Bregman Three-Operator Splitting Methods

Xin Jiang, Lieven Vandenberghe

TL;DR

This paper introduces generalized Bregman distances to enhance primal-dual splitting methods for convex optimization, extending existing algorithms like Condat-Vũ and PD3O. The authors provide a unified convergence analysis framework and propose a novel line search technique for adaptive stepsize selection, improving practical performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world problems in machine learning, signal processing, and operations research can be formulated as convex optimization problems with multiple terms. Primal-dual splitting methods are powerful tools for solving these problems, but their convergence and efficiency can be sensitive to stepsize selection and the choice of proximal operators. Standard methods rely on Euclidean distances, which might not always be optimal. This paper addresses these limitations by exploring the use of generalized Bregman distances, which can offer better local approximations and potentially faster convergence. The authors aim to extend existing algorithms to leverage these generalized distances, provide rigorous convergence guarantees, and develop more robust methods, particularly by incorporating adaptive stepsize selection.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the development and analysis of Bregman extensions of primal-dual splitting algorithms. Specifically, they extend the Condat-Vũ and PD3O algorithms by replacing the standard Euclidean proximal operators with generalized Bregman proximal operators.

  • Bregman Condat-Vũ Algorithms: The authors derive primal and dual variants of the Condat-Vũ algorithm using Bregman distances. They interpret these algorithms as applications of the Bregman proximal point method to a monotone inclusion problem, which allows for a unified convergence analysis. They establish an $O(1/k)$ ergodic convergence rate for both primal and dual iterates.
  • Line Search for Bregman Dual Condat-Vũ: A key practical contribution is a backtracking line search procedure for selecting stepsizes in the Bregman dual Condat-Vũ algorithm, specifically for equality-constrained problems. This adaptive approach aims to overcome the limitations of fixed stepsize rules, which can be overly conservative or lead to slow convergence.
  • Bregman PD3O Algorithm: The paper proposes a Bregman extension of the primal-dual three-operator (PD3O) algorithm and analyzes its convergence, also establishing an $O(1/k)$ ergodic convergence rate.

The analysis relies on properties of Bregman distances, including their convexity and strong convexity under certain conditions related to the problem's linear operator and the kernel functions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm development and analysis, with a numerical experiment section that uses a synthetic problem instance rather than a standard dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bregman Distances as Preconditioners: The paper highlights that generalized Bregman distances can act as a form of preconditioning, leading to more accurate local optimization models and potentially improving algorithm performance.
  • Unified Framework for Convergence Analysis: By interpreting the Bregman Condat-Vũ algorithms through the lens of the Bregman proximal point method, the authors establish a unified framework for analyzing their convergence, simplifying the theoretical treatment.
  • Adaptive Stepsizes for Robustness: The introduction of a backtracking line search for the Bregman dual Condat-Vũ algorithm is a significant practical advancement. It addresses the challenge of choosing appropriate fixed stepsizes, which can be difficult in practice due to the dependence on matrix norms and Lipschitz constants.
  • Extending Existing Algorithms: The work demonstrates that powerful existing algorithms can be effectively generalized using Bregman distances, opening avenues for improved performance and broader applicability.

Key Results

  • Convergence Guarantees: The paper establishes $O(1/k)$ ergodic convergence rates for the proposed Bregman primal and dual Condat-Vũ algorithms, and for the Bregman PD3O algorithm.
  • Line Search Effectiveness: The proposed line search technique for the Bregman dual Condat-Vũ algorithm is shown to be effective, allowing for adaptive stepsize selection and potentially improving convergence speed without significant computational overhead.
  • Algorithm Extensions: The paper successfully extends the Condat-Vũ and PD3O algorithms to incorporate generalized Bregman distances, creating new variants with potentially enhanced properties.
  • Numerical Validation: A numerical experiment demonstrates the performance of the proposed algorithms, comparing them to existing methods and illustrating the benefits of the line search technique. The results suggest that Bregman PD3O converges faster than the primal Condat-Vũ algorithm, and the line search significantly improves the performance of the dual Condat-Vũ algorithm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • PDDY Extension: The paper notes that it is unclear how to use Bregman distances in the primal-dual Davis-Yin (PDDY) algorithm.
  • Line Search Generalization: Extending the line search technique to Bregman PD3O, the Bregman primal Condat-Vũ algorithm, and the more general problem (1) remains an open question.
  • Fixed Step Size Ratio: The current backtracking line search technique uses a fixed ratio between primal and dual stepsizes, which could potentially be relaxed for further improvement.
  • Assumptions on Kernels: The convergence analysis relies on assumptions about the strong convexity of the kernel functions and the relative smoothness of the function $h$. Relaxing these assumptions could lead to more broadly applicable results.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The paper presents primal–dual proximal splitting methods for convex optimization, in which generalized Bregman distances are used to define the primal and dual proximal update steps. The methods extend the primal and dual Condat–Vũ algorithms and the primal–dual three-operator (PD3O) algorithm. The Bregman extensions of the Condat–Vũ algorithms are derived from the Bregman proximal point method applied to a monotone inclusion problem. Based on this interpretation, a unified framework for the convergence analysis of the two methods is presented. We also introduce a line search procedure for stepsize selection in the Bregman dual Condat–Vũ algorithm applied to equality-constrained problems. Finally, we propose a Bregman extension of PD3O and analyze its convergence.
BibTeX
@article{jiang2022bregman,
  author = {Xin Jiang and Lieven Vandenberghe},
  title = {{Bregman Three-Operator Splitting Methods}},
  journal = {Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10957-022-02125-9},
}

Loading related content...

Figure