Composite genus one Belyi maps

Raimundas Vidūnas, Yang‐Hui He

TL;DR

This paper presents an efficient method for constructing genus one Belyi maps, which are fundamental objects in algebraic geometry with deep connections to theoretical physics. By composing simpler maps and utilizing isogenies between elliptic curves, the authors generate a rich collection of new Belyi maps, many of which correspond to "brane tilings" in supersymmetric gauge theories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Belyi's theorem states that any algebraic curve defined over the rational numbers can be represented as a branched covering of the complex plane (specifically, the Riemann sphere). These coverings, called Belyi maps, are characterized by having branch points only at 0, 1, and ∞. The "dessins d'enfants" (children's drawings) are a visual representation of these maps as bipartite graphs on Riemann surfaces.

While Belyi maps for genus zero curves are relatively well-understood, constructing them for genus one curves (elliptic curves) is significantly more challenging. This difficulty has been a bottleneck for exploring the connections between algebraic geometry and theoretical physics, particularly in the context of "brane tilings" which are bipartite graphs on elliptic curves that encode supersymmetric gauge theories. The problem is to find explicit constructions for these genus one Belyi maps, which are crucial for understanding the underlying physics.

Methods

The authors propose two primary methods for constructing genus one Belyi maps:

  1. Composition with Genus 0 Maps: They leverage existing genus 0 Belyi maps and compose them with quadratic coverings of the Riemann sphere that branch over four points. This technique allows for the generation of genus one Belyi maps where the map's expression depends only on the x-coordinate of the elliptic curve.
  2. Composition with Isogenies: They utilize isogenies between elliptic curves. An isogeny is a structure-preserving map between elliptic curves that is also a covering map. By composing genus one Belyi maps with isogenies, they can generate new genus one Belyi maps, effectively exploring different "versions" of the same underlying mathematical structure.

The paper also details computational aspects, including the use of Maple programs to compute Belyi maps and the challenges associated with simplifying and canonicalizing elliptic curve equations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constructions and explicit examples rather than empirical evaluation on datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Composition as a Powerful Tool: The paper demonstrates that simple composition of existing genus 0 Belyi maps with specific quadratic coverings is a highly effective and efficient method for generating a large number of new genus one Belyi maps.
  • Isogenies Reveal Deeper Structures: The use of isogenies reveals that different Belyi maps can be related through these structure-preserving maps between elliptic curves, highlighting a deeper underlying symmetry.
  • Connection to Brane Tilings: Many of the newly constructed genus one Belyi maps correspond to "brane tilings" found in the physics literature, providing explicit mathematical realizations for these theoretical constructs. This bridges the gap between abstract mathematical objects and concrete physical models.
  • Computational Challenges: The paper acknowledges the non-triviality of simplifying and canonicalizing elliptic curve equations, which is a significant hurdle in the explicit construction of Belyi maps.

Key Results

  • The paper provides an efficient method for explicitly computing genus one Belyi maps.
  • It generates numerous new explicit genus one Belyi maps, including those with degrees 10, 12, 14, 16, and 18.
  • Several of these new maps are identified as corresponding to known "brane tilings" in the context of supersymmetric gauge theories, offering explicit mathematical descriptions for these physical models.
  • The paper presents a comprehensive catalogue of these constructed Belyi maps, their corresponding dessins, and their associated gauge theories.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the methods are efficient, the simplification and canonicalization of elliptic curve equations remain a computationally challenging problem.
  • Completeness: The paper acknowledges that this is an ongoing study, and there is potential for further exploration and computation of Belyi maps.
  • Galois Action and Physics: The authors note that the relationship between the Galois action on dessins and the consistency of the corresponding gauge theories is an open question.
  • Cluster Transformations and Seiberg Duality: The paper raises questions about how cluster transformations and Seiberg duality in quantum field theory affect the j-invariant of elliptic curves and the associated dessins.
  • Future Work: The authors mention upcoming work that will expand the catalogue of Belyi maps and companion elliptic curves, suggesting a continued effort in this area. They also highlight the need for further research into the implications of Galois conjugation in quivers and the role of dessins in theoretical physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motivated by a demand for explicit genus 1 Belyi maps from theoretical physics, we give an efficient method of explicitly computing genus one Belyi maps by (1) composing covering maps from elliptic curves to the Riemann sphere with simpler (univariate) genus zero Belyi maps, as well as by (2) composing further with isogenies between elliptic curves. This gives many new explicit dessins on the doubly periodic plane, including several which have been realized in the physics literature as so-called brane-tilings in the context of quiver gauge theories.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vidunas2018composite,
  author = {Raimundas Vidūnas and Yang‐Hui He},
  title = {{Composite genus one Belyi maps}},
  booktitle = {Indagationes},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.indag.2018.02.001},
}
Figure