The volume Comment peut-on être sceptique?, edited by Michèle Cohen-Halimi and Hélène L’Heuillet, serves as a profound tribute to the philosopher Didier Deleule. Comprising studies by his former students, the collection explores skepticism not as a dead end of thought, but as a vital condition for the possibility of philosophical inquiry.
An unpublished article by Deleule himself, titled "Scepticisme et politique," opens the volume, tracing the historical manifestations of skeptical thought from La Mothe le Vayer to Michael Oakeshott.
Skepticism as a Productive Lens
The central question of the volume challenges the common misconception of skepticism as mere nihilism or a paralyzing lack of belief. Instead, the contributors argue that skepticism is a rigorous critical tool. It functions as a productive lens through which we can analyze politics, economic liberalism, ethics, and literature. By moving beyond a simple "suspension of judgment," the authors define skepticism as a necessary framework for navigating the complexities of human action and theory.
Political and Economic Frameworks
One of the volume's key strengths is its defense of Deleule’s earlier work on economic liberalism. Rather than dismissing liberalism as a simple "capitalist ideology," the essays frame it as a complex philosophical development. This development is rooted in a skeptical inquiry into human nature and social order, suggesting that economic systems are built upon fundamental epistemological uncertainties rather than dogmatic certainties.
Historical and Comparative Analysis
The contributors employ hermeneutic and historical-critical methods to re-evaluate foundational figures:
- David Hume: The concept of "careless skepticism" is analyzed not as a lack of rigor, but as a psychological necessity that allows a philosopher to function in the world despite the absence of absolute certainty.
- Immanuel Kant: The volume explores the paradox where Kant, while viewing skepticism as a form of dogmatism to be overcome, relied heavily on skeptical arguments to establish the limits of human reason.
- Adam Smith and Thomas Reid: The text notes how the critique of Humean "generality" by these thinkers paradoxically led to a rehabilitation of certain theistic elements within a skeptical framework.
Interdisciplinary Reach
The reach of skepticism extends beyond pure philosophy into sociology (Pierre Bourdieu), literature (Henry James), and feminist theory. For instance, an analysis of Henry James’s work suggests that literary skepticism involves the "dissipation of the object," where meaning is found in the interpretive process itself. Similarly, "baroque skepticism" is presented as an ethics of variability and prudence, operating without a priori norms.
Conclusion
While the volume is a "multiform" collection of diverse perspectives, it successfully rehabilitates skepticism as a vital, active force in contemporary thought. It provides a critical lens for navigating the "crisis of truth" in modern politics and the history of philosophy itself.
Summary updated