Schwinger-boson mean-field theory of the Heisenberg ferrimagnetic spin chain

Congjun Wu, Bin Chen, Xi Dai, Yue Yu, Zhao-Bin SuPhysical 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Schwinger-boson mean-field theory is applied to the quantum ferrimagnetic Heisenberg chain. There is a ferrimagnetic long-range order in the ground state. We observe two branches of the low-lying excitation and calculate the spin reduction, the gap of the antiferromagnetic branch, and the spin fluctuation at $T=0 \mathrm{K}.$ These results agree with the established numerical results quite well. At finite temperatures, the long-range order is destroyed because of the disappearance of the Bose condensation. The thermodynamic observables, such as the free energy, magnetic susceptibility, specific heat, and the spin correlation at $T>0 \mathrm{K},$ are calculated. The $T{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\mathrm{uni}}$ has a minimum at intermediate temperatures and the spin-correlation length behaves as ${T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ at low temperatures. These qualitatively agree with the numerical results and the difference is small at low temperatures.

Introduction

In the study of quantum magnetism, one-dimensional (1D) spin systems serve as critical models for understanding strong quantum fluctuations and exotic phases of matter. While pure ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic chains are well-documented, the Heisenberg ferrimagnetic chain—characterized by alternating spins of different magnitudes (e.g., $S^A = 1/2$ and $S^B = 1$) coupled antiferromagnetically—presents a more complex challenge. Classically, such a system exhibits a net magnetization due to the imbalance of the sublattices. However, in the quantum regime, fluctuations can significantly alter this picture.

This paper explores the application of Schwinger Boson Mean Field Theory (SBMFT) to the $(1/2, 1)$ ferrimagnetic chain. SBMFT provides a unified analytical framework to describe both the zero-temperature ground state and the finite-temperature thermodynamic properties, bridging the gap between simple spin-wave theories and computationally intensive numerical methods.

Theoretical Framework: The SBMFT Approach

The authors utilize a bosonization technique where spin operators are represented by two species of Schwinger bosons ($a$ and $b$). The Hamiltonian for the ferrimagnetic chain is expressed in terms of these bosons, subject to a local constraint: the total number of bosons at each site $i$ must equal $2S_i$.

To make the problem tractable, the authors employ a mean-field approximation:

  1. Constraints: The local constraint is replaced by a global constraint enforced by a Lagrangian multiplier, ensuring the boson number is correct on average.
  2. Bond Operators: The interaction terms are decoupled using bond operators that represent the correlations between neighboring sites.
  3. Bogoliubov Transformation: The resulting quadratic Hamiltonian is diagonalized, yielding the energy spectrum of the system's elementary excitations.

Ground State and Excitation Spectrum

At $T=0$, the SBMFT predicts the emergence of Bose condensation in the lowest energy state. This condensation is the mathematical manifestation of long-range ferrimagnetic order in the ground state.

The theory identifies two distinct branches of low-lying excitations:

  • Ferromagnetic Branch: A gapless quadratic dispersion ($\omega \sim k^2$) at low momenta, which accounts for the net magnetization and the system's response to external fields.
  • Antiferromagnetic Branch: A gapful branch representing higher-energy fluctuations.

The calculated values for the ground state are remarkably accurate when compared to numerical benchmarks. The authors found a spin reduction ($\tau$) of 0.209, which aligns closely with Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) results of 0.207. Furthermore, the calculated gap for the antiferromagnetic branch was 1.778, showing excellent agreement with the exact diagonalization value of 1.759.

Thermodynamics and Finite Temperature Behavior

As the temperature increases ($T > 0$), the Bose condensation disappears. This is a crucial result consistent with the Mermin-Wagner theorem, which forbids spontaneous breaking of continuous symmetry in 1D systems at finite temperatures. Consequently, the long-range order is replaced by short-range correlations.

Key thermodynamic findings include:

  • Susceptibility: The product of temperature and uniform magnetic susceptibility ($T\chi_{uni}$) exhibits a characteristic minimum at intermediate temperatures. This minimum arises from the competition between the ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic excitation branches.
  • Correlation Length: The spin correlation length $\xi$ scales as $T^{-1}$ at low temperatures, matching the behavior predicted by numerical studies.
  • Specific Heat: The specific heat $C$ scales as $T^{1/2}$ at low temperatures, a signature of the ferrimagnetic nature of the chain.

Limitations and Conclusions

While SBMFT is highly successful at low temperatures, it faces limitations as the system heats up. The mean-field approximation eventually breaks down (around $T \approx 1.38$ in the units used), where the order parameter vanishes and the theory fails to accurately describe the local moment phase. Additionally, because the theory only enforces boson constraints on average, it tends to overcount the physical degrees of freedom, requiring a correction factor (the Arovas-Auerbach factor) to align the ground state energy with numerical data.

Despite these constraints, the SBMFT provides a powerful, physically intuitive description of the Heisenberg ferrimagnetic chain. It successfully captures the dual nature of the system—combining ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic characteristics—and provides a consistent analytical path from the ordered ground state to the disordered finite-temperature regime.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Schwinger-boson mean-field theory is applied to the quantum ferrimagnetic Heisenberg chain. There is a ferrimagnetic long-range order in the ground state. We observe two branches of the low-lying excitation and calculate the spin reduction, the gap of the antiferromagnetic branch, and the spin fluctuation at $T=0 \mathrm{K}.$ These results agree with the established numerical results quite well. At finite temperatures, the long-range order is destroyed because of the disappearance of the Bose condensation. The thermodynamic observables, such as the free energy, magnetic susceptibility, specific heat, and the spin correlation at $T>0 \mathrm{K},$ are calculated. The $T{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\mathrm{uni}}$ has a minimum at intermediate temperatures and the spin-correlation length behaves as ${T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ at low temperatures. These qualitatively agree with the numerical results and the difference is small at low temperatures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu1999schwinger,
  author = {Congjun Wu and Bin Chen and Xi Dai and Yue Yu and Zhao-Bin Su},
  title = {{Schwinger-boson mean-field theory of the Heisenberg ferrimagnetic spin chain}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.60.1057},
}
Figure