Abstract
Based on Bethe-ansatz approach and inelastic neutron scattering experiments, we reveal evolution of confinement of many-body Bethe strings in ordered regions of quasi-one-dimensional antiferromagnet $\rm YbAlO_3$. In the antiferromagnetic phase, the spin dynamics is dominated by the confined length-1 Bethe strings, whose dominancy in the high-energy branch of the excitation spectrum yields to the confined length-2 Bethe strings when the material is tuned to the spin-density-wave phase. In the thermal-induced disordered region, the confinement effect disappears, and the system restores the conventional quantum integrable physics of the one-dimensional Heisenberg model. Our results establish a unified picture based on Bethe string for the spin dynamics in different magnetic phases of $\rm YbAlO_3$, and thus provide profound insight into the many-body quantum magnetism.
Introduction
In the realm of one-dimensional (1D) quantum physics, the Heisenberg model serves as a gold standard for understanding how spins interact. Theory predicts that instead of simple "magnons" (spin waves), these systems should host fractional excitations called spinons and even more exotic "Bethe strings"—complex bound states of multiple magnons. While spinons have been observed frequently, Bethe strings are notoriously difficult to detect and characterize in real materials. Furthermore, existing low-energy theories, such as Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid theory, often fail to explain the high-energy components of a material's excitation spectrum. This paper provides a unified physical picture that explains the entire magnetic spectrum of $\rm YbAlO_3$ across various phases using the framework of Bethe strings.
Experimental and Theoretical Framework
The researchers employed a dual-pronged approach to investigate these exotic states. Experimentally, they used Inelastic Neutron Scattering (INS) at the Cold Neutron Chopper Spectrometer (CNCS) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. By probing a $\rm YbAlO_3$ crystal at ultra-low temperatures (down to 0.05 K) and varying magnetic fields, they mapped out the material's Dynamical Structure Factor (DSF)—essentially a map of how the spins fluctuate in response to energy and momentum transfer.
Theoretically, the team utilized the Bethe-ansatz approach, an exact analytical solution for 1D quantum models. Specifically, they used a "truncated string state space method" to calculate the theoretical spectrum. This allowed them to simulate how different lengths of Bethe strings (length-1, length-2, etc.) contribute to the overall signal, even when the system is not perfectly integrable due to real-world crystal interactions.
Mapping the Magnetic Landscape of $\rm YbAlO_3$
$\rm YbAlO_3$ is a quasi-1D antiferromagnet that exhibits a rich variety of magnetic phases. Understanding these phases is crucial for interpreting the behavior of Bethe strings, as the ordering fields in these phases act to "confine" the excitations, much like quarks are confined inside protons.
As shown in the phase diagram, the material transitions from an antiferromagnetic (AFM) phase at zero field to a spin-density-wave (SDW) phase and eventually a transverse antiferromagnetic (TAF) phase as the external magnetic field is increased. In the thermal-induced disordered region at higher temperatures, the confinement effect vanishes, and the system restores the standard behavior predicted by the 1D Heisenberg model.
Observing String Evolution and Confinement
The core discovery of the study is the evolution of confined strings across these phases. In the AFM phase ($B=0$ T), the spectrum is dominated by confined length-1 strings. However, as the material is tuned into the SDW phase ($B=0.4$ T), the dominant high-energy excitations shift to length-2 Bethe strings.
The researchers identified a characteristic "M-shaped" high-energy continuum in the SDW phase, which serves as a "smoking gun" for confined length-2 Bethe strings. The theoretical Bethe-ansatz calculations showed an excellent quantitative match with the INS experimental data across all tested phases, confirming that the 1-strings are suppressed at high energies in the SDW phase, giving way to the gapped, confined 2-string continuum.
Conclusion
This work establishes a unified picture based on Bethe strings for the spin dynamics in the different magnetic phases of $\rm YbAlO_3$. By combining high-resolution neutron scattering with advanced Bethe-ansatz calculations, the researchers demonstrated that these exotic bound states dominate the material's magnetic signature and change their behavior predictably as the system transitions through different magnetic phases. These results provide profound insight into many-body quantum magnetism and offer a roadmap for studying other non-integrable magnetic systems.
Summary updated