R&D Argon Detector at Ash River (RADAR) - Letter of Intent

P. Adamson, Sanjib Kumar Agarwalla, A. Aurisano, John Evans, P. Guzowski, A. Habig, A. Holin, J. Huang, M. Kordosky, A. Kreymer, K. Lang, Marvin L. Marshak, R. Mehdiyev, William H. Miller, D. Naples, R. J. Nichol, V. Paolone, R. B. Patterson, A. Sousa, J. Thomas, L. WhiteheadarXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In the RADAR project described in this Letter of Intent, we propose to deploy a 6 kton liquid argon TPC at the NOvA Far Detector building in Ash River, Minnesota, and expose it to the NuMI beam during NOvA running. It will significantly add to the physics capabilities of the NOvA program while providing LBNE with an R&D program based on full-scale TPC module assemblies. RADAR offers an excellent opportunity to improve the full Homestake LBNE project in physics reach, timeline, costs, and fostering international partnership. The anticipated duration of the project's construction is 5 years, with running happening between 2018 and 2023.

Introduction

Neutrinos remain some of the most enigmatic particles in the Standard Model. Key questions regarding their mass hierarchy and the potential for CP violation in the lepton sector are central to our understanding of the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe. While current experiments like NOvA and T2K are providing initial insights, the next generation of neutrino physics requires significantly larger target masses and advanced detection technologies. The Long-Baseline Neutrino Experiment (LBNE) is envisioned as the definitive facility for these measurements, but its scale and cost necessitate a robust R&D and prototyping phase. The R&D Argon Detector at Ash River (RADAR) proposal addresses this need by providing a multi-kiloton scale prototype that delivers immediate, high-impact physics results.

The RADAR Proposal

The core of the RADAR project is the construction of a 6-kiloton Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber (LAr TPC) at the existing NOvA site in Ash River, Minnesota. This location allows the detector to be exposed to the high-intensity NuMI neutrino beam from Fermilab.

Technologically, RADAR serves as a full-scale validation of the LBNE design. It utilizes Anode Plane Assemblies (APAs) and Cathode Plane Assemblies (CPAs) to detect ionization electrons in a uniform 500 V/cm electric field. The detector is composed of modular assemblies designed to be identical to those planned for the final LBNE detector. Containment is provided by a stainless-steel membrane cryostat, a technology adapted from industrial liquefied natural gas (LNG) shipping, ensuring the high levels of argon purity required for long-drift TPCs.

Physics Reach: Mass Hierarchy and CP Violation

RADAR is not merely a technical prototype; it is a powerful physics instrument. By combining data from RADAR with existing datasets from NOvA and T2K, the statistical significance of key measurements is dramatically enhanced.

Projections indicate that the combined "Ash River Program" can resolve the neutrino mass hierarchy with a significance exceeding 4.5σ for favorable values of the CP-violating phase δ. As shown in the following figure, the hierarchy can be determined at better than 95% Confidence Level (C.L.) for more than half of the possible δ range when RADAR data is included.

Significance of hierarchy resolution (left) and the fraction of the CP phase δ for which a given significance is achieved (right).

In the search for CP violation, the addition of RADAR data would allow for the first 95% C.L. sensitivity across approximately 25% of the δ range. The figure below illustrates how the combined sensitivity of NOvA, T2K, and RADAR pushes the discovery potential significantly higher than the current generation of experiments alone.

Significance of CP violation discovery potential (left) and the fraction of δ coverage (right) for the combined experimental datasets.

Strategic and Economic Value

A unique aspect of the RADAR proposal is its cost-effectiveness. Because the detector uses the exact components intended for the final LBNE project, a significant portion of the RADAR budget acts as a direct investment in LBNE. This "recyclable science" approach reduces the overall financial risk of the larger project. Additionally, leveraging the existing infrastructure at the NOvA Far Detector building avoids substantial civil engineering costs and accelerates the timeline for first data.

Challenges and Future Outlook

Operating a large LAr TPC near the surface presents challenges, primarily from cosmic ray backgrounds. The current plan utilizes the existing NOvA overburden, but further studies may indicate the need for additional shielding. Integrating the lessons learned from RADAR's construction and operation into the final 34-kton LBNE design will be a critical task for project management. Despite these challenges, RADAR represents a strategic bridge to the next era of neutrino physics, offering a path that balances technical de-risking with immediate scientific discovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the RADAR project described in this Letter of Intent, we propose to deploy a 6 kton liquid argon TPC at the NOvA Far Detector building in Ash River, Minnesota, and expose it to the NuMI beam during NOvA running. It will significantly add to the physics capabilities of the NOvA program while providing LBNE with an R&D program based on full-scale TPC module assemblies. RADAR offers an excellent opportunity to improve the full Homestake LBNE project in physics reach, timeline, costs, and fostering international partnership. The anticipated duration of the project's construction is 5 years, with running happening between 2018 and 2023.
BibTeX
@misc{adamson2013r,
  author = {P. Adamson and Sanjib Kumar Agarwalla and A. Aurisano and John Evans and P. Guzowski and A. Habig and A. Holin and J. Huang and M. Kordosky and A. Kreymer and K. Lang and Marvin L. Marshak and R. Mehdiyev and William H. Miller and D. Naples and R. J. Nichol and V. Paolone and R. B. Patterson and A. Sousa and J. Thomas and L. Whitehead},
  title = {{R\&D Argon Detector at Ash River (RADAR) - Letter of Intent}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1307.6507},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.6507},
}
Figure