Reviewer #2 (Public Review): Cell type-specific contributions to a persistent aggressive internal state in female Drosophila

Hui Chiu, Alice A. Robie, Kristin Branson, Tanvi Vippa, Samantha Epstein, Gerald M. Rubin, David J. Anderson, Catherine E SchretterOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Persistent internal states are essential for survival-promoting behaviors like aggression. In female Drosophila melanogaster, activating specific cell types—aIPg or pC1d—can induce aggression. This study investigates how these neurons and their reciprocal connections generate a persistent aggressive state. We found that a brief 30-second optogenetic stimulation of aIPg neurons promotes aggression lasting at least 10 minutes, whereas pC1d stimulation alone does not. However, simultaneous stimulation of pC1d and pC1e induces persistence, suggesting a synergistic relationship. Interestingly, neither aIPg nor pC1d show persistent neural activity, and inactivating pC1d does not reduce aIPg-evoked persistence. These findings suggest that the "memory" of aggression is not maintained by simple recurrent feedback loops between these neurons, pointing toward alternative mechanisms like biochemical signaling.

Introduction: The Mystery of Persistent Aggression

Internal states such as hunger, fear, or aggression are characterized by their persistence; they often outlast the initial stimulus. In Drosophila, researchers have identified specific clusters of neurons that control female aggression, but the mechanism for maintaining this state has remained controversial. Previous studies offered conflicting views on whether persistence arises from a single cell type or a complex circuit. This research seeks to determine if persistence is driven by specific cell combinations or "recurrent" circuits where neurons keep each other active through feedback loops.

The "Sliding Door" Assay and Behavioral Results

To distinguish between a simple reflex and a persistent internal state, the researchers developed a "sliding door" assay. Flies were separated by a metal door during a 30-second optogenetic stimulation of specific neurons. The door was only removed 10 minutes later to observe if the flies remained "primed" to fight.

The sliding door assay (A) reveals that aIPg and pC1d+e co-activation (B, C) lead to persistent aggression 10 minutes after stimulation, while pC1d alone does not.

The results were striking:

  • aIPg as a Persistence Switch: A brief stimulation of aIPg neurons was sufficient to keep flies aggressive for over 10 minutes.
  • pC1d/pC1e Synergy: While pC1d stimulation alone produced only immediate, "time-locked" aggression that vanished when the light turned off, co-stimulating pC1d and pC1e successfully induced a persistent state. This suggests pC1e acts as a modulator that transforms a fleeting impulse into a lasting behavioral state.
  • Social Context: Interestingly, higher fly density was found to extend the duration of the persistent state, suggesting that external social cues can "refresh" or sustain the internal state initiated by aIPg.

Challenging the Recurrent Connectivity Model

A leading hypothesis in neuroscience suggests that persistence is "electronic"—maintained by neurons firing in a recurrent loop. Connectomic analysis using the Drosophila "Hemibrain" dataset confirmed that aIPg, pC1d, and pC1e are indeed physically connected by strong reciprocal synapses.

Circuit diagram (A) showing reciprocal connectivity between pC1d, pC1e, and aIPg. Conceptual model (B) questioning the link between connectivity, neural activity, and persistent behavior.

However, the experimental evidence contradicted the electronic model. First, in vivo calcium imaging showed that neural activity in these cells decayed within 5 to 20 seconds—far too quickly to explain a 10-minute behavioral state. Second, behavioral epistasis experiments showed that silencing pC1d while activating aIPg did not stop the persistent aggression, proving the state does not depend on a feedback loop between these specific clusters.

Conclusion and Future Directions

If the "memory" of aggression isn't stored in electronic loops within these neurons, where does it live? The authors suggest the persistence might be biochemical rather than electrical. For instance, aIPg neurons produce short Neuropeptide F (sNPF), which could act as a slow-release signal that maintains the aggressive state. Future research will likely focus on these neuropeptides and downstream targets like the interneuron SMP312 to fully map the circuit of "long-lasting anger" in the fly brain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Persistent internal states are important for maintaining survival-promoting behaviors, such as aggression. In female Drosophila melanogaster, we have previously shown that individually activating either aIPg or pC1d cell types can induce aggression. Here we investigate further the individual roles of these cholinergic, sexually dimorphic cell types, and the reciprocal connections between them, in generating a persistent aggressive internal state. We find that a brief 30-second optogenetic stimulation of aIPg neurons was sufficient to promote an aggressive internal state lasting at least 10 minutes, whereas similar stimulation of pC1d neurons did not. While we previously showed that stimulation of pC1e alone does not evoke aggression, persistent behavior could be promoted through simultaneous stimulation of pC1d and pC1e, suggesting an unexpected synergy of these cell types in establishing a persistent aggressive state. Neither aIPg nor pC1d show persistent neuronal activity themselves, implying that the persistent internal state is maintained by other mechanisms. Moreover, inactivation of pC1d did not significantly reduce aIPg-evoked persistent aggression arguing that the aggressive state did not depend on pC1d-aIPg recurrent connectivity. Our results suggest the need for alternative models to explain persistent female aggression.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chiu2023reviewer,
  author = {Hui Chiu and Alice A. Robie and Kristin Branson and Tanvi Vippa and Samantha Epstein and Gerald M. Rubin and David J. Anderson and Catherine E Schretter},
  title = {{Reviewer \#2 (Public Review): Cell type-specific contributions to a persistent aggressive internal state in female Drosophila}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.88598.2.sa0},
}
Figure