Comparison of the effects of reef and anthropogenic soundscapes on oyster larvae settlement

Sarah Schmidlin, Clea Parcerisas, Jeroen Hubert, Maryann S. Watson, Jan Mees, Dick Botteldooren, Paul Devos, Elisabeth Debusschere, Pascal I. HablützelScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract: Settlement is a critical period in the life cycle of marine invertebrates with a planktonic larval stage. For reef-building invertebrates such as oysters and corals, settlement rates are predictive for long-term reef survival. Increasing evidence suggests that marine invertebrates use information from ocean soundscapes to inform settlement decisions. Sessile marine invertebrates with a planktonic stage are particularly reliant on environmental cues to direct them to ideal habitats. As gregarious settlers, oysters prefer to settle amongst members of the same species. It has been hypothesized that oyster larvae from species Crassostrea virginica and Ostrea angasi use distinct conspecific oyster reef sounds to navigate to ideal habitats. In controlled laboratory experiments we exposed Pacific Oyster Magallana gigas larvae to anthropogenic sounds from conspecific oyster reefs, vessels, combined reef-vessel sounds as well as off-reef and no speaker controls. Our findings show that sounds recorded at conspecific reefs induced higher percentages of settlement by about 1.44 and 1.64 times compared to off-reef and no speaker controls, respectively. In contrast, the settlement increase compared to the no speaker control was non-significant for vessel sounds (1.21 fold), combined reef-vessel sounds (1.30 fold), and off-reef sounds (1.18 fold). This study serves as a foundational stepping stone for exploring larval sound feature preferences within this species.

TL;DR

Oyster larvae are more than just passive drifters; they use the "symphony" of a healthy reef to decide where to call home. This study demonstrates that Pacific oyster (Magallana gigas) larvae settle at significantly higher rates when exposed to reef soundscapes, while anthropogenic vessel noise may disrupt this process by masking these vital acoustic cues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For reef-building invertebrates like oysters, the transition from a free-swimming planktonic larva to a stationary benthic adult—known as settlement—is the most high-stakes decision of their lives. Picking a suboptimal location can lead to mortality before reproduction. While scientists have long known that larvae use chemical and physical cues to find habitats, the role of "soundscapes" is a newer frontier in marine ecology.

The authors address a critical gap: does the Pacific oyster (Magallana gigas), a major ecosystem engineer and aquaculture species, use sound to navigate? Furthermore, in an increasingly noisy ocean, does human-made (anthropogenic) noise like vessel traffic interfere with this biological "GPS"? Understanding these dynamics is essential for both conservation and the success of reef restoration projects.

Methods

The researchers conducted controlled laboratory playback experiments using a sophisticated tank setup designed to minimize acoustic interference and reflections.

  • The Setup: Five 100L tanks were utilized. Four were equipped with underwater speakers (Lubell UW30) playing specific sound treatments, while one served as a silent "no-speaker" control to establish a baseline.
  • Acoustic Treatments: The team used high-quality field recordings from the North Sea (Belgian and Dutch coasts) to create five distinct scenarios:
  • Reef: Sounds from healthy, conspecific oyster reefs.
  • Vessel: Noise from passing ships.
  • Reef + Vessel: An artificial overlay of both.
  • Off-reef: Ambient sounds from sandy, non-reef areas.
  • No speaker: The baseline lab environment.
  • The Subjects: Pediveliger larvae (the final larval stage ready to settle) were placed in jars with oyster shell fragments as a substrate. After 24 hours of exposure, the team counted how many larvae had successfully "cemented" themselves to the shells.
  • Analysis: Beyond measuring volume (Sound Pressure Level), the authors used advanced metrics like the Acoustic Complexity Index (ACI) and Acoustic Diversity Index (ADI) to quantify the "texture" and temporal patterns of the soundscapes.
Schematic of the experimental laboratory setup, including the top view of the tank and the arrangement of speakers and larval jars.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complexity over Volume: The most striking finding was that reef sounds were unique not just in volume, but in their acoustic complexity (high ACI). This suggests that larvae aren't just looking for "loud" places; they are tuning into the specific, complex temporal patterns created by the biological activity of a healthy reef, such as snapping shrimp or fish vocalizations.
  • Vessel Noise is "Neutral" but Noisy: Interestingly, vessel noise alone didn't significantly repel the larvae compared to the control. However, it failed to provide the attractive cues found in reef sounds.
  • The Masking Effect: When vessel noise was added to reef sounds, the settlement rate dropped by approximately 1.29 times compared to pure reef sounds. This points toward acoustic masking: the biological "signal" of the healthy reef gets buried under the "noise" of the ship, making the ideal habitat harder for larvae to detect.
  • Species Specificity: While previous studies on other oyster species (e.g., C. virginica) showed a preference for high-volume sounds, this study suggests M. gigas might be more sensitive to the diversity and complexity of the soundscape.
Comparison of acoustic indices (ACI, ADI, AEI) and power spectral density (PSD) across treatments, highlighting the differences between field recordings and laboratory tank playbacks.

Key Results

  • Reef Attraction: Sounds recorded at oyster reefs induced 1.44 to 1.64 times higher settlement compared to off-reef and no-speaker controls, respectively.
  • Statistical Significance: The increase in settlement for reef sounds was statistically significant (p < 0.05). In contrast, the increases for vessel sounds (1.21 fold) and combined reef-vessel sounds (1.30 fold) were not statistically significant, suggesting they do not provide a strong enough cue for settlement.
  • Acoustic Fingerprint: Reef treatments consistently showed the highest ACI and ADI values across all batches, confirming that biological reefs produce a distinctively "busy" and complex acoustic environment that larvae can distinguish from ambient ocean noise.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors are transparent about the challenges of "tank acoustics." In small tanks, sound reflects off walls, and "particle motion"—the physical vibration of water molecules which oysters likely "feel" rather than "hear" via pressure—is much harder to control and measure than sound pressure.

Future Directions: 1. Field Validation: The next step is to move out of the lab. Researchers aim to test if "acoustic enrichment" (playing reef sounds through underwater speakers) can jumpstart restoration on degraded or newly constructed reefs. 2. Particle Motion: Future studies need to quantify the physical vibration of the water particles to better understand the sensory world of the oyster larva. 3. Long-term Exposure: This study looked at a 24-hour window; understanding how chronic noise pollution affects long-term population dynamics and recruitment remains a high priority for marine conservationists.

This research provides a foundational stepping stone for using sound as a tool in marine conservation, suggesting that if we want to restore our oceans, we might need to start by listening to them.

Summary updated

Abstract

Settlement is a critical period in the life cycle of marine invertebrates with a planktonic larval stage. For reef-building invertebrates such as oysters and corals, settlement rates are predictive for long-term reef survival. Increasing evidence suggests that marine invertebrates use information from ocean soundscapes to inform settlement decisions. Sessile marine invertebrates with a planktonic stage are particularly reliant on environmental cues to direct them to ideal habitats. As gregarious settlers, oysters prefer to settle amongst members of the same species. It has been hypothesized that oyster larvae from species Crassostrea virginica and Ostrea angasi use distinct conspecific oyster reef sounds to navigate to ideal habitats. In controlled laboratory experiments we exposed Pacific Oyster Magallana gigas larvae to anthropogenic sounds from conspecific oyster reefs, vessels, combined reef-vessel sounds as well as off-reef and no speaker controls. Our findings show that sounds recorded at conspecific reefs induced higher percentages of settlement by about 1.44 and 1.64 times compared to off-reef and no speaker controls, respectively. In contrast, the settlement increase compared to the no speaker control was non-significant for vessel sounds (1.21 fold), combined reef-vessel sounds (1.30 fold), and off-reef sounds (1.18 fold). This study serves as a foundational stepping stone for exploring larval sound feature preferences within this species.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmidlin2024comparison,
  author = {Sarah Schmidlin and Clea Parcerisas and Jeroen Hubert and Maryann S. Watson and Jan Mees and Dick Botteldooren and Paul Devos and Elisabeth Debusschere and Pascal I. Hablützel},
  title = {{Comparison of the effects of reef and anthropogenic soundscapes on oyster larvae settlement}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-63322-2},
}
Figure