Confinement Effects and Acid Strength in Zeolites

Emanuele Grifoni, GiovanniMaria Piccini, Johannes A. Lercher, Vassiliki‐Alexandra Glezakou, Roger Rousseau, Michele Parrinello

Abstract

Chemical reactivity and sorption in zeolites is coupled to confinement and—to a lesser extent—to the acid strength of Brønsted acid sites (BAS). In the presence of water, zeolite BAS eventually convert into hydronium ions. This study examines the gradual transition from BAS to hydronium ions in zeolites of varying pore size using ab initio molecular dynamics combined with enhanced sampling. While at low water content (1–2 water/BAS) acidic protons are shared between the zeolite and water, higher water contents ($n > 2$) lead to proton solvation within a localized water cluster. At low loadings, the free energy is dominated by enthalpy and associated with acid strength and local space. Conversely, entropy increases linearly with water concentration, favoring proton solvation independently of pore size or shape.

Introduction: The Role of Water and Confinement

Zeolites are essential solid acid catalysts in the petrochemical industry, utilized for fuel refining and plastic production. Their catalytic activity stems from Brønsted acid sites (BAS)—protons associated with aluminum-doped silicate frameworks. In industrial applications, water is frequently present, clustering around these sites and eventually facilitating the transfer of the proton to form a hydronium ion ($H_3O^+$).

A long-standing debate in zeolite science concerns how the confinement within microscopic pores influences this process. This research addresses the fundamental thermodynamics of the BAS-to-hydronium transition, aiming to decouple the influence of the zeolite framework from the intrinsic properties of the water clusters themselves.

Computational Methodology

The researchers utilized a multi-faceted computational approach to model these complex interactions:

  • Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD): Employing Density Functional Theory (PBE functional) to calculate electronic structures at each step, allowing for the accurate modeling of bond breaking and formation during proton transfer.
  • Well-Tempered Metadynamics: To overcome the "rare event" nature of proton transfer on picosecond timescales, a bias potential was applied to explore the full free energy landscape.
  • Collective Variables (CVs): Descriptors for the protonation state ($s_p$) and charge carrier distance ($s_d$) were used to map the transition from a bound proton to a solvated hydronium ion.

The study investigated four zeolite frameworks with diverse architectures: GIS (small cavities), CHA (medium cages), MFI (interconnecting channels), and FAU (large supercages), with water loadings ranging from 1 to 8 molecules per BAS.

Key Insights: A Universal Solvation Behavior

The most significant finding is the emergence of a "universal" solvation curve. While initial acid strengths vary by framework at low water content ($n=1$), the change in free energy as more water is added is consistent across all zeolites. When adjusted for initial framework-specific binding, the energy curves collapse into a single line, suggesting that the local water environment, rather than the zeolite cage, primarily dictates acid strength in humid conditions.

Structural model of an 8-water cluster solvating a proton within a zeolite pore.

Analysis of the water clusters' "sphericity" indicates they closely resemble gas-phase water clusters. The zeolite pore acts as a passive container rather than an active template for cluster geometry. This is supported by similarity metrics ($\psi$) comparing confined clusters to reference gas-phase structures across different frameworks.

Similarity metrics of water clusters in various zeolite frameworks compared to gas-phase clusters.

Thermodynamic Drivers of Protolysis

The study identifies a three-state transition:

  1. State A: Proton bound to the zeolite framework.
  2. State B: A Zundel-like state where the proton is shared between the zeolite and water.
  3. State C: A fully solvated hydronium ion within the water cluster.

Complete proton dissociation (protolysis) typically occurs at a threshold of 4 water molecules. Thermodynamically, entropy is the primary driver of this process. While the enthalpic benefit plateaus after 3 water molecules, entropy increases linearly with the number of waters at a rate of approximately -4.0 kJ/mol per water molecule. This entropic slope is independent of pore size, ranging from 0.5 nm to 1.1 nm.

Conclusions and Future Outlook

The research demonstrates that at higher water loadings, the zeolite's role in determining acid strength diminishes as the entropic contributions of the water cluster take over. However, the authors note that these findings were obtained using a low concentration of acid sites (Al:Si = 1:95). In aluminum-rich zeolites, overlapping water clusters might alter this universal behavior.

Future investigations could extend this metadynamics framework to study how organic reactants interact with these water clusters, providing critical insights for designing catalysts for "wet" chemical processes, such as biomass conversion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Chemical reactivity and sorption in zeolites is coupled to confinement and - to a lesser extent- to the acid strength of Brønsted acid sites (BAS). In presence of water the zeolite Brønsted acid sites eventually convert into hydronium ions. The gradual transition from zeolite Brønsted acid sites to hydronium ions conversion in zeolites of varying pore size is examined by ab initio molecular dynamics combined with enhanced sampling based on well-tempered metadynamics and a recently developed set of collective variables. While at low water content (1-2 water/BAS) the acidic protons prefer to be shared between zeolites and water, higher water contents (n>2) invariably lead to solvation of the protons within a localized water cluster adjacent to the BAS. At low water loadings the standard free energy of the formed complexes is dominated by enthalpy and is associated with the acid strength of the BAS and the space around the site. Conversely, the entropy increases linearly with the concentration of waters in the pores, favors proton solvation and is independent of the pore size/shape.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{grifoni2021confinement,
  author = {Emanuele Grifoni and GiovanniMaria Piccini and Johannes A. Lercher and Vassiliki‐Alexandra Glezakou and Roger Rousseau and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Confinement Effects and Acid Strength in Zeolites}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-22936-0},
}
Figure