Classifiability of crossed products by nonamenable groups

Eusebio Gardella, Shirly Geffen, Julian Kranz, Petr Naryshkin

Abstract

We show that all amenable, minimal actions of a large class of nonamenable countable groups on compact metric spaces have dynamical comparison. This class includes all nonamenable hyperbolic groups, many HNN-extensions, nonamenable Baumslag-Solitar groups, a large class of amalgamated free products, lattices in many Lie groups, $\widetilde{A}_2$-groups, as well as direct products of the above with arbitrary countable groups. As a consequence, crossed products by amenable, minimal and topologically free actions of such groups on compact metric spaces are Kirchberg algebras in the UCT class, and are therefore classified by $K$-theory.

Introduction

The Elliott Classification Program represents a landmark effort in operator algebras, aiming to classify simple, nuclear $C^*$-algebras using $K$-theoretic invariants. A central construction in this field is the crossed product $C^*(X, G)$, arising from a group $G$ acting on a topological space $X$. Historically, the classifiability of these algebras has been well-understood for amenable groups, where the "size" of the space $X$ (measured by dimension) plays a critical role. This paper explores the nonamenable frontier, revealing a surprising structural advantage inherent to nonamenable dynamics.

The Amenable Constraint

For amenable groups like $\mathbb{Z}$, the resulting $C^*$-algebra is typically classifiable only if the action is "small"—specifically, if the space $X$ has finite dimension or mean dimension zero. If the space is infinite-dimensional and the action is "large," the algebra often becomes too complex for standard classification. This led to the question: do nonamenable groups face similar dimensional restrictions? Does a nonamenable group acting on an infinite-dimensional space still produce a classifiable $C^*$-algebra?

Paradoxical Towers and Dynamical Comparison

The authors introduce paradoxical towers as a fundamental tool. This concept strengthens the classical idea of paradoxical decompositions (the foundation of the Banach-Tarski paradox). A group possesses $n$-paradoxical towers if, for any finite set of directions, the group can be partitioned into pieces that can be shifted without overlapping while still covering the entire group.

This property is used to establish dynamical comparison. In essence, if one open set is "smaller" than another (relative to invariant measures), the smaller set can be decomposed and "tucked" into the larger set using the group action.

Visualization of dynamical subequivalence: subsets $U_i$ are mapped into $V$ via group elements $g_i$.

By proving comparison, the authors demonstrate that the resulting $C^*$-algebras are Kirchberg algebras. These are purely infinite algebras that serve as the "gold standard" for classifiability, being entirely determined by their $K$-theory.

The Nonamenable Advantage

A key insight of this work is that nonamenability is actually a benefit for classification. While amenable groups require "small" spaces to yield well-behaved algebras, the intrinsic "chaos" or expansiveness of nonamenable groups (manifested through paradoxicality) allows the space $X$ to be arbitrarily complex. In the nonamenable regime, dimension simply does not matter for classifiability. This reveals a genuine difference between amenable and nonamenable dynamics.

Key Results

The paper establishes several major theorems:

  • Theorem B: For any group $G = H \times K$ where $H$ has paradoxical towers, every amenable, minimal, topologically free action on a compact metric space results in a Kirchberg algebra satisfying the Universal Coefficient Theorem (UCT). This means they are completely classified by $K$-theory.
  • Theorem C: A vast catalog of groups is shown to possess paradoxical towers, including acylindrically hyperbolic groups (such as nonabelian free groups), Baumslag-Solitar groups $BS(m, n)$ for $|m|, |n| > 1$, lattices in semisimple Lie groups like $SL_n(\mathbb{Z})$ for $n \ge 3$, and various amalgamated free products and HNN-extensions.

Future Directions

The authors propose Conjecture D, suggesting that every amenable, minimal action of any nonamenable group should satisfy dynamical comparison. While the "paradoxical tower" property covers a massive class of groups, it is not yet universal. Proving this conjecture would establish the "dimension-free" nature of nonamenable classification as a universal law in the theory of operator algebras.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that all amenable, minimal actions of a large class of nonamenable countable groups on compact metric spaces have dynamical comparison. This class includes all nonamenable hyperbolic groups, many HNN-extensions, nonamenable Baumslag-Solitar groups, a large class of amalgamated free products, lattices in many Lie groups, $\widetilde{A}_2$-groups, as well as direct products of the above with arbitrary countable groups. As a consequence, crossed products by amenable, minimal and topologically free actions of such groups on compact metric spaces are Kirchberg algebras in the UCT class, and are therefore classified by $K$-theory.
BibTeX
@misc{gardella2022classifiability,
  author = {Eusebio Gardella and Shirly Geffen and Julian Kranz and Petr Naryshkin},
  title = {{Classifiability of crossed products by nonamenable groups}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2201.03409},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.03409},
}
Figure