Cross calibration of gamma-ray detectors (GRD) of GECAM-C

Yan-Qiu Zhang, S. L. Xiong, Rui Qiao, D. Y. Guo, Wen-Xi Peng, Xinqiao Li, W. C. Xue, Chao Zheng, Jia-Cong Liu, Wen-Jun Tan, Chen-Wei Wang, Peng Zhang, Ping Wang, Ce Cai, Shuo Xiao, Yue Huang, Pei-Yi Feng, Xiao‐Bo Li, L. M. Song, Qi-Bin Yi, Yi Zhao, Zhi-Wei Guo, Jian-Jian He, Chaoyang Li, Yaqing Liu, Ke Gong, Yan-Qi Du, Xiao-Jing Liu, Sheng-Lun Xie, Guoying Zhao, Xiaoyun Zhao, Xiaolu Zhang, Zhen Zhang, S. J. Zheng, Jin Wang, Xiang-Yang Wen, Zhenghua An, Dali Zhang, Min Gao, Xilei Sun, X. H. Liang, S. Yang, Gang Chen, Fan ZhangarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The gamma-ray detectors (GRDs) of GECAM-C onboard the SATech-01 satellite are designed to monitor gamma-ray transients across the sky from 6 keV to 6 MeV. The Energy Response Matrix (ERM) is critical for accurate spectral measurements of these bursts. While initially generated via GEANT4 simulations and ground calibration, the ERM must be verified in-flight. In this work, the GECAM-C GRD energy response is cross-calibrated with Fermi/GBM and Swift/BAT using a sample of Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) and Soft Gamma-Ray Repeaters (SGRs). The results demonstrate strong agreement between GECAM-C and these established instruments, as well as internal consistency among GECAM-C's own detectors, confirming its capability for reliable spectral measurements.

The Challenge of In-Flight Calibration

When a new mission like GECAM-C (launched July 2022) begins its survey of high-energy transients, establishing data integrity is paramount. The core of this accuracy is the Energy Response Matrix (ERM), which translates raw detector counts into physical energy spectra. However, the space environment—characterized by detector aging and complex background noise—can introduce discrepancies not captured in ground-based simulations.

To ensure GECAM-C is "science-ready," researchers performed in-flight cross-calibration. This process involves comparing GECAM-C's observations of specific cosmic events with data from "gold standard" observatories like the Fermi Gamma-ray Burst Monitor (GBM) and the Swift Burst Alert Telescope (BAT).

The GECAM-C payload on SATech-01, showing the distribution of GRD and CPD detectors across the top and bottom cabins.

Methodology: Joint Spectral Fitting

The team utilized joint spectrum fitting of simultaneous observations. Key technical strategies included:

  • Constant Factor Modeling: By fixing the reference instrument's normalization factor to 1.0 and allowing GECAM-C’s factor to vary, the team could quantify the level of agreement. A factor near 1.0 indicates high calibration accuracy.
  • Spectral Modeling: Standard models like the "Band model" (curved power-law) and "cutoff power-law" were applied to the data.
  • Threshold Correction: A significant finding was that detectors do not have a hard "cut-off" at low energies. Instead, they exhibit a "soft threshold" where efficiency gradually fades. The researchers modeled this using a Gaussian Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) to improve data reliability near the 6-10 keV limit.

Key Results and Insights

The study focused on four primary events, including GRB 220921A (for Fermi cross-calibration) and GRB 220930A (for Swift cross-calibration).

Cross-Instrument Harmony

For the bright GRB 220921A, the normalization factors for GECAM-C detectors ranged from 0.88 to 0.94, indicating excellent agreement with Fermi/GBM. Despite differences in detector materials (LaBr3/NaI for GECAM-C vs. NaI/BGO for Fermi), spectral parameters like the power-law indices ($\alpha \approx -0.81$ and $\beta \approx -2.09$) remained remarkably consistent.

Joint spectral fit of GECAM-C (GRD01, 04, 05) and Fermi/GBM for GRB 220921A, showing counts, energy flux, and residuals.

Low-Energy Precision

By applying the new Gaussian CDF threshold correction, the researchers significantly reduced residuals in the low-energy data. The ratio of data to the model remained near 1.0 even down to the 8-10 keV range, effectively extending the instrument's usable sensitivity.

Internal Consistency

The 12 individual GRD detectors on GECAM-C showed high internal consistency. This ensures that the all-sky monitor provides a uniform view of the transient sky, regardless of the burst's arrival direction relative to the satellite.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This cross-calibration effort confirms that GECAM-C GRD provides reliable spectral measurements consistent with the world's leading gamma-ray observatories. While the current sample size is small, future work will expand this analysis as more bursts are detected, refining the threshold models for all 12 detectors and further investigating the integration between High-Gain and Low-Gain channels.

Summary updated

Abstract

The gamma-ray detectors (GRDs) of GECAM-C onborad SATech-01 satellite is designed to monitor gamma-ray transients all over the sky from 6 keV to 6 MeV. The energy response matrix is the key to do spectral measurements of bursts, which is usually generated from GEANT4 simulation and partially verified by the ground calibration. In this work, energy response matrix of GECAM-C GRD is cross-calibrated with Fermi/GBM and Swift/BAT using a sample of Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) and Soft Gamma-Ray Repeaters (SGRs). The calibration results show there is a good agreement between GECAM-C and other reasonably well calibrated instrument (i.e. Fermi/GBM and Swift/BAT). We also find that different GRD detectors of GECAM-C also show consistency with each other. All these results indicate that GECAM-C GRD can provide reliable spectral measurements.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023cross,
  author = {Yan-Qiu Zhang and S. L. Xiong and Rui Qiao and D. Y. Guo and Wen-Xi Peng and Xinqiao Li and W. C. Xue and Chao Zheng and Jia-Cong Liu and Wen-Jun Tan and Chen-Wei Wang and Peng Zhang and Ping Wang and Ce Cai and Shuo Xiao and Yue Huang and Pei-Yi Feng and Xiao‐Bo Li and L. M. Song and Qi-Bin Yi and Yi Zhao and Zhi-Wei Guo and Jian-Jian He and Chaoyang Li and Yaqing Liu and Ke Gong and Yan-Qi Du and Xiao-Jing Liu and Sheng-Lun Xie and Guoying Zhao and Xiaoyun Zhao and Xiaolu Zhang and Zhen Zhang and S. J. Zheng and Jin Wang and Xiang-Yang Wen and Zhenghua An and Dali Zhang and Min Gao and Xilei Sun and X. H. Liang and S. Yang and Jin-Zhou Wang and Gang Chen and Fan Zhang},
  title = {{Cross calibration of gamma-ray detectors (GRD) of GECAM-C}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.00698},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.00698},
}
Figure