Bosonic short-range entangled states beyond group cohomology classification

Cenke Xu, Yi‐Zhuang YouPhysical 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the study of quantum matter, topological phases represent states that are distinguished not by local symmetry breaking, but by global, non-local properties of their wavefunctions. For over a decade, the classification of these phases has been dominated by the framework of group cohomology. This framework successfully categorizes Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) states—phases that possess gapless boundaries as long as certain global symmetries remain intact. However, group cohomology has a notable limitation: it fails to account for states that are topologically non-trivial even in the absence of any symmetry.

These "rebel" states are known as Bosonic Short-Range Entangled (BSRE) states. The most famous example is the $E_8$ state in two spatial dimensions ($2d$). This research explores a new class of BSRE states in $4k+2$ spatial dimensions (such as 6D and 10D) that serve as higher-dimensional generalizations of the $E_8$ state, fundamentally defying standard mathematical classifications.

The $E_8$ Legacy and the $4k+2$ Rule

The $2d$ $E_8$ state is unique because its boundary consists of eight chiral bosonic modes. Because these modes all move in the same direction, they cannot be "gapped out" or stopped by any local perturbation, even if all symmetries are broken. This stability is a direct consequence of a gravitational anomaly.

This phenomenon is not restricted to $2d$. By utilizing the mathematics of self-dual forms, these states can be constructed in any spatial dimension $D = 4k+2$. In these dimensions, the system can support a bulk described by rank-$(2k+1)$ antisymmetric tensor fields, leading to boundary physics that mirrors the robustness of the $E_8$ state.

Field Theoretic Construction

The authors construct these higher-dimensional BSRE states using a generalized Chern-Simons field theory. In standard $2d$ topological phases, Chern-Simons theory involves vector fields. For the $4k+2$ dimensional generalization, the theory employs rank-$(2k+1)$ antisymmetric tensor fields $a^I$.

The topological properties are governed by an effective $K$-matrix formalism. By using an $8 \times 8$ matrix identical to the Cartan matrix of the $E_8$ Lie group, the authors ensure that the bulk is fully gapped and non-degenerate. This specific construction ensures there are no fractional excitations in the bulk, satisfying the criteria for a short-range entangled state. Furthermore, the entries of the $K$-matrix must be integers to maintain gauge invariance under "large" transformations, a condition the $E_8$ structure naturally fulfills.

Boundary Physics and Gravitational Anomalies

One of the most striking features of these BSRE states is their boundary. For a state in $4k+2$ dimensions, the boundary exists in $4k+1$ dimensions. This boundary is described by a "self-dual" rank-$2k$ antisymmetric tensor gauge field.

Unlike SPT states, which require symmetry to protect their boundary, these BSRE boundaries are guaranteed to be gapless due to an intrinsic gravitational anomaly. When coupled to a gravitational field (or a curved spacetime background), the boundary theory is not self-consistent on its own; it requires the existence of the higher-dimensional bulk to cancel the anomaly. This "anomaly matching" ensures that the boundary remains a dynamical, gapless system regardless of the presence or absence of internal symmetries.

Construction via Fermionic Branes

To provide a microscopic intuition, the authors propose a construction method involving fermionic degrees of freedom. They demonstrate that these bosonic states can be viewed as the result of "confining" fermions. Specifically, by taking eight copies of $(4k+2)d$ fermionic SRE states and introducing fermionic $2k$-branes, the fermions can be "glued" together. Once these fermionic excitations are confined, the remaining low-energy degrees of freedom are purely bosonic, resulting in the BSRE state.

Dimensional Reduction and Descendants

The relationship between these higher-dimensional states and known physics is further solidified through dimensional reduction. If a $(4k+2)d$ BSRE state is compactified on a closed $4k$-dimensional manifold, the resulting $2d$ system can reduce to the original $E_8$ state, depending on the topology of the manifold.

Furthermore, these BSRE states act as "parents" for other phases. By imposing additional symmetries, such as time-reversal, one can derive new Bosonic Symmetry Protected Topological (BSPT) states in various dimensions. These "descendant" states were previously unknown and fall outside the traditional group cohomology classification.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The discovery of BSRE states in $4k+2$ dimensions significantly expands the map of topological matter. By moving beyond the constraints of group cohomology, this work highlights the deep connection between quantum entanglement, antisymmetric tensor fields, and gravitational anomalies.

While this theoretical framework provides a robust description, several challenges remain. The current analysis focuses primarily on perturbative gravitational anomalies; a complete classification will require addressing global gravitational anomalies through the lens of cobordism theory. Additionally, while the field theory is well-defined, creating a realistic lattice model that could be implemented in a laboratory setting remains a significant challenge for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We explore and construct a class of bosonic short-range entangled (BSRE) states in all $4k+2$ spatial dimensions, which are higher dimensional generalizations of the well-known Kitaev's ${E}_{8}$ state in $2d$ [Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 321, 2 (2006); http://online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/topomat11/kitaev]. These BSRE states share the following properties: (1) their bulk is fully gapped and nondegenerate; (2) their $(4k+1)d$ boundary is described by a ``self-dual'' rank-$2k$ antisymmetric tensor gauge field, and it is guaranteed to be gapless without assuming any symmetry; (3) their $(4k+1)d$ boundary has intrinsic gravitational anomaly once coupled to the gravitational field; (4) their bulk is described by an effective Chern-Simons field theory with rank-$(2k+1)$ antisymmetric tensor fields, whose ${K}^{IJ}$ matrix is identical to that of the ${E}_{8}$ state in $2d$; (5) the existence of these BSRE states leads to various bosonic symmetry protected topological (BSPT) states as their descendants in other dimensions; (6) these BSRE states can be constructed by confining fermionic degrees of freedom from eight copies of $(4k+2)d$ SRE states with fermionic $2k\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{branes}$; (7) after compactifying the $(4k+2)d$ BSRE state on a closed $4k$ dimensional manifold, depending on the topology of the compact $4k$ manifold, the system could reduce to nontrivial $2d$ BSRE states.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2015bosonic,
  author = {Cenke Xu and Yi‐Zhuang You},
  title = {{Bosonic short-range entangled states beyond group cohomology classification}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.91.054406},
}
Figure