Introduction
Urban centers globally face a dual mandate: achieving aggressive decarbonization targets while preserving irreplaceable cultural heritage. Historic districts are frequently perceived as obstacles to energy efficiency. Standard retrofit measures—such as external wall insulation or modern HVAC installations—can irreparably damage the "spirit" and physical fabric of protected buildings. This "tug-of-war" often leaves planners without clear, evidence-based tools to navigate the complex regulatory and aesthetic constraints of historic zones.
Existing Urban Building Energy Models (UBEMs) typically treat building stocks as homogenous data blocks, overlooking the nuanced statutory conservation levels that dictate what can and cannot be modified. This research introduces a novel UBEM framework that bridges the gap between quantitative energy simulation and qualitative heritage preservation, using Shanghai’s iconic Wukang Road district as a primary case study.
Methodology and Data Integration
The proposed framework operates in three distinct stages, integrating geospatial data with heritage regulations to create a constraint-aware simulation environment.
Data Acquisition and Morphological Modelling
The study utilized a combination of GIS data from BaiduMap and AMap alongside high-resolution satellite imagery to extract building footprints and functions. A key technical challenge was determining building heights for the 3D district model. The researchers employed "geometric inversion," a technique that calculates height based on shadow length and solar angle at specific times.
As shown in the data breakdown, the Wukang Road area comprises a diverse mix of 1,047 buildings, dominated by commercial and industrial types, alongside domestic and office spaces. Thermal properties were estimated by cross-referencing building construction eras with Chinese building design standards from 1980 through 2015.
Tiered Heritage Classification and Retrofit Assignment
The core innovation of this framework is the classification of buildings into four protection categories: Protected, Retained Historical, General Historical, and Other. Rather than applying a "one-size-fits-all" upgrade, interventions were strictly regulated by these levels:
- Protected buildings: No interventions were permitted to ensure zero impact on the historic fabric.
- Retained buildings: Limited to lighting upgrades.
- General Historical: Received internal insulation and lighting upgrades, preserving the exterior facade.
- Other: Received comprehensive envelope and HVAC system upgrades.
Dynamic, hourly energy simulations were then conducted using EnergyPlus to compare the baseline state against the proposed retrofit scenarios.
Key Insights and Results
The simulation results demonstrate that heritage constraints do not preclude significant sustainability gains. By "operationalizing" qualitative heritage values into quantitative parameters, the model identifies a "middle path" for urban renewal.
Quantitative Energy Savings
The district-wide impact of the tiered retrofit strategy was substantial:
- Heating Demand: Reduced by up to 44.86% across the district, with individual domestic buildings achieving savings as high as 53%.
- Cooling Demand: Decreased by 31.28%.
- Total Electricity Use: Lowered by 23.66%.
Interestingly, industrial buildings showed the highest potential for cooling intensity reduction (nearly 40%), largely because they often face fewer aesthetic restrictions compared to residential villas, allowing for more aggressive envelope upgrades.
The "General Historic" Opportunity
A critical finding is the role of "General Historic" buildings. These structures offer the optimal balance of impact and effort; they allow for internal thermal upgrades that yield massive energy gains while maintaining a streetscape that remains visually identical to its historical state. Furthermore, the baseline analysis highlighted that many historic buildings already possess inherent "passive" advantages, such as high thermal mass, which the UBEM framework accounts for before suggesting active mechanical interventions.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This research proves that integrating heritage conservation into energy modelling provides a replicable tool for balancing decarbonization with cultural preservation. It allows planners to perform a "spatial reading" of energy, identifying which blocks are energy-intensive and which are "locked" by high protection levels.
While the current model relies on secondary data and does not yet account for resident behavior or the "rebound effect," it sets the stage for future developments. The authors suggest that integrating Digital Twins and AI could further refine the model, allowing for the simulation of advanced micro-interventions like vacuum-insulated panels or solar PVs designed to mimic traditional roofing materials. Ultimately, this framework supports context-sensitive, evidence-based decision-making for the sustainable management of historic urban landscapes.
Summary updated