Covariance estimation under one-bit quantization

Sjoerd Dirksen, Johannes Maly, Holger Rauhut

TL;DR

This paper introduces new methods for estimating the covariance and correlation matrices of high-dimensional data when you only have access to 1 or 2 bits of information per entry. The authors prove that these "coarse" estimators are nearly as accurate as classical full-precision methods and, in some highly correlated scenarios, can even outperform them.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the "big data" era, we often assume we have perfect, high-precision access to our samples. However, in real-world signal processing—like massive MIMO systems or remote sensor networks—hardware constraints, power consumption, and bandwidth limits force us to quantize data.

The most extreme version of this is one-bit quantization, where we only record the sign of a signal (positive or negative). While this is great for hardware efficiency, it throws away a massive amount of information. The challenge is: can we still accurately estimate the underlying structure of the data (its covariance matrix) from these "impoverished" bits?

Previous work mostly looked at asymptotic results (what happens as the number of samples goes to infinity). This paper provides non-asymptotic bounds, telling us exactly how many samples we need to achieve a specific level of accuracy in a high-dimensional setting.

Methods

The authors explore two distinct quantization scenarios:

  1. Pure One-bit Quantization: Using the sign function $Q(x) = \text{sign}(x)$. Because this is scale-invariant (multiplying the input by a constant doesn't change the sign), you can only recover the correlation matrix, not the full covariance. The authors use a clever estimator based on the "arcsin-law" (Grothendieck’s identity), which relates the correlation of signs to the correlation of the original Gaussian variables.
  2. Dithered One-bit Quantization: To recover the full covariance matrix (including the variances on the diagonal), the authors add a small amount of random noise—dithering—before quantizing. By collecting two bits per entry (using two different random dithers), they can "cancel out" the quantization distortion in expectation.

The paper also incorporates masking, a technique used to estimate specific structures like sparse or banded matrices, which is common in high-dimensional statistics to reduce the "curse of dimensionality."

Datasets

This is a theoretical paper focused on mathematical proofs and statistical guarantees. As such, it does not use large-scale real-world datasets. Instead, the authors validate their findings using synthetic numerical simulations with i.i.d. samples drawn from centered Gaussian and subgaussian distributions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Dithering: Dithering isn't just noise; it's a tool. By adding controlled randomness before quantization, the bias introduced by the "sign" function can be mathematically managed, allowing for the recovery of the full covariance matrix.
  • Surprising Efficiency: One of the most counter-intuitive findings is that the one-bit estimator can actually outperform the classical sample covariance matrix in cases where the data is extremely highly correlated. In these "extreme" regimes, the quantization process acts as a sort of natural regularizer.
  • Near-Optimality: The authors derive "minimax" lower bounds, proving that their proposed estimators are essentially as good as any possible estimator could be under these bit constraints.
  • Operator Norm Focus: Unlike many papers that focus on simpler entry-wise errors, this work derives bounds in the operator norm, which is much more challenging but more useful for applications like Principal Component Analysis (PCA).

Key Results

  • Theoretical Bounds: The authors provide explicit error bounds showing that the estimation error scales with $\sqrt{\frac{\log(p)}{n}}$, where $p$ is the dimension and $n$ is the number of samples. This matches the scaling of classical full-precision estimation.
  • Numerical Validation: Simulations show that the one-bit estimator $\tilde{\Sigma}_n$ performs almost as well as the full-precision sample covariance $\hat{\Sigma}_n$ for standard Gaussian data.
  • Correlation Sensitivity: The experiments confirm that the one-bit estimator's performance is highly dependent on the internal correlation of the signal. When correlation is near 1.0, the one-bit method is remarkably robust.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: The dithered estimator requires choosing a "dithering level" $\lambda$. Currently, the optimal $\lambda$ depends on the number of samples $n$ and the (unknown) maximum variance in the data. The authors suggest some modifications to make this more practical, but finding a truly "data-driven" way to pick $\lambda$ without prior knowledge remains an open research question.
  • Gaussian Assumption: While some results apply to general subgaussian distributions, the most elegant "arcsin-law" results for pure one-bit quantization are specific to Gaussian data. Extending these tight bounds to broader classes of distributions is a potential next step.
  • Computational Complexity: While the estimators are mathematically sound, the paper focuses on their statistical properties rather than the computational overhead of implementing them in real-time hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the classical problem of estimating the covariance matrix of a sub-Gaussian distribution from i.i.d. samples in the novel context of coarse quantization, that is, instead of having full knowledge of the samples, they are quantized to one or two bits per entry. This problem occurs naturally in signal processing applications. We introduce new estimators in two different quantization scenarios and derive nonasymptotic estimation error bounds in terms of the operator norm. In the first scenario, we consider a simple, scale-invariant one-bit quantizer and derive an estimation result for the correlation matrix of a centered Gaussian distribution. In the second scenario, we add random dithering to the quantizer. In this case, we can accurately estimate the full covariance matrix of a general sub-Gaussian distribution by collecting two bits per entry of each sample. In both scenarios, our bounds apply to masked covariance estimation. We demonstrate the near optimality of our error bounds by deriving corresponding (minimax) lower bounds and using numerical simulations.
BibTeX
@article{dirksen2022covariance,
  author = {Sjoerd Dirksen and Johannes Maly and Holger Rauhut},
  title = {{Covariance estimation under one-bit quantization}},
  journal = {The Annals of Statistics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1214/22-aos2239},
}

Loading related content...

Figure