Author Correction: A rigorous electrochemical ammonia synthesis protocol with quantitative isotope measurements

Suzanne Z. Andersen, Viktor Čolić, Sungeun Yang, Jay A. Schwalbe, Adam C. Nielander, Joshua M. McEnaney, Kasper Enemark‐Rasmussen, Jon G. Baker, Aayush R. Singh, Brian A. Rohr, Michael J. Statt, Sarah J. Blair, Stefano Mezzavilla, Jakob Kibsgaard, Peter C. K. Vesborg, Matteo Cargnello, Stacey F. Bent, Thomas F. Jaramillo, Ifan E. L. Stephens, Jens K. Nørskov, Ib ChorkendorffNature 2019 · DOI

In May 2019, a landmark study was published in Nature aimed at addressing one of the most persistent challenges in modern catalysis: the electrochemical reduction of nitrogen to ammonia (eNRR). This research was designed to establish a "gold standard" for experimental rigor in a field frequently plagued by false positives and reproducibility issues. Recently, the authors issued a formal correction to address a significant typographical error in the data presentation that, while not altering the fundamental scientific conclusions, drastically changes the reported scale of ammonia production.

The Core Correction: Units of Magnitude

The primary focus of this correction is the y-axis label of Figure 4b. In the original publication, the yield of ammonia (NH$_3$) was labeled in millimoles (mmol). The corrected label is micromoles (μmol). This represents a three-order-of-magnitude difference—a thousand-fold reduction in the reported yield.

In the context of chemical synthesis, the distinction between millimoles and micromoles is profound. While the former might suggest a process nearing commercial viability or high-throughput efficiency, the latter reflects the current reality of laboratory-scale electrochemical nitrogen reduction, where yields remain extremely low and difficult to measure.

Addressing the Reproducibility Crisis

To understand why this correction is so critical, one must consider the state of eNRR research. For years, the scientific community has struggled with "false positives" in ammonia synthesis. Ammonia is a ubiquitous contaminant found in human breath, cleaning supplies, and laboratory equipment (such as nitrile gloves). Many early reports of high-yield electrochemical ammonia synthesis were later found to be the result of environmental contamination rather than actual catalytic activity.

The original paper sought to solve this by introducing a rigorous protocol involving:

  • Quantitative Isotope Measurements: Using $^{15}$N$_2$ gas as a feedstock. By detecting $^{15}$NH$_3$ instead of the common $^{14}$NH$_3$, researchers can definitively prove that the nitrogen in the produced ammonia originated from the gas supply and not from ambient contaminants.
  • Standardized Cleaning and Control Procedures: Ensuring that the electrochemical cell and all components are free of nitrogenous impurities.

Implications for the Field

The correction underscores the extreme difficulty of the eNRR process. Even with "rigorous" protocols and state-of-the-art detection, the actual quantities of ammonia produced are in the micromolar range. For a paper intended to serve as the definitive guide for benchmarking and experimental design, such a unit error is mathematically significant.

The issuance of this correction by a high-impact journal like Nature highlights the ongoing scrutiny applied to foundational research. By correcting the online record, the authors ensure that future researchers attempting to replicate or build upon these protocols have an accurate baseline for comparison. It serves as a cautionary reminder that in the pursuit of sustainable chemistry, the difference between a breakthrough and a baseline observation often rests on a single prefix.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{andersen2019author,
  author = {Suzanne Z. Andersen and Viktor Čolić and Sungeun Yang and Jay A. Schwalbe and Adam C. Nielander and Joshua M. McEnaney and Kasper Enemark‐Rasmussen and Jon G. Baker and Aayush R. Singh and Brian A. Rohr and Michael J. Statt and Sarah J. Blair and Stefano Mezzavilla and Jakob Kibsgaard and Peter C. K. Vesborg and Matteo Cargnello and Stacey F. Bent and Thomas F. Jaramillo and Ifan E. L. Stephens and Jens K. Nørskov and Ib Chorkendorff},
  title = {{Author Correction: A rigorous electrochemical ammonia synthesis protocol with quantitative isotope measurements}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41586-019-1625-1},
}
Figure