Erratum: Half-metallic graphene nanoribbons

Young-Woo Son, Marvin L. Cohen, Steven G. LouieNature 2007 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

Scientific publishing is an iterative process where the pursuit of accuracy often requires post-publication adjustments. In the March 15, 2007 issue of Nature (Vol 446), a series of corrigenda were published to address errors in five high-impact studies. These corrections span diverse fields, including condensed matter physics, quantum optics, and molecular biology. While the primary focus of this summary is the erratum for "Half-metallic graphene nanoribbons," the collective updates underscore the importance of maintaining a precise scientific record.

The full page of Corrections & Amendments from Nature, March 2007.

Graphene Nanoribbons: A Scaling Correction

The study "Half-metallic graphene nanoribbons" (originally published in Nature 444, 347–349; 2006) received a significant numerical update. The authors identified a normalization error in the contour values presented in Figure 2b. Specifically, the scale bar for these values was incorrectly reported as ±1.4, whereas the correct values should have been ±36.6. This represents a scaling factor error of approximately 26. Despite this substantial numerical discrepancy in the visualization, the authors confirmed that the underlying data and the paper's primary conclusions regarding the electronic properties of graphene nanoribbons remain unchanged.

Clarifying Biological and Physical Mechanisms

Several other papers were amended to improve technical clarity and correct experimental attributions:

  • Pin1 and Alzheimer’s Disease: In the paper "Pin1 prolyl isomerase-mediated phosphorylation of APP regulates amyloid-β production," a key reference was restored that had been removed during the editorial process. This restoration clarifies that the Pin1 protein interacts specifically with the phosphorylated Thr 668–Pro motif of the C99 fragment (a β-cleaved carboxy-terminal fragment) rather than the full-length amyloid precursor protein (APP).
  • Human Embryonic Stem Cells: A correction to "Human embryonic stem cell lines derived from single blastomeres" refined the description of developmental potency. It clarified that while blastomeres are versatile, individual 8–16 cell stage blastomeres in most mammals have not been definitively shown to possess the "intrinsic capacity" to generate a complete organism on their own.
  • Quantum Optics: The historical and experimental record for "Happy centenary, photon" was corrected to distinguish between the experimental setups of Clauser and the team of Grangier, Roger, and Aspect. Figure 1 was re-attributed to reflect the principles of the latter team's experiment.

Ethical and Historical Accuracy

Beyond technical data, the corrigenda addressed transparency and attribution. In the study "The molecular basis of individual differences in phenylthiocarbamide and bitter taste perception," the authors added a missing disclosure regarding a patent application (US6558910) to comply with "Competing Financial Interests" standards.

Conclusion

These amendments serve as a vital mechanism for self-correction in science. Whether rectifying a scaling error in graphene simulations or ensuring proper credit in quantum optics history, these updates ensure that subsequent research is built upon a foundation of accurate and transparent data. The correction in the graphene nanoribbon paper, while numerically large, demonstrates how rigorous post-publication review can validate the robustness of a study's core findings even when visualization errors are discovered.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{son2007erratum,
  author = {Young-Woo Son and Marvin L. Cohen and Steven G. Louie},
  title = {{Erratum: Half-metallic graphene nanoribbons}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1038/nature05686},
}
Figure