Topic-1b: Technical aspects and physiological problems in split/living donor liver transplantation

Kōichi Tanaka, C Lo, S Fan, C Liu, W Wei, Rjw Lo, C Lai, Jkf Chan, Iol Ng, A Fung, J Wong, B Yong, S Lee, Y Lee, K Park, Y Kobayashi, T KiuchiThe Keio Journal of Medicine 2001 · DOI

This document summarizes a series of keynote lectures and abstracts from a symposium focused on the technical and physiological challenges of adult-to-adult living donor liver transplantation (LDLT).

TL;DR

To address the critical shortage of cadaveric organs, surgeons are refining adult-to-adult living donor liver transplantation by transitioning from small left-lobe grafts to larger right-lobe grafts. The core challenge lies in balancing "small-for-size" graft syndrome in recipients against the surgical safety of the living donor, particularly regarding the management of the Middle Hepatic Vein (MHV).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The primary hurdle in adult LDLT is the "small-for-size" graft. While pediatric transplants can easily use a small portion of a parent's liver, adult recipients require a much larger metabolic mass.

When a graft is too small—specifically when the Graft-to-Recipient Weight Ratio (GRWR) falls below 0.8%—recipients often suffer from poor early graft function, prolonged cholestasis (bile backup), and increased surgical complications. Surgeons face a "Goldilocks" dilemma: a left-lobe graft is safer for the donor but often too small for the recipient, while a right-lobe graft provides more mass but increases the risk to the donor and introduces complex venous drainage issues.

Methods

The papers describe various clinical strategies and surgical refinements across major Asian transplant centers (Kyoto, Tokyo, Hong Kong, and Seoul):

  • Volumetric Analysis: Using GRWR to predict outcomes and determine the minimum viable graft size.
  • Graft Selection: Shifting from left-lobe grafts to right-lobe grafts to increase the implanted liver mass.
  • Venous Reconstruction: Developing techniques to reconstruct the Middle Hepatic Vein (MHV) or its tributaries using autogenous vein grafts (interposition grafts) to prevent congestion in the transplanted liver.
  • Intraoperative Ultrasound: Using real-time imaging to evaluate blood flow and determine if specific venous tributaries require reconstruction based on regurgitating flow or discoloration under occlusion.

Datasets

The findings are based on clinical retrospective data from four major institutions:

  • Kyoto University: Analysis of survival rates based on GRWR in non-ICU-bound patients.
  • University of Tokyo: Results from 48 adult LDLTs focusing on left-liver grafts and caudate lobe inclusion.
  • Queen Mary Hospital (Hong Kong): Data from 12 children and 64 adults, comparing left-lobe vs. right-lobe outcomes.
  • Asan Medical Center (Seoul): Clinical experiences with "Modified Right Lobe" (MRL) grafts and anterior segment congestion.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 0.8% Threshold: Tanaka (Kyoto) demonstrates a clear survival drop-off: patients with a GRWR > 1.0% had a 91.8% one-year survival rate, which plummeted to 59.7% when the ratio was below 0.8%.
  • The MHV Dilemma: The Middle Hepatic Vein is the "contested territory" of the liver. Including it in the graft helps the recipient's drainage but may compromise the donor's remaining liver.
  • Modified Right Lobe (MRL): Lee (Seoul) proposes keeping the MHV in the donor for safety while using a vein graft to reconstruct the recipient's drainage. This provides the mass of a right lobe without the donor risk of an "Extended" right lobe graft.
  • Waiting List Impact: Fan (Hong Kong) notes that adopting right-lobe LDLT increased the transplantation rate from 19% to 78% and slashed median waiting times from 465 days to just 38 days.

Key Results

  • Survival: Right-lobe grafts in Hong Kong achieved an 83% survival rate, significantly better than the 0% survival seen in cirrhotic patients receiving undersized left-lobe grafts.
  • Donor Safety: Across the reports, donor mortality remained at 0%, even with the more complex right-lobe extractions, provided that at least 30% of the donor's liver volume remained.
  • Complication Correlation: Surgical complications (hemorrhage, intestinal perforation) and septic complications were found to be inversely correlated with graft size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Early Stage Technology: Tanaka emphasizes that adult LDLT is still in an "early stage" and requires continuous critical review.
  • Anatomical Variation: The success of these procedures relies heavily on precise knowledge of individual anatomical variations, which can make standardization difficult.
  • Ethical Balancing: The "most important ethical issue" remains donor safety. While right-lobe grafts help recipients, they impose a more extensive and risky operation on a healthy donor. Future work focuses on refining "Modified" grafts that maximize recipient mass while minimizing donor tissue loss.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{tanaka2001topic,
  author = {Kōichi Tanaka and C Lo and S Fan and C Liu and W Wei and Rjw Lo and C Lai and Jkf Chan and Iol Ng and A Fung and J Wong and S Fan and C Lo and C Liu and S Fan and C Lo and C Liu and B Yong and Jkf Chan and Iol Ng and S Lee and Y Lee and K Park and K Tanaka and Y Kobayashi and T Kiuchi},
  title = {{Topic-1b: Technical aspects and physiological problems in split/living donor liver transplantation}},
  journal = {The Keio Journal of Medicine},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.2302/kjm.50.supplement1\_24},
}
Figure