Asymptotic Convergence Rate of Alternating Minimization for Rank One Matrix Completion

Rui Liu, Alex Olshevsky

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the convergence rate of a simple yet effective algorithm (alternating minimization) for a fundamental matrix completion problem: reconstructing a rank-one matrix from incomplete data. The authors establish a polynomial upper bound on this convergence rate, connecting it to the dynamics of reversible consensus problems and providing a theoretical foundation for the algorithm's practical success.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Matrix completion, the task of filling in missing entries in a matrix, is crucial in many applications like recommendation systems and data imputation. While algorithms for this problem exist, understanding their convergence guarantees, especially for simpler cases, is an ongoing challenge. This paper focuses on the most basic scenario: completing a rank-one matrix. Even in this simplified setting, the convergence behavior of alternating minimization (a popular and computationally efficient method) is not fully understood without strong assumptions on the data's structure (like incoherence or specific graph properties). The authors aim to provide a more general theoretical understanding of its convergence rate.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in connecting alternating minimization for rank-one matrix completion to reversible consensus dynamics.

  • Alternating Minimization (AM): The algorithm iteratively updates two vectors, x and y, such that their outer product xy^T approximates the target rank-one matrix M. In each step, it optimizes x while keeping y fixed, then optimizes y while keeping x fixed, using only the revealed entries.
  • Consensus Problem Connection: The authors show that the updates in AM can be reformulated as a stochastic matrix iteration. This means the algorithm's progress can be viewed as a discrete-time Markov chain.
  • Reversibility: They prove that these stochastic matrices are reversible. This property is key because it allows for a connection to the variational characterization of eigenvalues, a powerful tool in spectral analysis.
  • Variational Characterization: By leveraging the reversibility and properties of the resulting Markov chain, the paper derives an upper bound on the asymptotic convergence rate using the joint spectral radius of a set of matrices related to the consensus dynamics. This allows them to express the convergence rate in terms of the graph structure of the revealed entries.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses simulated data based on different graph structures (line, star, 2D-grid, 3D-grid, complete graph) to evaluate the theoretical bounds.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consensus as a Unifying Framework: The paper elegantly demonstrates that alternating minimization for rank-one matrix completion can be framed as a consensus problem. This opens up new avenues for analysis by leveraging existing theory from distributed systems and Markov chains.
  • Reversibility is Key: The reversibility of the underlying Markov chain is crucial. It allows the authors to use spectral properties (eigenvalues) to bound the convergence rate, which is a more robust approach than relying solely on direct iterative analysis.
  • Graph Structure Matters: The convergence rate is shown to depend polynomially on the number of nodes (n) and the maximum degree (Δ) of the graph formed by the revealed entries. This provides concrete insights into how the sparsity and connectivity of the observed data influence how quickly the algorithm converges.
  • Asymptotic vs. Non-Asymptotic Guarantees: The paper focuses on asymptotic convergence rates. This means it describes how the algorithm behaves in the long run, rather than providing a strict bound on the number of iterations needed to reach a certain accuracy from any starting point.

Key Results

  • The paper establishes a polynomial upper bound on the asymptotic convergence rate of alternating minimization for rank-one matrix completion.
  • This bound is expressed as 1 - O(b^2 / (n(n-1)Δ)), where n is the matrix dimension, Δ is the maximum degree of the graph of revealed entries, and b is a parameter related to the bounds on the entries of the latent vectors.
  • The convergence time to shrink the distance to the optimal solution by a factor of ε is shown to be approximately O(n(n-1)Δ log(1/ε)).
  • Numerical simulations suggest that for certain graph structures (like line graphs), the derived bound is quite tight, while for others (grids, star graphs), it might be conservative.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Asymptotic Nature: The primary limitation is that the results are asymptotic. This means the polynomial convergence guarantee holds for "large enough" iterations and "small enough" error tolerance. Establishing a non-asymptotic polynomial convergence time that holds for all initializations and error tolerances remains an open challenge.
  • Rank-One Simplification: The analysis is strictly for rank-one matrices. Extending these results to higher-rank matrix completion is a significant but challenging next step. The authors note that while the consensus framework can be generalized, the time-varying and potentially negative coefficients in higher-rank scenarios complicate the analysis.
  • Noisy Data: The current analysis assumes perfect knowledge of the revealed entries. Extending the framework to handle noisy observations is another important direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study alternating minimization for matrix completion in the simplest possible setting: completing a rank-one matrix from a revealed subset of the entries. We bound the asymptotic convergence rate by the variational characterization of eigenvalues of a reversible consensus problem. This leads to a polynomial upper bound on the asymptotic rate in terms of number of nodes as well as the largest degree of the graph of revealed entries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021asymptotic,
  author = {Rui Liu and Alex Olshevsky},
  title = {{Asymptotic Convergence Rate of Alternating Minimization for Rank One Matrix Completion}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Control. Syst. Lett},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=LDuSZJcKdR_},
}
Figure