Conformation of self-assembled porphyrin dimers in liposome vesicles by phase-modulation 2D fluorescence spectroscopy

Alejandro Perdomo‐Ortiz, Geoffrey A. Lott, James K. Utterback, Julia R. Widom, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik, Andrew H. Marcus

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new spectroscopic technique, phase-modulation 2D fluorescence spectroscopy (PM-2D FS), to precisely determine the three-dimensional structure of porphyrin dimers within liposome membranes. This method offers a more detailed conformational analysis than traditional techniques, revealing a "T-shaped" geometry for the studied dimers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the precise three-dimensional structure of molecules is crucial in fields like molecular biology and material science. For non-crystalline systems, like molecules embedded in cell membranes, determining structure is particularly challenging. Traditional spectroscopic methods often lack the resolution to distinguish between various possible molecular arrangements. This paper tackles this challenge by developing and applying a novel 2D electronic spectroscopy technique that leverages fluorescence detection to provide highly detailed structural information about molecular dimers, specifically porphyrin dimers within liposome vesicles.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and application of phase-modulation 2D fluorescence spectroscopy (PM-2D FS). This technique uses a sequence of four collinear laser pulses to excite electronic populations. The key innovation lies in how the resulting nonlinear signal is detected: by sweeping the relative phases of the excitation pulses at kilohertz frequencies and using lock-in amplification to monitor spontaneous fluorescence. This phase-selective detection allows for sensitive measurement of fluorescence, effectively reducing noise.

The authors also employed computational modeling using a nonlinear global optimization approach. This involved simulating linear absorption and 2D spectra for a broad distribution of potential dimer conformations and comparing these simulations to experimental data. A "joint target optimization function" was used, combining both linear and 2D spectral data to constrain the possible structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses experimental data collected by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PM-2D FS as a powerful structural probe: The study demonstrates that PM-2D FS is a highly sensitive technique for elucidating the conformation of molecular dimers, even within complex environments like liposome membranes.
  • Linear vs. 2D spectroscopy: While linear absorption spectra can suggest a wide range of possible dimer conformations, they are insufficient for unique structural determination. The addition of 2D spectral information significantly narrows down the possibilities.
  • "T-shaped" dimer geometry: The combination of linear and PM-2D FS data strongly constrains the conformation of the magnesium meso tetraphenylporphyrin (MgTPP) dimers to a specific "T-shaped" geometry.
  • Differences between PM-2D FS and 2D PE: The authors highlight that PM-2D FS and 2D photon-echo (2D PE) spectroscopy, while conceptually similar, can yield distinct spectra due to differences in how excited-state populations contribute to the signal, particularly concerning fluorescence quantum yields. This difference is crucial for structural analysis.
  • Sensitivity to structural parameters: The study quantifies the sensitivity of the PM-2D FS method to various structural parameters, revealing that certain angles and distances are more critical for defining the dimer's conformation.

Key Results

  • The PM-2D FS technique successfully resolved exciton coupling in MgTPP dimers within DSPC liposomes.
  • A quantitative comparison between experimental and simulated spectra led to the identification of an optimized "T-shaped" dimer conformation.
  • The optimized conformation is characterized by specific structural parameters: $\theta = 117.4^\circ$, $\phi = 225.2^\circ$, $\alpha = 135.2^\circ$, $\beta = 137.2^\circ$, and a center-to-center distance $R = 4.2$ Å.
  • The fluorescence efficiency parameter $\Gamma$ for doubly-excited excitons was determined to be 0.31.
  • The analysis showed that linear spectra alone could not uniquely determine the structure, but the inclusion of 2D spectra constrained the possibilities to a narrow distribution.
  • The calculated trust intervals for the structural parameters were found to be relatively small, indicating high confidence in the determined conformation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Hamiltonian limitations: The authors acknowledge that discrepancies between experimental and simulated 2D lineshapes suggest limitations in the current model Hamiltonian, particularly regarding system-bath interactions. Future experiments could focus on these interactions.
  • Uncertainty in monomer dipole moment: The estimation of the monomer square transition dipole moment ($|\mu|^2$) could introduce a systematic error in the calculated end-to-end distance $R$.
  • Dynamic disorder: While the study was conducted at room temperature where the DSPC membrane is in its gel phase, the possibility of dynamic disorder and rapid exchange between energetically equivalent structures is mentioned. Future work could investigate the temperature dependence of dimer conformation.
  • Quantum chemical calculations: The authors propose that further refinements in conformational analysis could be achieved through quantum chemical calculations, particularly for determining the distance $R$ and accounting for steric effects of phenyl groups.
  • Broader applications: The authors suggest that PM-2D FS could be widely applied to other problems in biological and material science, including studies of chiral structures (when combined with circular dichroism) and exciton coupling under low light conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

By applying a phase-modulation fluorescence approach to 2D electronic spectroscopy, we studied the conformation-dependent exciton coupling of a porphyrin dimer embedded in a phospholipid bilayer membrane. Our measurements specify the relative angle and separation between interacting electronic transition dipole moments and thus provide a detailed characterization of dimer conformation. Phase-modulation 2D fluorescence spectroscopy (PM-2D FS) produces 2D spectra with distinct optical features, similar to those obtained using 2D photon-echo spectroscopy. Specifically, we studied magnesium meso tetraphenylporphyrin dimers, which form in the amphiphilic regions of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine liposomes. Comparison between experimental and simulated spectra show that although a wide range of dimer conformations can be inferred by either the linear absorption spectrum or the 2D spectrum alone, consideration of both types of spectra constrain the possible structures to a "T-shaped" geometry. These experiments establish the PM-2D FS method as an effective approach to elucidate chromophore dimer conformation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{perdomoortiz2012conformation,
  author = {Alejandro Perdomo‐Ortiz and Geoffrey A. Lott and James K. Utterback and Julia R. Widom and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik and Andrew H. Marcus},
  title = {{Conformation of self-assembled porphyrin dimers in liposome vesicles by phase-modulation 2D fluorescence spectroscopy}},
  booktitle = {APS},
  year = {2012},
}
Figure