Computing Urban Fabric of a Historical Town

Naai-Jung Shih, Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Yi Chen, Pei-Huang DiaoCATA 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Traditional urban planning often relies on static 2D maps and Geographic Information Systems (GIS) that prioritize permanent building boundaries. However, in living heritage sites like the historical town of Lukang, Taiwan, the "real" streetscape is defined by a "second contour"—a fuzzy, ever-changing layer of temporary installations, including retractable weather shields, commercial signage, and illegal extensions. While these additions are vital for local economic survival, they often conflict with preservation goals. This research introduces a quantitative method to assess these "micro-expressions" of urban fabric using high-precision 3D laser scanning.

Methodology: Quantifying the 2nd Contour

The study employed a multi-stage digital approach to capture and analyze approximately 2,500 meters of historical streets in Lukang.

  1. 3D Laser Scanning: Using a Faro Focus 3D® scanner, researchers generated a high-density point cloud. This data provides a level of realism—capturing light, shadow, and complex geometries—that traditional CAD models cannot replicate.
  2. Sectional Analysis: The point cloud was sliced both horizontally and vertically. Horizontal slices reveal how building boundaries shift from the ground up, while vertical sections illustrate the "openness" of the street.
  3. The Modification Ratio: This core metric is calculated by dividing the projected area of additive building parts (the "2nd contour") by the total projected facade area.
  4. Typology Classification: Street profiles were categorized into five types: U, convex (凸), T, enclosed (□), and L. This helps visualize how additions transform an open corridor (U-type) into a covered, tunnel-like space (□-type).
3D scanning path and point cloud visualization of Lukang's historical streets.

Key Insights: Zoning and Urban Identity

The research suggests that these temporary additions are not merely clutter but are essential expressions of the town's identity. Features like lanterns near temples or mobile booths in markets create a unique local character that attracts tourism.

However, the modification ratio is heavily influenced by urban zoning. Commercial districts tend to "intrude" into public space to maximize business area, pushing "U" shaped street profiles toward "T" or "凸" shapes as owners add rain shields and signage to invite pedestrians into recessed storefronts. In contrast, residential areas maintain lower modification ratios to preserve living quality.

Results and Temporal Evolution

The study's findings highlight a clear distinction between functional zones:

  • Commercial Dominance: The highest modification ratios (reaching nearly 20%) were found in commercial districts near traditional markets.
  • Residential Stability: Preservation and residential districts showed minimal change, with ratios often below 5%.
  • Quantifiable Enclosure: Commercial activity effectively narrows the perceived width of the street, turning public thoroughfares into semi-private pedestrian zones.

To verify these horizontal changes over time, the researchers analyzed satellite imagery from 2002 to 2018. This temporal data confirmed a marked increase in facade complexity corresponding to intensified commercial activities.

Satellite imagery time series (2002-2018) showing urban fabric evolution in Lukang.

Conclusion

While this study successfully quantifies the physical evolution of the urban fabric, the authors note that social and environmental dimensions require further exploration. Future work should investigate how these "2nd contours" affect microclimates and whether over-commercialization might eventually erode the very cultural industry it seeks to support. Balancing economic vitality with the preservation of the social fabric remains the critical challenge for sustainable heritage development.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shih2020computing,
  author = {Naai-Jung Shih and Cheng-Yu Hsieh and Yi Chen and Pei-Huang Diao},
  title = {{Computing Urban Fabric of a Historical Town}},
  booktitle = {CATA},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.29007/9sk3},
}
Figure