The effects of pile driving on marine mammals and fish in Belgian waters

J. Haelters, Elisabeth Debusschere, Dick Botteldooren, Valérie Dulière, Kristian Hostens, A. Norro, Sofie Vandendriessche, L. Vigin, Magda Vincx, S. DegraerFlanders 2013

Abstract

Pile driving generates very high levels of low frequency impulsive underwater noise, with possible consequences for marine mammals and fish. To describe the effects of pile driving on harbour porpoises we developed a model based on the results of aerial surveys, which clearly pointed at disturbance effects. Especially fish with a swim bladder can be affected by piling operations, but the investigation of sub-lethal effects and the sensitivity of different fish species and life stages is complex. A multidisciplinary study is proposed to investigate these effects in the field and under controlled laboratory conditions.

Introduction

The global transition to renewable energy has led to a surge in offshore wind farm construction. However, the installation of these turbines often requires driving massive steel piles into the seabed using hydraulic hammers. This process produces impulsive, low-frequency noise that can exceed 200 dB, traveling vast distances through the water column.

Offshore pile driving operations for wind turbine foundations.

While extreme noise levels can cause immediate physical trauma, the more widespread concern involves "sub-lethal" impacts. For harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena), noise can mask vital sonar signals used for navigation and hunting. For fish, particularly those with swim bladders, the pressure waves can cause internal damage or chronic stress. This paper quantifies the reach of these disturbances and outlines frameworks for studying vulnerable life stages, such as fish larvae, that cannot flee the noise.

Methodology

The research utilized a dual-track approach to assess impacts on different marine groups:

Mammal Modeling and Observation

To track harbour porpoises, standardized aerial line transect surveys were conducted in Belgian waters before and during piling activities. A movement model was developed, combining directional movement (animals swimming away at 0.9 to 4.3 m/s) and random dispersal patterns characteristic of undisturbed behavior.

Fish Larvae Experimental Design

To study "passive drifters," the team designed an in-situ experimental rig. Vials containing European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) larvae were positioned on piling platforms and on secondary vessels 500m away. This allowed for the measurement of physiological responses to actual construction noise.

Acoustic Metrics

The study focused on Sound Exposure Level (SEL) metrics rather than simple peak pressure. Specifically, SELss (single strike) and SELcum (cumulative exposure) were used to better represent the total acoustic energy absorbed by organisms over time.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed a significant "disturbance radius" of approximately 20km around piling sites. Within this zone, habitat effectively becomes unavailable to sensitive mammals.

Modelled radial density of harbour porpoises showing displacement after successive piling events.

Porpoise Displacement

Aerial observations showed that average porpoise density dropped from 2.7 animals/km² pre-piling to 1.3 animals/km² during construction—a nearly 50% reduction. The movement model successfully predicted the "void" created around the site, though it noted that cumulative piling events might increase the distance of disturbance, suggesting a sensitization effect.

Vulnerability of Fish Larvae

While adult fish may swim away, eggs and larvae are at the mercy of currents. The paper highlights that "physoclist" fish (those lacking a connection between the gut and swim bladder) are particularly susceptible to internal pressure injuries from sound waves. Measured noise levels at 750m reached a cumulative SEL of 196 dB, far exceeding the 140 dB threshold known to cause discomfort in porpoises and potentially damaging fish tissues.

Limitations and Future Directions

The current model provides a snapshot but does not yet account for seasonal migrations or prey availability, which might influence an animal's decision to remain in a noisy area.

Future research will focus on:

  • Scaling to Monopiles: Testing impacts of larger foundations which produce even higher noise levels.
  • Long-term Laboratory Studies: Investigating how operational noise (the ongoing hum of turbines) affects fish growth and survival over months.
  • Continuous Acoustic Monitoring: Using hydrophone arrays to track animal presence 24/7, providing data that aerial surveys cannot capture during poor weather or night.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pile driving generates very high levels of low frequency impulsive underwater noise, with possible consequences for marine mammals and fish. To describe the effects of pile driving on harbour porpoises we developed a model based on the results of aerial surveys, which clearly pointed at disturbance effects. Especially fish with a swim bladder can be affected by piling operations, but the investigation of sub-lethal effects and the sensitivity of different fish species and life stages is complex. A multidisciplinary study is proposed to investigate these effects in the field and under controlled laboratory conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{haelters2013effects,
  author = {J. Haelters and Elisabeth Debusschere and Dick Botteldooren and Valérie Dulière and Kristian Hostens and A. Norro and Sofie Vandendriessche and L. Vigin and Magda Vincx and S. Degraer},
  title = {{The effects of pile driving on marine mammals and fish in Belgian waters}},
  booktitle = {Flanders},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure