle.
  2. A Vector/Vortex Potential ($\sigma$): A relativistic component representing the "swirl" or vortex-like effects of moving matter.

While the equations are formulated within a 3-dimensional Euclidean space ($V_3$), Koppel accounts for the physical reality that the 3-space may be conformally curved depending on the specific potentials involved. This allows the model to capture geometric nuances that standard Newtonian gravity ignores.

Key Insights: The Vortex Potential and Curvature

The most striking feature of Koppel’s derivation is the explicit appearance of the vortex potential $\sigma$. In Newtonian gravity, the field is purely a gradient of a scalar potential (a "pull"). In Koppel’s post-nonrelativistic approximation, the motion of matter generates a vortex component. This is physically analogous to how moving electric charges generate a magnetic field, a phenomenon often referred to in GR as gravitomagnetism.

Furthermore, Koppel demonstrates that if the non-Newtonian potential (denoted as $\psi$) is non-zero, the 3-dimensional space remains intrinsically curved. This contradicts the standard Newtonian assumption of a flat, Euclidean 3-space, suggesting that the non-Newtonian limit retains a "memory" of relativistic geometry.

The "Specific Essence" of the Non-Newtonian Limit

A central question of the paper is whether the non-Newtonian limit is simply a simplified version of the post-Newtonian approximation. Through a rigorous comparison of the governing equations, Koppel proves that they are qualitatively different.

Specifically, he points to the modified Poisson equations for the scalar potential $\lambda$. In the standard post-Newtonian correction, the additional terms are positive. However, in the non-Newtonian limit, the presence of the vortex potential introduces a negative term to the Poisson equation. Koppel shows that attempting to equate these two regimes leads to a mathematical contradiction (Eq. 19 in the original text). This confirms that the non-Newtonian limit possesses its own "specific essence" and represents a unique physical regime rather than a mere approximation of standard theory.

Conclusions and Limitations

Koppel’s work provides a refined set of equations (Eq. 11–14) that describe how density, pressure, and velocity generate gravitational potentials in the post-nonrelativistic regime. By identifying the qualitative differences between the non-Newtonian limit and standard corrections, the paper clarifies the boundaries of the Newtonian framework.

However, the study has notable constraints:

  • Stationarity: It does not account for time-dependent phenomena like gravitational waves.
  • Ideal Fluid: The model assumes no viscosity or heat conduction in the source matter.
  • Dynamics: The paper focuses on the field equations; it does not derive the geodesics (the actual paths objects take) within these fields.

Despite these limitations, Koppel’s derivation remains a significant contribution to our understanding of the mathematical structure of gravity between the classical and relativistic worlds.

Summary updated

Abstract

В данной работе поставлена цель получить основные уравнения, определяющие стационарное гравитационное поле (СГ-поле) в пост-не- релятивистском приближении, и проанализировать их с учетом возможности существования неньютонова нерелятивистского предела ['].При этом изучение уравнений движения материальных объектов в таком поле в наши задачи не входит.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koppel1976,
  author = {Alec Koppel},
  title = {{ОБ УРАВНЕНИЯХ СТАЦИОНАРНОГО ГРАВИТАЦИОННОГО ПОЛЯ В ПОСТ-НЕРЕЛЯТИВИСТСКОМ ПРИБЛИЖЕНИИ}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences of the Estonian SSR Physics Mathematics},
  year = {1976},
  doi = {10.3176/phys.math.1976.2.16},
}
Figure