Application of technical and economic analysis in the selection of technical solution in the enterprise

Jianbin Hang, Rui Miao, Wanchun Yang, Zhaoyi Zhang2017 · DOI

Abstract

In view of the problem happened nowadays that the deviation found in the selection of technical solution in the enterprise, on the basis of analyzing the characteristic, this article proposed the solution by technical and economic analysis method, introduced the procedure how to use this method in detail and verified by a case study of a manufacturing company for example. The results show that the application of technical and economic analysis method can provide a scientific basis for the enterprise to formulate and choose technology solutions, which means great significance for the enterprise to invest and make strategic decision.

Introduction

In modern industrial engineering, enterprises frequently encounter what can be termed the "technical advancement trap." Engineers and designers, driven by a pursuit of excellence, often gravitate toward the most cutting-edge materials or processes due to their superior performance metrics. However, technical brilliance does not inherently guarantee market success. If a solution is technically advanced but economically unfeasible—due to prohibitive material costs, manufacturing complexities, or limited market demand—the resulting product becomes uncompetitive. This paper addresses the lack of a systematic, scientific basis for selecting technical solutions that satisfy both rigorous engineering demands and the fundamental economic requirements of a business.

Methodology: The Technical-Economic Analysis Framework

To bridge the gap between engineering performance and financial viability, the researchers propose a structured six-step procedure for technical and economic analysis:

  1. Problem Identification: Identifying the specific manufacturing or management challenge.
  2. Target Setting: Defining measurable goals, such as cost reduction or market share targets.
  3. Alternative Design: Developing multiple technical paths or material options to solve the problem.
  4. Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis: Evaluating each alternative's technical merits and economic costs independently.
  5. Comprehensive Evaluation: Synthesizing technical and economic results to find the optimal balance.
  6. Decision-Making: Recommending the final scheme to stakeholders based on the synthesized data.

Technical Evaluation

The technical evaluation utilizes the Delphi method (expert scoring) combined with weighted calculations. Performance is categorized into primary indices—Design Ability and Manufacturing Ability—which are further broken down into secondary indices such as Allowable Stress, Thickness, High-Temperature Performance, Plasticity, and Welding Performance.

Economic Evaluation

The economic evaluation is centered on a Total Cost (TC) formula that accounts for the full lifecycle of production:

$$TC = MC + MPC + TTC + RC + WC + FC$$

Where:

  • MC: Material Cost
  • MPC: Processing Cost
  • TTC: Testing Cost
  • RC: Molding Cost
  • WC: Welding Cost
  • FC: Repair Cost

Case Study: High-Pressure Vessel Manufacturing

The framework was applied to a real-world scenario involving a power station equipment manufacturer designing a heat exchanger shell for 545°C steam conditions. Four alloy steel alternatives were evaluated using the proposed methodology.

Technical vs. Economic Performance

The analysis highlighted a significant disparity between technical ranking and economic feasibility. Two primary contenders emerged:

  • SA-387Gr91: This material achieved the highest technical score (87.96 points) due to its superior safety and performance characteristics. However, it was also the most expensive option, with a total cost of 3,611,448 RMB.
  • 12Cr1MoV: This material ranked second technically (85.80 points). While slightly lower in performance than SA-387Gr91, it was the most economical choice, costing 2,223,256 RMB.

Key Insights and Results

The study demonstrates the "Good Enough" principle in engineering management. While SA-387Gr91 was technically superior, 12Cr1MoV met all necessary safety and performance requirements for the project. Crucially, the total cost of the 12Cr1MoV solution was 38.44% lower than that of the top technical performer.

The economic analysis further revealed that manufacturing costs are often "hidden killers." Factors such as welding performance and cold molding costs significantly impacted the total project cost, sometimes outweighing the raw material price differences. By using weighted expert scoring, the authors successfully transformed subjective engineering intuition into a quantifiable metric comparable against hard currency costs.

Discussion and Limitations

While effective, the framework relies on the Delphi method, meaning results are sensitive to the expertise and potential biases of the consulted specialists. Furthermore, the current economic model is static; it does not account for the volatility of global metal markets or labor rate fluctuations over the lifecycle of a long-term project. Future work should integrate automated cost-estimation software and sensitivity analysis to address these variables.

Conclusion

The application of technical and economic analysis provides a scientific basis for strategic decision-making in enterprises. When the technical gap between two solutions is marginal and both meet the project's safety requirements, economic factors should become the primary decider. Selecting the 12Cr1MoV solution allowed the enterprise to maintain high quality while significantly enhancing market competitiveness through cost optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

In view of the problem happened nowadays that the deviation found in the selection of technical solution in the enterprise, on the basis of analyzing the characteristic, this article proposed the solution by technical and economic analysis method, introduced the procedure how to use this method in detail and verified by a case study of a manufacturing company for example. The results show that the application of technical and economic analysis method can provide a scientific basis for the enterprise to formulate and choose technology solutions, which means great significance for the enterprise to invest and make strategic decision.
BibTeX
@misc{hang2017application,
  author = {Jianbin Hang and Rui Miao and Wanchun Yang and Zhaoyi Zhang},
  title = {{Application of technical and economic analysis in the selection of technical solution in the enterprise}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2991/icemeet-16.2017.186},
}
Figure