Contribution to understanding the evolution of holometaboly: Transformation of internal head structures during the metamorphosis in the green lacewing Chrysopa pallens (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae)

Chenjing Zhao, Ang Y, Mengqing Wang, Caixia Gao, Kuiyan Zhang, Chufei Tang, Xingyue Liu, Min Li, Ding Yang, Rudolf Meier

This research paper, published in BMC Evolutionary Biology, provides a high-resolution look at the "black box" of insect metamorphosis. By using 3D imaging to track the internal head development of the green lacewing, the authors challenge traditional models of how insects rebuild themselves and suggest a universal sequence for the evolution of complete metamorphosis.

TL;DR

Using micro-CT imaging, researchers mapped the dramatic internal "renovation" of the green lacewing’s head during metamorphosis. They discovered that skeletal, neural, and muscular systems rebuild in a specific, staggered sequence—a finding that suggests a common ancestral blueprint for all insects that undergo complete metamorphosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metamorphosis is one of nature’s most radical transformations, yet we know surprisingly little about what happens inside the pupal case. Most research focuses on "extreme" cases like flies or butterflies, where the larva (maggot/caterpillar) eats something entirely different from the adult.

The authors chose the green lacewing (Chrysopa pallens) because it is a "moderate" case: both the larvae and adults are predators that eat aphids. If the diet doesn't change, do the internal structures still need a total overhaul? The paper investigates whether the internal "histolysis" (tissue breakdown) and rebuilding are as dramatic in these species and seeks to identify the precise timing of these events.

Methods

The researchers employed micro-computed tomography (µ-CT), a non-destructive X-ray imaging technique that allows for high-resolution 3D reconstruction of soft tissues like muscles and brains.

  • Sampling: They collected 40 specimens of C. pallens, capturing daily snapshots from the final larval stage through 12 days of pupation until adult emergence.
  • 3D Modeling: Using Amira 5.4 software, they manually reconstructed the skeletal elements, 10+ pharyngeal muscles, and the central nervous system (CNS) for each stage.
  • Novelty: While µ-CT is becoming a standard in entomology, applying it to a full developmental time-series in Neuroptera (lacewings) provides a rare "movie" of internal development rather than just "before and after" snapshots.

Datasets

As a biological morphology study, the "dataset" consists of the physical specimens and the resulting 3D volumetric data.

  • Primary Subject: Chrysopa pallens (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae).
  • Comparative Data: The authors compared their findings against established developmental data for Drosophila (flies), Apis (bees), Tenebrio (beetles), and Panorpa (scorpionflies).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Renovation" Sequence: The study found a strict order of operations: the skeleton remodels first, followed by the central nervous system, and finally the muscles. This suggests that muscles cannot be rebuilt until the skeletal "anchor points" are in place.
  • Brain Expansion: Despite having the same diet as larvae, adults have significantly larger brains. The brain volume jumps from ~20% of the head capsule in larvae to over 33% in adults. This is likely due to the massive increase in sensory input from new compound eyes and long antennae needed for flight and mating.
  • The Head Tilt: The most visible change is a 3D "re-orientation." The larva has a forward-facing (prognathous) head for skewering prey, while the adult head rotates downward (hypognathous) for chewing. This shift happens rapidly during the prepupal stage.
  • Challenging the "Two-Step" Model: Traditional theory suggests metamorphosis happens in two discrete steps: external parts first, then internal. This paper shows that the adult cuticle and internal structures actually form gradually and simultaneously inside the cocoon.

Key Results

  • Brain Volume Dynamics: The brain actually shrinks slightly in relative volume during the early pupal stage (to 12.5%) before exploding in size to reach its final adult form (33.3%).
  • Muscle Transformation: Most larval muscles disintegrate completely (histolysis) by Day 2 of pupation. New muscle "granules" appear by Day 4, and full muscle bundles are only completed just before emergence on Day 12.
  • Head Angle: The angle between the body axis and mouthparts shifts from 200° (larva) to 60° (prepupa) and finally settles at 135° (adult).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study focused exclusively on the head's skeleto-muscular and nervous systems. They noted that:

  • Other Systems: The transformation of the digestive and tracheal (respiratory) systems was not detailed here and will be the subject of future papers.
  • Taxonomic Breadth: To prove that this "skeleton-first" rebuilding sequence is truly the ancestral state for all holometabolous insects, more studies are needed on other under-researched groups like Megaloptera (alderflies) and Raphidioptera (snakeflies).
  • Functional Testing: While they hypothesize that the larger adult brain is for sensory processing, they did not perform neurophysiological tests to confirm how these new neural pathways are utilized.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold>Metamorphosis remains one of the most complicated and poorly understood processes in insects. This is particularly so for the very dynamic transformations that take place within the pupal sheath of holometabolous insects. Only few studies address these transformations especially with regard to cranial structures of those holometabolous species where the larval and adult forms have a similar diet. It thus remains unclear to what extent the internal structures undergo histolysis and rebuilding. Here, the development of the brain and skeleto-muscular system of the head of <italic>Chrysopa pallens</italic> (Rambur, 1838) is studied. This species is a predator of aphids in the larval and adult stage.<bold>Results:</bold>We used micro-computed-tomography (µ-CT) to study the transformations of the larval, prepupal and pupal head within the cocoon. We first assessed the morphological differences and similarities between the stages. We then determined the point in time when the compound eyes appear and describe the re-orientation of the head capsule which transforms the prognathous larva into a hypognathous adult. The internal head muscles are distinctly more slender in larvae than adults. In addition, the adults have a significantly larger brain which is likely needed for the processing of the signals obtained by the adults’ vastly expanded sensory organs that are presumably needed for dispersal and mating. Our study shows that the histolysis and modification of the inner muscles and skeletal elements take place within the prepupa. The central nervous system persists throughout metamorphosis but its morphology changes significantly. <bold>Conclusion:</bold>Our study reveals that not only the inner structures, but also the outer morphology continues to change after the final larval moult. The adult cuticle and internal structures form gradually within the cocoon. The histolysis and rebuilding begins with the skeletal elements and is followed by changes in the central nervous system before it concludes with modifications of the musculature. This order of events is likely ancestral for Holometabola because it is also known from Hymenoptera, Diptera, Mecoptera, and Coleoptera.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020contribution,
  author = {Chenjing Zhao and Ang Y and Mengqing Wang and Caixia Gao and Kuiyan Zhang and Chufei Tang and Xingyue Liu and Min Li and Ding Yang and Rudolf Meier},
  title = {{Contribution to understanding the evolution of holometaboly: Transformation of internal head structures during the metamorphosis in the green lacewing Chrysopa pallens (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae)}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1186/s12862-020-01643-2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure