Covariance estimation under one-bit quantization

Sjoerd Dirksen, Johannes Maly, Holger Rauhut

Abstract

We consider the classical problem of estimating the covariance matrix of a subgaussian distribution from i.i.d. samples in the novel context of coarse quantization, i.e., instead of having full knowledge of the samples, they are quantized to one or two bits per entry. This problem occurs naturally in signal processing applications. We introduce new estimators in two different quantization scenarios and derive non-asymptotic estimation error bounds in terms of the operator norm. In the first scenario we consider a simple, scale-invariant one-bit quantizer and derive an estimation result for the correlation matrix of a centered Gaussian distribution. In the second scenario, we add random dithering to the quantizer. In this case we can accurately estimate the full covariance matrix of a general subgaussian distribution by collecting two bits per entry of each sample. In both scenarios, our bounds apply to masked covariance estimation. We demonstrate the near-optimality of our error bounds by deriving corresponding (minimax) lower bounds and using numerical simulations.

Introduction

In the modern era of high-dimensional data analysis, we often operate under the assumption of perfect, high-precision access to samples. However, in practical signal processing contexts—such as massive MIMO systems or remote sensor networks—hardware constraints, power consumption, and bandwidth limitations necessitate data quantization.

The most extreme form of this is one-bit quantization, where only the sign of a signal (positive or negative) is recorded. While this significantly enhances hardware efficiency and reduces storage requirements, it discards a substantial amount of information. This research addresses a fundamental question: can we accurately estimate the underlying covariance structure of data from these impoverished, one-bit observations? Moving beyond traditional asymptotic analysis, this paper provides non-asymptotic bounds that define the sample complexity required for high-dimensional accuracy.

Estimation Frameworks

The study explores two primary quantization scenarios to recover the statistical structure of a distribution from coarse measurements.

1. Pure One-bit Quantization

In the simplest case, we use the sign function $Q(x) = \text{sign}(x)$. Because this operation is scale-invariant—multiplying the input by a positive constant does not change the output sign—it is impossible to recover the full covariance matrix. Instead, the focus is on recovering the correlation matrix.

The authors employ an estimator based on the "arcsin-law" (Grothendieck’s identity). This identity provides a direct mathematical relationship between the correlation of the signs of two Gaussian variables and the correlation of the variables themselves. By applying this transformation to the sample correlation of the quantized data, the underlying correlation structure can be reconstructed.

2. Dithered One-bit Quantization

To recover the full covariance matrix, including the variances on the diagonal, the authors introduce random dithering. By adding a controlled amount of random noise before the quantization step and collecting two bits per entry (using two distinct dithers), the bias inherent in the sign function can be mathematically neutralized. This allows for the "cancellation" of quantization distortion in expectation, enabling the estimation of the full covariance matrix for general subgaussian distributions.

Masking and High-Dimensionality

To combat the "curse of dimensionality," the paper incorporates masking. This technique is used to estimate specific structures, such as sparse or banded matrices, which are common in high-dimensional statistics. Masking allows the estimators to focus on relevant entries, improving performance in settings where the number of parameters exceeds the number of samples.

Key Insights and Theoretical Results

Near-Optimality and Scaling

The authors derive explicit error bounds in the operator norm, a challenging metric that is highly relevant for applications like Principal Component Analysis (PCA). The results show that the estimation error scales with $\sqrt{\frac{\log(p)}{n}}$, where $p$ is the dimension and $n$ is the number of samples. Remarkably, this matches the scaling of classical full-precision estimation, suggesting that the information loss from quantization does not fundamentally alter the rate of convergence.

The Efficiency of Coarse Quantization

One of the most surprising findings is that the one-bit estimator can occasionally outperform the classical sample covariance matrix. In regimes where the data is extremely highly correlated, the quantization process acts as a natural regularizer, providing more robust estimates than high-precision methods that might overfit to the noise in the correlation.

Minimax Lower Bounds

To prove the strength of their proposed estimators, the authors derive "minimax" lower bounds. These bounds demonstrate that no possible estimator, regardless of its complexity, can significantly outperform the proposed methods under the same bit constraints. This establishes the near-optimality of the dithered and arcsin-based approaches.

Empirical Validation

Using synthetic numerical simulations with i.i.d. samples from Gaussian and subgaussian distributions, the authors validated their theoretical findings. The simulations confirmed that:

  • The one-bit estimator $\tilde{\Sigma}_n$ performs nearly as well as the full-precision sample covariance $\hat{\Sigma}_n$ for standard Gaussian data.
  • Performance is highly sensitive to internal correlation; when correlation is near 1.0, the one-bit method exhibits remarkable robustness.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the paper establishes a strong theoretical foundation, several areas remain for future exploration:

  • Parameter Tuning: The dithered estimator requires a "dithering level" $\lambda$, which currently depends on the (often unknown) maximum variance in the data. Developing a data-driven, adaptive method for selecting $\lambda$ is a key open question.
  • Distributional Assumptions: The tightest results for pure one-bit quantization rely on the Gaussian assumption due to the arcsin-law. Extending these bounds to a broader class of non-Gaussian distributions remains a challenge.
  • Computational Implementation: The focus of this work is statistical efficiency. Future research could address the computational overhead and hardware-specific implementation of these estimators in real-time systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the classical problem of estimating the covariance matrix of a subgaussian distribution from i.i.d. samples in the novel context of coarse quantization, i.e., instead of having full knowledge of the samples, they are quantized to one or two bits per entry. This problem occurs naturally in signal processing applications. We introduce new estimators in two different quantization scenarios and derive non-asymptotic estimation error bounds in terms of the operator norm. In the first scenario we consider a simple, scale-invariant one-bit quantizer and derive an estimation result for the correlation matrix of a centered Gaussian distribution. In the second scenario, we add random dithering to the quantizer. In this case we can accurately estimate the full covariance matrix of a general subgaussian distribution by collecting two bits per entry of each sample. In both scenarios, our bounds apply to masked covariance estimation. We demonstrate the near-optimality of our error bounds by deriving corresponding (minimax) lower bounds and using numerical simulations.
BibTeX
@article{dirksen2022covariance,
  author = {Sjoerd Dirksen and Johannes Maly and Holger Rauhut},
  title = {{Covariance estimation under one-bit quantization}},
  journal = {The Annals of Statistics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1214/22-aos2239},
}
Figure