Composite Genus One Belyi Maps

Raimundas Vidūnas, Yang‐Hui He

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a powerful "composition" method to explicitly compute genus one Belyi maps—complex mathematical functions that link number theory to geometry. By combining simpler genus zero maps with elliptic curve coverings and isogenies, the authors provide the explicit algebraic equations for "brane tilings," which are essential for describing supersymmetric gauge theories in theoretical physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

At the heart of this paper is Belyi’s Theorem, a profound result in mathematics stating that any smooth, compact algebraic curve defined over the field of algebraic numbers ($\overline{\mathbb{Q}}$) can be uniquely represented by a rational map to the Riemann sphere ($\mathbb{P}^1$) that branches at only three points: $\{0, 1, \infty\}$.

The pre-image of the line segment $[0, 1]$ under such a map creates a bipartite graph on the surface of the curve, famously called a dessin d’enfant (child’s drawing) by Alexander Grothendieck. While the theory is elegant, finding the explicit algebraic equations for these maps—especially for genus one curves (tori/elliptic curves)—is notoriously difficult.

In theoretical physics, these dessins are known as brane tilings. They are not just pretty pictures; they encode the entire structure of 4D supersymmetric gauge theories derived from string theory. Physicists have long had catalogues of these tilings but lacked the explicit Belyi maps (the "Belyi pairs") needed to fully understand the underlying geometry and physical properties like R-charges.

Methods

The authors bypass the "formidable task" of direct computation by using a composition strategy. Instead of building a genus one map from scratch, they use two primary techniques:

  1. Composition with Genus 0 Maps: They start with a known genus zero Belyi map $\phi_0$ (defined on the sphere). They then compose this with a quadratic covering map $\pi: E \to \mathbb{P}^1$ from an elliptic curve $E$. If the four branching points of the elliptic curve are chosen to coincide with the branching fibers of the genus zero map, the result is a valid genus one Belyi map.
  2. Isogenies: An isogeny is a special kind of map between two elliptic curves that preserves their group structure. By composing an existing genus one Belyi map with an isogeny, the authors can "scale up" to much higher-degree maps (e.g., degree 24) while maintaining explicit control over the equations.

To find the initial genus zero maps, they utilized a specialized Maple program designed for computing Belyi maps with nearly regular "branching passports."

Datasets

The paper does not use traditional machine learning datasets. Instead, it relies on two mathematical benchmarks:

  • The Brane Tiling Catalogue: Specifically, the classification of tilings with up to 6 nodes in the fundamental region (Davey et al., 2010).
  • Genus 0 Belyi Map Databases: The authors draw from existing libraries of computed genus zero maps (degree $\le 60$) to serve as the "building blocks" for their compositions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "X-only" Shortcut: Many complex genus one Belyi maps can be expressed purely as functions of the $x$-coordinate of the elliptic curve in its Weierstrass form. This significantly simplifies the algebra.
  • Isogeny as a Power Tool: The paper demonstrates that isogenies are not just abstract morphisms but practical tools for generating "isogenous versions" of gauge theories, allowing researchers to explore families of related physical models.
  • Galois Asymmetry: A surprising insight is that the "consistency" of a gauge theory (a physical requirement) is not necessarily invariant under the action of the Galois group on the dessin. This suggests a deep, yet-to-be-fully-explored tension between the arithmetic of the map and the physics of the theory.
  • Geometric Realism: The authors show that the $j$-invariant of the elliptic curve (which defines its shape) is physically significant, refuting earlier conjectures that the graph's embedding was purely combinatorial.

Key Results

The authors successfully constructed a "wealth" of explicit Belyi pairs for theories that were previously only known as combinatorial graphs.

  • New Explicit Maps: They provided the first explicit algebraic realizations for several important models, including $dP_3(I)$, $L^{222}(II)$, and $F_0(II)$.
  • High-Degree Constructions: The method reached degrees as high as 24, moving well beyond the simple examples previously found in the physics literature.
  • Comprehensive Appendix: The paper includes a 6-page appendix mapping specific algebraic equations to their corresponding doubly periodic tilings (dessins), creating a "Rosetta Stone" for researchers in the field.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Automation Gaps: While the composition method is efficient, simplifying the resulting equations into a "canonical" Weierstrass form remains a manual and "cumbersome" process that is not yet fully automated.
  • Physical Inconsistency: Some of the mathematical dessins correspond to "inconsistent" gauge theories. The authors note that the relationship between Galois action and physical consistency remains an open problem.
  • Seiberg Duality: Future work is suggested to explore how "cluster transformations" (or Seiberg duality in physics) relate to the $j$-invariant and Galois conjugation of these maps.

Reference: Vidunas, R., & He, Y.-H. (2016). Composite Genus One Belyi Maps. arXiv:1610.08075v2 [math.AG].

Summary updated

Abstract

Motivated by a demand for explicit genus 1 Belyi maps from theoretical physics, we give an efficient method of explicitly computing genus one Belyi maps by (1) composing covering maps from elliptic curves to the Riemann sphere with simpler (univariate) genus zero Belyi maps, as well as by (2) composing further with isogenies between elliptic curves. This gives many new explicit dessins on the doubly periodic plane, including several which have been realized in the physics literature as so-called brane-tilings in the context of quiver gauge theories.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vidunas2018composite,
  author = {Raimundas Vidūnas and Yang‐Hui He},
  title = {{Composite Genus One Belyi Maps}},
  booktitle = {Indagationes},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.indag.2018.02.001},
}

Loading related content...

Figure