Abstract
Tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVG) have shown promise in advancing vascular reconstructions. However, precise in vivo implantation is challenging, and it is unclear how deviations in location and size affect hemodynamics. This study aims to compare preoperative designs and postoperative anatomies of TEVG in an in vivo study to evaluate discrepancies and investigate the impact of graft displacement and size on hemodynamics by virtually simulating implantation scenarios that are informed by in vivo postoperative results. Designed and postoperative geometries of four porcine aortas were compared to measure the mismatch in implantation location and graft shape. These results informed a virtual TEVG implantation study. TEVG location, orientation, and size were varied to investigate the effects on the final aorta shape and hemodynamics. Anastomosis of TEVG was simulated using finite element modeling. Key hemodynamic metrics were obtained from virtual implantations and actual postoperative anatomies using computational fluid dynamics. Our in vivo study showed that TEVGs can experience up to 6.9 mm displacement and a 38 degree rotational shift post-implantation, leading to discrepancies in pressure drop (2.5 mmHg, 50%) and time-averaged wall shear stress (7.2 Pa, 72%) compared to predictions. Virtual anastomosis simulations improved aortic shape predictions by 27.5%. Our results highlight the sensitivity of key hemodynamic metrics to graft implantation location and size mismatch. By quantifying displacement ranges and their impacts during surgery, surgeons can make informed decisions.
Introduction
For pediatric patients with aortic anomalies such as coarctation, traditional synthetic grafts are often inadequate because they lack growth potential. Tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) offer a transformative alternative, acting as biodegradable scaffolds that are eventually replaced by the patient's native tissue.
Despite their potential, a significant "translation gap" exists between idealized computer-aided designs (CAD) and real-world surgical outcomes. In the operating room, surgeons face anatomical constraints that can lead to slight misalignments or rotations during suturing. These deviations, even on the scale of millimeters, can significantly alter hemodynamics—the blood flow patterns critical for long-term graft health. This study quantifies the impact of such "surgical imprecision" to define allowable margins for graft placement.
Methods and Study Design
The researchers utilized a dual-track approach combining animal models with high-fidelity computational simulations.
In Vivo Validation
Customized TEVGs were implanted into four porcine models (20-30 kg). Magnetic Resonance Angiography (MRA) was performed postoperatively to compare the actual geometry against the intended preoperative CAD design.
Virtual Implantation Framework
To systematically explore the effects of placement errors, a simulation pipeline was developed:
- Finite Element Modeling (FEM): The team simulated "virtual anastomosis"—the physical suturing process—to account for how soft tissues deform and interact mechanically.
- Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): Blood flow was simulated on these deformed geometries to evaluate Peak Systolic Pressure Drop (PSPD) and Time-Averaged Wall Shear Stress (TAWSS).
- Sensitivity Analysis: The study varied graft translation (up to 6.9 mm), rotation (up to 38°), and size to identify the most critical factors affecting hemodynamics.
Key Insights
The Importance of Virtual Anastomosis
The study demonstrated that simply overlaying a CAD model onto a scan is insufficient. By using FEM to simulate the mechanical stresses of suturing, the researchers improved the accuracy of aortic shape predictions by 27.5%.
Directional Sensitivity and Sizing
Hemodynamics proved highly sensitive to specific types of movement. The system was most affected by inferior-superior (vertical) translation and anterior-posterior rotation. Furthermore, the study found that undersized grafts caused significantly greater deviations in pressure and shear stress than oversized ones, suggesting that surgeons should "err on the side of larger" when between sizes.
Tolerance Mapping
A primary output of this research is the "tolerance map," which defines a spatial "safe zone" for implantation. For the models studied, allowable translational deviation ranged from 1 to 5 mm depending on the direction.
Results
The in vivo study revealed that grafts could experience up to 6.9 mm of displacement and 38° of rotation compared to the plan. These real-world deviations resulted in a 50% increase in pressure drop (2.5 mmHg) and a 72% increase in wall shear stress (7.2 Pa) over predicted values. While pressure drops generally remained below clinical intervention thresholds (20 mmHg), Wall Shear Stress (TAWSS) emerged as the more sensitive and critical metric for monitoring potential complications like thrombosis or stenosis.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This study provides a quantitative foundation for understanding how surgical variability impacts TEVG performance. While limited by a small cohort (n=4) and rigid-wall CFD assumptions, the findings highlight the need for intraoperative guidance tools. Future work will focus on incorporating Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI) to account for vessel pulsatility and conducting long-term studies to observe how TEVGs remodel in response to initial placement discrepancies.
Summary updated