Decoding functional cell–cell communication events by multi-view graph learning on spatial transcriptomics

Haochen Li, Tianxing Ma, Minsheng Hao, Wenbo Guo, Jin Gu, Lei Wei, Xuegong Zhang

TL;DR

This paper introduces HoloNet, a novel deep learning framework that decodes "functional cell-cell communication events" (FCEs) from spatial transcriptomics data. By integrating ligand-receptor interactions, cell-type spatial distribution, and gene expression, HoloNet can identify which specific communication events drive downstream gene expression changes, offering a more precise understanding of cellular interactions in complex tissues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cells communicate is fundamental to biology, especially in complex environments like tumors. Cell-cell communication (CE) is mediated by ligand-receptor pairs, but not all CEs lead to a specific, observable outcome. The authors define "functional communication events" (FCEs) as those CEs that directly cause a particular downstream gene expression change in a specific microenvironment. Identifying these FCEs is crucial for understanding biological processes and diseases, but it's been challenging due to the complexity of multiple interacting factors and the lack of direct observation. Existing methods often focus on broader aspects of communication (like ligand-target links) but don't pinpoint the specific, functional interactions that drive observed gene expression patterns.

Methods

HoloNet employs a multi-view graph learning approach.

  • Multi-view CE Network Construction: It models cell-cell communications as a network where each "view" represents a specific ligand-receptor pair. Edge weights in these networks are determined by the expression of the ligand in the sender cell, the receptor in the receiver cell, and the physical distance between them.
  • Attention-Based Graph Neural Network (GNN): A GNN is used to learn how these multi-view networks influence target gene expression. An attention mechanism helps weigh the contribution of different ligand-receptor pairs (views) to the overall gene expression.
  • FCE Decoding: The trained GNN model is then interpreted to decompose the target gene expression into a baseline component (determined by cell type) and an expression change component (attributed to CEs). By analyzing the attention weights and model outputs, HoloNet identifies the key ligand-receptor pairs and cell types involved in driving specific gene expression changes.

Datasets

HoloNet was applied to several publicly available spatial transcriptomics datasets:

  • Breast Cancer: Two Visium datasets (one from 10x Genomics, another from Wu et al.).
  • Liver Cancer: One Visium dataset (from Wu et al.).
  • Mouse Hippocampus: One Slideseq-v2 dataset (from Stickels et al.) for validating model stability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Focus on "Functional" Communication: The core innovation is the concept of FCEs, moving beyond general CE detection to identify specific interactions that cause downstream effects. This provides a more mechanistic understanding.
  • Multi-view Network for Complexity: Modeling CEs as a multi-view network, where each view is a ligand-receptor pair, effectively captures the combinatorial nature of cellular communication.
  • Attention Mechanism for Prioritization: The attention mechanism in the GNN is crucial for identifying which ligand-receptor pairs are most influential for a given gene's expression, effectively prioritizing key communication events.
  • Decomposition of Gene Expression: Separating gene expression into baseline and CE-driven components (E = E₀ + ΔE) allows for a clearer attribution of expression changes to intercellular signaling.

Key Results

  • Improved Gene Expression Prediction: HoloNet demonstrated improved accuracy in predicting gene expression compared to models that only consider cell-type information, highlighting the importance of CEs.
  • Breast Cancer Insights: In breast cancer, HoloNet identified specific ligand-receptor signals (e.g., FN1:SDC1) driving the expression of invasion-related genes in stromal cells, with basal-like-1 cells identified as key senders. It also revealed how the FN1 pathway impacts the extracellular matrix.
  • Liver Cancer Insights: In liver cancer, HoloNet identified key FCEs, particularly involving the JAG1:NOTCH3 pathway, that affect angiogenesis, with fibroblasts, malignancy cells, and endothelial cells acting as major senders.
  • Model Stability: HoloNet showed good stability and robustness across different spatial transcriptomics technologies (Visium, Slideseq-v2) and varying spot sizes/sampling strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependence on Deconvolution: For technologies like Visium with lower resolution, HoloNet relies on cell-type deconvolution, which can introduce its own biases. However, the authors showed their method is not overly sensitive to the deconvolution method.
  • Data Sparsity: For technologies with very sparse data (e.g., some single-cell resolution technologies), constructing a dense enough communication network for robust analysis might be challenging.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest incorporating prior knowledge (e.g., intracellular signaling networks) into the model and developing multi-scale models to capture finer cellular distinctions or temporal dynamics. They also aim to adapt HoloNet for emerging spatial technologies with higher resolution and more comprehensive gene detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cell–cell communication events (CEs) are mediated by multiple ligand–receptor pairs. Usually only a particular subset of CEs directly works for a specific downstream response in a particular microenvironment. We name them as functional communication events (FCEs) of the target responses. Decoding the FCE-target gene relations is important for understanding the machanisms of many biological processes, but has been intractable due to the mixing of multiple factors and the lack of direct observations. We developed a method HoloNet for decoding FCEs using spatial transcriptomic data by integrating ligand–receptor pairs, cell-type spatial distribution and downstream gene expression into a deep learning model. We modeled CEs as a multiview network, developed an attention-based graph learning method to train the model for generating target gene expression with the CE networks, and decoded the FCEs for specific downstream genes by interpreting the trained model. We applied HoloNet on three Visium datasets of breast cancer or liver cancer. It revealed the communication landscapes in tumor microenvironments, and uncovered how various ligand–receptor signals and cell types affect specific biological processes. We also validated the stability of HoloNet in a Slideseq-v2 dataset. The experiments showed that HoloNet is a powerful tool on spatial transcriptomic data to help revealing specific cell–cell communications in a microenvironment that shape cellular phenotypes.
BibTeX
@article{li2023decoding,
  author = {Haochen Li and Tianxing Ma and Minsheng Hao and Wenbo Guo and Jin Gu and Lei Wei and Xuegong Zhang},
  title = {{Decoding functional cell–cell communication events by multi-view graph learning on spatial transcriptomics}},
  journal = {Briefings in Bioinformatics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/bib/bbad359},
}
Figure