Author Correction: Genome-scale CRISPR-Cas9 knockout and transcriptional activation screening

Julia Joung, Silvana Konermann, Jonathan S. Gootenberg, Omar O. Abudayyeh, Randall J. Platt, Mark D. Brigham, Neville E. Sanjana, Feng ZhangNature Protocols 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In the realm of high-stakes experimental science, the precision of published protocols is paramount. Even minor typographical errors or formatting shifts can lead to significant experimental failures or the misinterpretation of data. This paper summarizes a collection of amendments published in Nature Protocols (Vol 14, July 2019), which provide critical technical updates to three established methodologies: surface-wetting characterization, rodent behavioral tasks, and genome-scale CRISPR-Cas9 screening.

Technical Corrections and Procedural Updates

1. Surface-Wetting Characterization (Huhtamäki et al.)

The correction for the protocol on surface-wetting characterization addresses technical descriptions within Table 1. Specifically, it clarifies that the "Simple" advantages listed are attributed to the "Tilting plate" method rather than "Sessile-drop goniometry." Additionally, a line break error was corrected that previously obscured the baseline placement criteria for Receding Contact Angle (RCA) measurements. These distinctions are vital for researchers selecting the appropriate technique for material characterization.

2. Object Pattern Separation in Rodents (van Goethem et al.)

This amendment focuses on the structural integrity of troubleshooting resources. In the original HTML publication, Table 6—which outlines "Problem," "Possible reason," and "Solution"—suffered from column misalignment. For researchers attempting to debug behavioral tasks, this misalignment rendered the troubleshooting logic unusable. The correction restores the mapping between experimental hurdles and their respective solutions.

3. Genome-Scale CRISPR-Cas9 Screening (Joung et al.)

Perhaps the most procedurally significant update concerns the 64-step workflow for CRISPR-Cas9 screening. In the original 2017 protocol, Step 64 (the final stage involving Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) analysis) directed users to refer back to Steps 37–39. The corrected protocol now directs users to Steps 35–39. This ensures that two foundational steps required for the proper analysis of sgRNA distribution are included in the final analytical workflow.

The Impact of Minor Errors on Reproducibility

The corrections highlighted in this document underscore the fragility of complex experimental workflows. The "Step 64" error in the Joung et al. protocol is particularly illustrative: for a researcher conducting a genome-scale screen, following the original instruction would result in an incomplete analysis of the sgRNA library, potentially compromising the entire study's results.

Furthermore, the misalignment in the van Goethem et al. paper demonstrates that formatting is not merely an aesthetic concern in digital publishing; it is a functional component of information delivery. When a troubleshooting table is misaligned, the logical flow of the experiment is effectively broken.

Conclusion

These amendments serve as a formal rectification of the scientific record. While the errors in the Huhtamäki et al. and van Goethem et al. papers have been integrated into their respective digital versions, the amendment for Joung et al. remains the definitive source for the correct procedural flow, as the original 2017 text remains uncorrected. This collection serves as a critical reminder for the scientific community to regularly consult "Amendments" and "Corrections" sections before embarking on complex, resource-intensive protocols.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{joung2018author,
  author = {Julia Joung and Silvana Konermann and Jonathan S. Gootenberg and Omar O. Abudayyeh and Randall J. Platt and Mark D. Brigham and Neville E. Sanjana and Feng Zhang and Omar Abudayyeh},
  title = {{Author Correction: Genome-scale CRISPR-Cas9 knockout and transcriptional activation screening}},
  booktitle = {Nature Protocols},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41596-018-0063-0},
}
Figure