Cost-effective Design Options for IsoDAR

Andreas Adelmann, J. Alonso, W.a. Barletta, R. J. Barlow, L. Bartoszek, Adriana Bungau, L. Calabretta, A. Calanna, D. Campo, J. M. Conrad, Z. Djurcic, Y. Kamyshkov, Hywel Owen, M. H. Shaevitz, I. Shimizu, Tess Smidt, J. Spitz, M. Toups, M. O. Wascko, L. A. Winslow, Jianjun Yang

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive review of design options for IsoDAR, a novel, high-intensity electron antineutrino source. The authors conclude that their baseline design, featuring a compact cyclotron and a beryllium target surrounded by a lithium sleeve, is the most cost-effective approach to achieving the project's ambitious physics goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of designing a cost-effective and technically feasible electron antineutrino source capable of producing a high flux of neutrinos for beyond-Standard Model physics searches, particularly for sterile neutrinos. Existing neutrino sources have not achieved the necessary event rates, and the authors explore various design choices to optimize cost-effectiveness while meeting stringent physics requirements. These requirements include maximizing the neutrino flux and its energy distribution, minimizing backgrounds, ensuring low technical risk, and considering factors like compactness, simplicity of construction, reliability, and potential for future physics programs and industrial partnerships.

Methods

The paper employs a comparative analysis of various design options for the IsoDAR antineutrino source. The authors systematically evaluate different accelerators (cyclotrons, LINACs, FFAGs, synchrotrons), beam particles (H₂, protons, deuterons, H⁻), target materials (beryllium, copper, tungsten), and sleeve materials (lithium). They utilize simulation studies (e.g., OPAL for beam dynamics) and draw upon existing experimental data and accelerator performance to assess the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of each option against a defined set of criteria. The baseline design is presented as the culmination of this evaluation process.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulation data and existing literature for performance metrics and cost estimates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • H₂ as the optimal beam particle: The paper strongly advocates for using H₂ ions over protons or H⁻ ions due to reduced space-charge effects, enabling higher beam currents and thus higher neutrino fluxes. This choice also aligns well with potential future applications in chained cyclotron systems.
  • Compact cyclotron is key: The baseline design's reliance on a compact, 60 MeV/amu cyclotron is justified by its cost-effectiveness, suitability for underground deployment, and ability to achieve the required beam current.
  • Synergistic partnerships drive cost-effectiveness: The design is heavily influenced by potential collaborations with the medical isotope industry and other particle physics experiments, which can offset development costs and leverage existing infrastructure.
  • Underground construction feasibility: The paper details how the cyclotron and source components can be designed for modular assembly and transport within the constraints of underground facilities, a critical factor for cost and practicality.
  • IsoDAR as a phased approach: The design is presented as a potential stepping stone towards larger future experiments like DAESALUS, adding value beyond its primary physics goals.

Key Results

The paper concludes that the baseline IsoDAR design, featuring a 60 MeV/amu H₂ cyclotron, a beryllium target, and a 99.99% pure Li sleeve, is the most cost-effective option. This design is projected to produce $2.6 \times 10^{22}$ electron antineutrinos per year with an average energy of 6.4 MeV. The analysis systematically rules out several alternative designs, including those based on LINACs, RFQ injection, and modified beta-beam production, primarily due to higher costs, technical risks, or lower performance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the baseline design still requires some R&D, particularly concerning the ion source and the precise details of underground assembly. They also note that while beryllium is the preferred target material due to its lower activation and cost-effectiveness, tungsten remains an alternative if power dissipation proves insurmountable. Future work will involve further refinement of the design through detailed simulations and experimental verification of key components. The paper also highlights the ongoing investigation into alternative coil segmentation for underground assembly.

Summary updated

Abstract

This whitepaper reviews design options for the IsoDAR electron antineutrino source. IsoDAR is designed to produce $2.6 \times 10^{22}$ electron antineutrinos per year with an average energy of 6.4 MeV, using isotope decay-at-rest. Aspects which must be balanced for cost-effectiveness include: overall cost; rate and energy distribution of the electron antineutrino flux and backgrounds; low technical risk; compactness; simplicity of underground construction and operation; reliability; value to future neutrino physics programs; and value to industry. We show that the baseline design outlined here is the most cost effective.
BibTeX
@misc{adelmann2012cost,
  author = {Andreas Adelmann and J. Alonso and W.A. Barletta and R. J. Barlow and L. Bartoszek and Adriana Bungau and L. Calabretta and A. Calanna and D. Campo and J. M. Conrad and Z. Djurcic and Y. Kamyshkov and Hywel Owen and M. H. Shaevitz and I. Shimizu and Tess Smidt and J. Spitz and M. Toups and M. O. Wascko and L. A. Winslow and Jianjun Yang},
  title = {{Cost-effective Design Options for IsoDAR}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1210.4454},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1210.4454},
}
Figure