Abstract
The Technical University of Denmark (DTU) 10 MW wind turbine is selected as the object of this study. The braceless semi-submersible platform for the National Renewable Energy Laboratory 5 MW wind turbine is upscaled to support the DTU 10 MW wind turbine. The servo control system of the 10 MW semi-submersible wind turbine is redesigned. Furthermore, torque control is performed below the rated wind speed to achieve maximum power capture, and the gain scheduling proportional integral (GSPI) control method is performed above the rated wind speed to realize the design of the variable propeller control system. This ensures the safe operation of the floating wind turbine above the rated wind speed. The reliability of the designed servo control system is verified by a full coupling dynamic response analysis with the designed servo control system, aerodynamics, and hydrodynamics under the combined action of wind and waves. The coupled dynamic characteristics of the 10 MW semi-submersible wind turbine under different conditions are analyzed, including operational, extreme, and fault situations. The results show that the servo control system effectively controls the motion response of a 10 MW floating offshore wind turbine (FOWT). Turbulent wind has an obvious excitation effect on the surge and pitch of the FOWT, whereas the heave motion is primarily excited by wave loads. Different fault conditions can cause different motion and structural responses. Furthermore, the tower top bending moment is greatly affected by the imbalance of aerodynamic load, and the surge, pitch motion, tower base bending moment, and mooring tension of the FOWT are affected by different fault conditions to varying degrees. In addition, the heave motion is generally barely affected by the fault conditions.
Introduction
As wind energy moves into deeper waters, the industry is shifting from fixed-bottom foundations to floating platforms. Simultaneously, turbines are scaling up to 10 MW and beyond. This upscaling presents a major engineering hurdle: a 10 MW turbine on a semi-submersible platform is a complex, "fully coupled" system where wind, waves, structural elasticity, and the computer-controlled servo system all influence one another.
Existing research often focuses on smaller 5 MW models or ignores the influence of the control system under turbulent conditions. This study provides a comprehensive "stress test" for the next generation of 10 MW floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs). By redesigning the servo control systems and simulating extreme environmental and fault conditions, the researchers demonstrate that while these giants are stable under normal operation, mechanical faults like a stuck pitch actuator can double the structural loads on the tower, necessitating robust emergency strategies.
Methodology
The researchers employed a "fully coupled" aero-hydro-servo-elastic simulation. This means they modeled the wind (aerodynamics), waves (hydrodynamics), structural bending (elasticity), and the turbine's "brain" (servo control) simultaneously using a suite of specialized tools:
- Modeling Tools: They integrated FAST (an NREL-developed aeroelastic code) with ANSYS-AQWA for hydrodynamic coefficients and MATLAB for the control logic.
- The Platform: They upscaled a "braceless" semi-submersible platform originally designed for 5 MW turbines to support the heavier DTU 10 MW reference turbine.
- The Controller: A key contribution is the redesigned servo control system. It uses Torque Control at low wind speeds to maximize power and a Gain Scheduling Proportional Integral (GSPI) method at high wind speeds to adjust blade pitch, specifically tuned to avoid "negative damping"—a phenomenon where the controller accidentally amplifies the platform's rocking motion.
Key Insights and Results
- Excitation Decoupling: One of the clearest findings is the separation of motion drivers. Turbulent wind is the primary driver for surge (forward/backward) and pitch (tilting) motions. Conversely, heave (up/down) is almost entirely dictated by wave loads and remains largely indifferent to what the turbine or its controller is doing.
- The Danger of Imbalance: The most severe structural stress occurs during a "stuck pitch actuator" fault. When one blade fails to adjust while the others do, it creates a massive aerodynamic imbalance. This creates a "shock load" on the tower top, with the tower top bending moment reaching values approximately twice as high as those seen during normal operation.
- Gyroscopic Effects on Mooring: The study found that mooring line tensions are not symmetrical. Due to the gyroscopic effect of the massive spinning rotor, the mooring line positioned to the right of the wind direction (Mooring #3) is significantly more susceptible to tension fluctuations than the others. Mooring tension was found to be directly influenced by surge motion, reaching its peak at the rated wind speed when aerodynamic thrust is at its maximum.
Conclusion and Future Work
The redesigned GSPI controller successfully stabilized the 10 MW platform, keeping power output steady above rated wind speeds without inducing platform instability. However, the authors acknowledge several areas for further refinement:
- Shutdown Strategies: Future work should investigate multi-stage or variable-rate pitch strategies for emergency shutdowns, rather than the constant rate used here.
- Environmental Complexity: Simulations should be expanded to include "misaligned" wind and wave conditions (e.g., cross-seas), which are common offshore and can create complex twisting loads.
- Actuator Fidelity: Adding more degrees of freedom to the actuator models could provide a higher-fidelity look at the transmission shaft's response during a failure.
Summary updated