Characteristics and clinical outcomes of living renal donors in Hong Kong

Yl Hong, Ch Yee, Cb Leung, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Bonnie Ching‐Ha Kwan, Philip Kt Li, Simon Sm Hou, Chi‐Fai NgHong 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The overall perioperative outcomes are good, with very few serious complications. The introduction of a laparoscopic approach has decreased perioperative blood loss and also shortened hospital stay. Long-term kidney function is satisfactory and no patients developed end-stage renal disease. The incidences of new-onset medical diseases and pregnancy-related complications were also low.

TL;DR

This retrospective study evaluates 25 years of living kidney donation in Hong Kong, confirming that the procedure is remarkably safe with no donor deaths or progression to end-stage renal disease. The transition from open surgery to laparoscopic techniques has significantly improved immediate recovery—reducing blood loss and hospital stays—while the remaining kidney demonstrates impressive long-term functional compensation.

Introduction

End-stage renal disease (ESRD) is a growing global health crisis. In Hong Kong, thousands of patients wait for kidney transplants, but cadaveric donations remain scarce. Living donor renal transplant (LDRT) is the most effective alternative, yet potential donors often fear the long-term health consequences of living with a single kidney. While Western data on donor safety is robust, there is a lack of long-term clinical data specifically focused on Asian populations. This paper fills that gap by analyzing the perioperative and long-term (up to 26 years) outcomes of living donors in a major Hong Kong teaching hospital.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study of 83 living renal donors who underwent nephrectomy at the Prince of Wales Hospital between January 1990 and December 2015. Key methodological aspects included:

  • Surgical Comparison: Tracking the evolution from Open Donor Nephrectomy (ODN) to Hand-port Assisted Laparoscopic and full Laparoscopic Donor Nephrectomy (LDN).
  • Renal Function Tracking: Glomerular Filtration Rate (GFR) was calculated using the MDRD equation based on serum creatinine levels.
  • Complication Scoring: Short-term complications were standardized using the Clavien-Dindo classification.
  • Long-term Monitoring: Territory-wide electronic patient records were used to track new-onset diseases like hypertension, diabetes, and pregnancy-related complications.

Study Population

The study utilized a clinical dataset of 83 living renal donors. Information was retrieved from the Clinical Management System (post-2000) and manual audits of paper records (1990–2000). The cohort was 67.5% female and 97.6% Chinese, with a mean age of 37.3 years at the time of donation.

Key Insights: Renal Compensation and Surgical Evolution

The "Hyperfiltration" Miracle

One of the most significant biological findings is how the remaining kidney compensates for the loss of its pair. Immediately following nephrectomy, the GFR drops significantly (from a baseline of ~96 to ~67 mL/min/1.73 m²). However, over the subsequent years, the remaining kidney increases its functional capacity, eventually stabilizing at approximately 75% of the original two-kidney baseline.

Annual mean GFR after surgery showing functional compensation over time.

Laparoscopic Trade-offs

The shift to laparoscopic surgery (LDN) offered clear benefits but also presented initial trade-offs. While LDN significantly reduced blood loss and shortened hospital stays, it initially resulted in longer "warm ischaemia time" and a higher rate of minor (Grade 1-2) complications, such as nausea.

Key Results

The study demonstrated excellent safety profiles for living donors:

  • Survival and ESRD: There were zero deaths and zero cases of renal failure among the donors over a mean follow-up period of 12 years (up to 26 years).
  • Surgical Comparison: LDN showed a massive reduction in blood loss compared to ODN (55.3 mL vs. 532.2 mL, P<0.01) and shorter hospital stays (5.7 days vs. 8.1 days).
  • Serious Complications: Only 3 patients (9.4%) experienced "Grade 3a" complications requiring surgical intervention, all of which occurred in the open surgery (ODN) group.
Comparison of perioperative outcomes between open and laparoscopic techniques.
  • Long-term Health: 18.2% of donors developed hypertension and 2.6% developed diabetes. These figures are expected as the cohort ages and may not be directly attributable to the donation.
  • Pregnancy Safety: For young female donors, the study provides reassuring evidence. Out of 17 post-donation pregnancies, the incidence of serious complications like pre-eclampsia or gestational hypertension was low.

Limitations and Conclusion

The study is limited by its relatively small sample size (n=83) and retrospective nature, which can introduce bias or incomplete data from earlier years. Additionally, the lack of a matched control group of healthy non-donors makes it difficult to isolate the effects of donation from natural aging.

Despite these limitations, the findings underscore the high safety profile of living kidney donation in the Hong Kong context. The authors advocate for medical practitioners to more actively encourage living donation among relatives of patients with kidney failure, given the excellent long-term outcomes and the significant functional compensation of the remaining kidney.

Summary updated

Abstract

The overall perioperative outcomes are good, with very few serious complications. The introduction of a laparoscopic approach has decreased perioperative blood loss and also shortened hospital stay. Long-term kidney function is satisfactory and no patients developed end-stage renal disease. The incidences of new-onset medical diseases and pregnancy-related complications were also low.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hong2017characteristics,
  author = {YL Hong and CH Yee and CB Leung and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Bonnie Ching‐Ha Kwan and Philip KT Li and Simon Sm Hou and Chi‐Fai Ng},
  title = {{Characteristics and clinical outcomes of living renal donors in Hong Kong}},
  booktitle = {Hong},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.12809/hkmj176820},
}
Figure