Cell type-specific contributions to a persistent aggressive internal state in female Drosophila

Hui Chiu, Alice A. Robie, Kristin Branson, Tanvi Vippa, Samantha Epstein, Gerald M. Rubin, David J. Anderson, Catherine E. Schretter

Abstract

Persistent internal states are important for maintaining survival-promoting behaviors, such as aggression. In female Drosophila melanogaster, we have previously shown that individually activating either aIPg or pC1d cell types can induce aggression. Here we investigate further the individual roles of these cholinergic, sexually dimorphic cell types, and the reciprocal connections between them, in generating a persistent aggressive internal state. We find that a brief 30-second optogenetic stimulation of aIPg neurons was sufficient to promote an aggressive internal state lasting at least 10 minutes, whereas similar stimulation of pC1d neurons did not. While we previously showed that stimulation of pC1e alone does not evoke aggression, persistent behavior could be promoted through simultaneous stimulation of pC1d and pC1e, suggesting an unexpected synergy of these cell types in establishing a persistent aggressive state. Neither aIPg nor pC1d show persistent neuronal activity themselves, implying that the persistent internal state is maintained by other mechanisms. Moreover, inactivation of pC1d did not significantly reduce aIPg-evoked persistent aggression arguing that the aggressive state did not depend on pC1d-aIPg recurrent connectivity. Our results suggest the need for alternative models to explain persistent female aggression.

Introduction

In both humans and animals, internal states—such as hunger, fear, or aggression—often outlast the stimulus that triggered them. This persistence is a fundamental feature of brain function, allowing organisms to remain vigilant or motivated long after a threat has passed. In female Drosophila melanogaster, previous research identified two clusters of cholinergic, sexually dimorphic neurons, aIPg and pC1d, that trigger aggression. Because these clusters are physically interconnected, it was hypothesized that they form a "recurrent excitatory loop"—a neural echo chamber where activity cycles back and forth to maintain an aggressive state. This study tests this hypothesis and explores the circuit logic behind persistent female aggression.

Methods

To dissect the neural mechanisms of persistence, researchers employed several advanced techniques:

  • Optogenetics: Red light was used to activate neurons expressing CsChrimson (aIPg, pC1d, or pC1e).
  • Sliding Door Assay: To isolate the internal state from immediate social triggers, flies were kept behind a door during a 30-second stimulation. The door was removed 10 minutes later to observe subsequent social interactions.
  • Calcium Imaging (GCaMP): Two-photon microscopy recorded real-time neural activity to determine if neurons remained active post-stimulation.
  • Behavioral Epistasis: The silencing channel Kir2.1 was used to deactivate pC1d while simultaneously activating aIPg to test if the behavior required both functional units.
  • Automated Tracking: The Caltech FlyTracker and JAABA machine-learning classifiers quantified aggressive behaviors like head-butting and shoving.

Results

Recurrent connectivity and persistence model Source, p. 1

Recurrent connectivity and persistence model

Analysis of the Janelia Hemibrain Connectome confirmed strong physical connections between aIPg, pC1d, and pC1e. However, behavioral experiments revealed that persistence is cell-type specific. A brief 30-second stimulation of aIPg neurons created an aggressive state lasting over 10 minutes. In contrast, stimulating pC1d neurons only caused aggression during the stimulus itself. Interestingly, while pC1e neurons do not trigger aggression alone, their co-stimulation with pC1d acted as a "persistence switch," inducing long-lasting aggression similar to aIPg activation.

Experimental assay and behavioral persistence results

Crucially, calcium imaging showed that neural activity in aIPg and pC1d returns to baseline immediately after stimulation, ruling out persistent electrical firing in these cells as the cause of the behavioral state. Furthermore, silencing pC1d did not significantly reduce aIPg-evoked persistent aggression, indicating that the aggressive state does not depend on a simple pC1d-aIPg recurrent loop. The duration of the aggressive state was also found to be influenced by social context; flies in higher-density environments showed longer-lasting aggression, suggesting social feedback can reinforce the internal state.

Discussion

The finding that aggression outlasts neural activity suggests that the persistent internal state is maintained by mechanisms downstream of the trigger neurons or through biochemical signaling. The authors suggest that slow-acting neuropeptides, such as sNPF (short neuropeptide F), may be responsible for maintaining the state. The role of pC1e as a necessary partner for pC1d-mediated persistence, but not for the behavior itself, highlights a complex modularity in the aggression circuit. Future work will focus on identifying the "integrator" neurons that transform transient neural pulses into long-term behavioral shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Persistent internal states are important for maintaining survival-promoting behaviors, such as aggression. In female <i>Drosophila melanogaster</i>, we have previously shown that individually activating either aIPg or pC1d cell types can induce aggression. Here we investigate further the individual roles of these cholinergic, sexually dimorphic cell types, and the reciprocal connections between them, in generating a persistent aggressive internal state. We find that a brief 30-second optogenetic stimulation of aIPg neurons was sufficient to promote an aggressive internal state lasting at least 10 minutes, whereas similar stimulation of pC1d neurons did not. While we previously showed that stimulation of pC1e alone does not evoke aggression, persistent behavior could be promoted through simultaneous stimulation of pC1d and pC1e, suggesting an unexpected synergy of these cell types in establishing a persistent aggressive state. Neither aIPg nor pC1d show persistent neuronal activity themselves, implying that the persistent internal state is maintained by other mechanisms. Moreover, inactivation of pC1d did not significantly reduce aIPg-evoked persistent aggression, arguing that the aggressive state did not depend on pC1d-aIPg recurrent connectivity. Our results suggest the need for alternative models to explain persistent female aggression.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chiu2023cell,
  author = {Hui Chiu and Alice A. Robie and Kristin Branson and Tanvi Vippa and Samantha Epstein and Gerald M. Rubin and David J. Anderson and Catherine E. Schretter},
  title = {{Cell type-specific contributions to a persistent aggressive internal state in female Drosophila}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.88598},
}
Figure