Abstract Vernacular architecture has always captured professionals’ attention for its unique approaches to construction and its integration of man and nature. Lilong houses (or Shikumen houses) are representative of Shanghai vernacular housing, combining traditional Chinese courtyard houses with Western townhouses. While UAV oblique photogrammetry has been applied to historic preservation in China, literature on Lilong houses remains scant. This research attempts to preserve and document Lilong houses using UAV-based 3D modeling, exploring a rational approach for narrow urban lanes. Using Meilan Lane as a case study, flight routes and angles were designed via AutoCAD and programmed into GoodStation. A total of 4,531 photos were processed to build four models at macro (40m–115m) and micro (20m–32m) levels. This paper elaborates on the pros and cons of UAV techniques for documenting Lilong residences and establishes an applicable approach for comprehensive heritage studies.
Introduction
Lilong housing represents a unique architectural fusion built primarily between 1876 and 1910. Today, these structures face dual threats: rapid urban decay and unauthorized modifications. Traditional documentation methods—manual measurement and on-site photography—are labor-intensive and often fail to capture the "top-down" perspective necessary for comprehensive preservation.
The physical environment of a Lilong complex presents significant challenges for standard aerial mapping. Lanes are extremely narrow, buildings are relatively tall (approx. 12.5m), and the airspace is cluttered with power lines, laundry poles, and thick tree canopies. This research seeks a "rational approach" to navigate these constraints and produce accurate digital twins for heritage conservation.
Methodology
The study employed an iterative, three-round experimental design to refine data collection using a DJI Mini 2 UAV, chosen for its small footprint and compliance with local flight regulations.
- Flight Planning: Initial routes were designed in AutoCAD to account for the "canyon" effect of the narrow lanes. Parameters such as speed, camera angles, and intervals were programmed into GoodStation to automate the drone’s path.
- Iterative Refinement: Initial rounds (30m to 118m) identified critical failures, such as image distortion on southern façades and obscurity caused by deep shadows.
- Optimized Workflow: The final phase utilized a multi-level approach: Macro-level flights at 40m and 115m for urban context, and Micro-level flights (20m–32m) specifically for the narrow lanes to capture architectural nuances.
Key Insights and Results
Overcoming Environmental Constraints
The researchers found that the height-to-width ratio of the lanes required a specialized 12-route flight design. This included "square tours" for roofs and specific flights along building footprints to capture façades while avoiding obstacles. Furthermore, the study concluded that cloudy days are superior to sunny days for photogrammetry in dense environments to avoid harsh shadows. A specific "seasonal window" (December to February) was identified as ideal, as local Platanus trees lose their leaves, making building envelopes fully visible.
Efficiency and Fidelity
The UAV workflow proved significantly more efficient than traditional methods, requiring only two people and four days to generate a complete model suite—a task that would take five people roughly two weeks using terrestrial reconnaissance. The resulting micro-level models provided enough resolution to assist craftsmen in locating degraded bricks, rotting window frames, and damaged gutters. Notably, the models successfully documented unauthorized third-floor additions and makeshift roof structures often hidden from ground-level inspection.
Conclusion and Future Work
This research demonstrates that a dual-height UAV approach is necessary to satisfy both urban planners and conservation architects. While the reliance on specific weather and seasonal windows presents a limitation, the efficiency gains are undeniable. Future work will focus on establishing a "data bank" of Lilong houses to support lifecycle management, tracking how these historic structures evolve or disappear during Shanghai's ongoing urban regeneration.
Summary updated