Abstract
Aluminosilicate zeolites are traditionally used in high-temperature applications at low water vapour pressures where the zeolite framework is generally considered to be stable and static. Increasingly, zeolites are being considered for applications under milder aqueous conditions. However, it has not yet been established how neutral liquid water at mild conditions affects the stability of the zeolite framework. Here, we show that covalent bonds in the zeolite chabazite (CHA) are labile when in contact with neutral liquid water, which leads to partial but fully reversible hydrolysis without framework degradation. We present ab initio calculations that predict novel, energetically viable reaction mechanisms by which Al-O and Si-O bonds rapidly and reversibly break at 300 K. By means of solid-state NMR, we confirm this prediction, demonstrating that isotopic substitution of <sup>17</sup>O in the zeolitic framework occurs at room temperature in less than one hour of contact with enriched water.
Introduction: Beyond the Static Framework
For decades, the chemical industry has treated aluminosilicate zeolites as rigid, "rock-like" mineral frameworks. Their stability under harsh, high-temperature conditions has made them indispensable as catalysts and ion exchangers. However, as the focus of chemical engineering shifts toward aqueous-phase processing—such as biomass refining or the "ADOR" (Assembly-Disassembly-Organization-Reassembly) synthesis method—the fundamental assumption of a static framework is being challenged.
This research addresses a critical gap in our understanding: how neutral liquid water at room temperature interacts with the covalent Si–O and Al–O bonds of a zeolite. If these bonds are not as permanent as once thought, it fundamentally changes our models for molecular diffusion and reactivity within these porous crystals.
Methodology: A Dual Computational and Experimental Approach
To investigate the potential lability of the zeolite framework, the study employed a synergistic approach combining advanced theoretical modeling with high-resolution spectroscopy.
Structural Modeling
The research focused on the chabazite (CHA) framework, a common zeolite topology. The structural models were sourced from the International Zeolite Association (IZA) database, specifically examining SSZ-13 (an aluminosilicate with the CHA topology) with a Si/Al ratio of 11.
Computational Analysis
The team utilized biased ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations. By applying thermodynamic integration, they mapped the free energy landscape of bond-cleavage events. This allowed for the identification of specific reaction pathways that would be energetically accessible at room temperature.
Experimental Validation
To provide physical evidence of bond breaking, the researchers used solid-state NMR spectroscopy ($^{17}O$, $^{27}Al$, and $^{29}Si$). By submerging the zeolite in $^{17}O$-enriched water, they could track the incorporation of the rare oxygen isotope into the framework. Any signal appearing in the framework region of the NMR spectrum serves as definitive proof that the original framework oxygen atoms were replaced by oxygen from the surrounding water.
The "Axial" Mechanism: A Low-Energy Path to Lability
The most significant theoretical discovery was a novel "axial" mechanism for bond cleavage. Unlike previously proposed "equatorial" mechanisms, which required high activation energies (160–200 kJ/mol), the axial mechanism utilizes a chain of water molecules acting as a proton shuttle—a Grotthuss-type mechanism.
This mechanism significantly lowers the free energy barrier to approximately 63 kJ/mol for Si–O bonds and even lower for Al–O bonds. Crucially, this process requires the density of liquid water to form the necessary molecular chains; the same rapid exchange is not observed with water vapor.
Key Results and Insights
- Rapid Isotopic Exchange: Experimental NMR data confirmed that $^{17}O$ incorporation into the zeolite framework occurs in less than one hour at 300 K. This confirms that the framework is in a state of dynamic equilibrium, constantly breaking and reforming bonds.
- Site Preference: Initial exchange occurs more rapidly at Si–O–Al sites compared to Si–O–Si sites, although both types of bonds eventually participate in the exchange process.
- Reversible Hydrolysis: Despite the constant breaking of covalent bonds, the process is fully reversible. The zeolite does not dissolve or undergo framework degradation. $^{29}Si$ and $^{27}Al$ NMR confirmed that the long-range crystallinity and tetrahedral coordination remained intact even after 200 days of submersion.
Discussion: The "Shimmering" Framework
The realization that zeolites are "labile" at room temperature has profound implications for catalysis and materials science. The presence of transient hydroxyl groups—temporary breaks in the framework—likely influences how guest molecules move through the pores and interact with active sites.
While this study focused on the CHA topology, the authors suggest that this lability is a universal characteristic of aluminosilicate zeolites. Future research will need to explore how different topologies and ring sizes affect these rates and, more importantly, how this "shimmering" framework impacts real-world catalytic selectivity and diffusion in industrial applications.
Summary updated