Erratum: Corrigendum: The promise and peril of chemical probes

C.h. Arrowsmith, James E. Audia, Christopher P. Austin, Jonathan B. Baell, Jonathan P. Bennett, Julian Blagg, C. Bountra, Paul E. Brennan, Peter J. Brown, Mark E. Bunnage, Carolyn Buser‐Doepner, Robert M. Campbell, Adrian J. Carter, Philip Cohen, Robert A. Copeland, Ben Cravatt, Jayme L. Dahlin, Dashyant Dhanak, A.m. Edwards, Mathias Frederiksen, Stephen V. Frye, Nathanael S. Gray, Charles E. Grimshaw, David Hepworth, Trevor Howe, K. Huber, Jian Jin, Stefan Knapp, Joanne Kotz, Ryan G. Kruger, Derek Lowe, Mary M. Mader, Brian D. Marsden, Anke Mueller‐Fahrnow, Susanne Müller, Rónán C. O’Hagan, John P. Overington, Dafydd R. Owen, Saul H. Rosenberg, Ruth A. Ross, Bryan L. Roth, Matthieu Schapira, Stuart L. Schreiber, Brian K. Shoichet, M. Sundström, Giulio Superti‐Furga, Jack Taunton, Leticia Toledo‐Sherman, Chris Walpole, Michael A. Walters, Timothy M. Willson, Paul Workman, Robert N. Young, William J. ZuercherNature Chemical Biology 2015 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

The scientific record is a living document that requires constant maintenance to ensure the accuracy of disseminated data. In the November 2015 issue of Nature Chemical Biology, a series of formal corrections—comprising one Erratum and two Corrigenda—was issued for three high-impact articles. These updates, while clerical or organizational in nature, are vital for maintaining the technical integrity of research in synthetic biology, targeted protein degradation, and chemical tool standards.

Correcting the Narrative of Combinatorial Biosynthesis

In the work of Kim et al. regarding the engineering of natural products, the correction addressed four typographical errors located within the abstract and the main text. While seemingly minor, the abstract serves as the primary gateway for indexing in databases like PubMed. Errors in this section can significantly hinder the searchability and accurate dissemination of synthetic biology techniques, potentially leading to confusion in the replication of natural product engineering protocols.

Visual Precision in PROTAC Research

One of the more scientifically significant corrections involved Raymond Deshaies’ foundational review, "Protein degradation: Prime time for PROTACs." In the original publication, Figure 1 contained a visual misidentification: the protein ERRα (Estrogen-related receptor alpha) was incorrectly labeled as BRD4 (Bromodomain-containing protein 4).

In the context of Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTACs), the specific recruitment of an E3 ligase to a target protein is the fundamental mechanism of action. Mislabeled targets in a central figure can lead to fundamental misunderstandings of the pathway being described. The correction ensures that researchers looking to understand or replicate these degradation pathways have an accurate visual reference for the proteins involved in the recruitment process.

Authorship and Institutional Credit in Large-Scale Collaborations

The commentary "The promise and peril of chemical probes" represents a massive multi-author effort to establish standards for the chemical tools used in biological research. The correction for this paper highlights the administrative complexity of "big science" and the importance of proper attribution.

Specifically, the update restores the name of Mathias Frederiksen (Novartis), who was omitted from the original author list, and corrects the affiliations for Bryan Roth, ensuring proper credit to the NIMH PDSP and the UNC Eshelman School of Pharmacy. In high-level academic and industrial research, accurate institutional affiliation is critical for funding, career progression, and establishing the provenance of collaborative work.

Conclusion

The formal amendments to these three articles have been integrated into their respective digital versions (HTML and PDF). These corrections underscore the ongoing necessity for rigorous data verification and the importance of the post-publication correction process in keeping the scientific record accurate and reliable for the global research community.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{arrowsmith2015erratum,
  author = {C.H. Arrowsmith and James E. Audia and Christopher P. Austin and Jonathan B. Baell and Jonathan P. Bennett and Julian Blagg and C. Bountra and Paul E. Brennan and Peter J. Brown and Mark E. Bunnage and Carolyn Buser‐Doepner and Robert M. Campbell and Adrian J. Carter and Philip Cohen and Robert A. Copeland and Ben Cravatt and Jayme L. Dahlin and Dashyant Dhanak and A.M. Edwards and Mathias Frederiksen and Stephen V. Frye and Nathanael S. Gray and Charles E. Grimshaw and David Hepworth and Trevor Howe and K. Huber and Jian Jin and Stefan Knapp and Joanne Kotz and Ryan G. Kruger and Derek Lowe and Mary M. Mader and Brian D. Marsden and Anke Mueller‐Fahrnow and Susanne Müller and Rónán C. O’Hagan and John P. Overington and Dafydd R. Owen and Saul H. Rosenberg and Ruth A. Ross and Bryan L. Roth and Matthieu Schapira and Stuart L. Schreiber and Brian K. Shoichet and M. Sundström and Giulio Superti‐Furga and Jack Taunton and Leticia Toledo‐Sherman and Chris Walpole and Michael A. Walters and Timothy M. Willson and Paul Workman and Robert N. Young and William J. Zuercher and Brian Marsden},
  title = {{Erratum: Corrigendum: The promise and peril of chemical probes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Chemical Biology},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1038/nchembio1115-887c},
}
Figure