Evaluation of Equipment Construction Project Schemes Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process and Grey Relational Analysis

Xuangong Zhang, Xin Gao, Menglong WangOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The evaluation of equipment construction project schemes is an important part of equipment development. On the basis of summarizing the characteristics of equipment construction project schemes evaluation, the corresponding evaluation index system and evaluation logic framework are constructed, and the evaluation mathematical model is constructed. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and grey relational analysis are introduced into the model analysis. The model is derived and solved, and the formula of grey correlation coefficient is improved. Finally, the effectiveness of the model is verified by an example analysis, and the optimization of the construction project scheme is realized.

Introduction: Addressing the "Three Major Issues"

In the realm of large-scale equipment development, particularly within military contexts, project management frequently encounters three systemic failures: "Dragging" (schedule delays), "Falling" (the degradation of technical standards to meet deadlines), and "Rising" (uncontrolled budget inflation). These issues often originate during the initial scheme selection phase, where the lack of a rigorous, objective evaluation method leads to the pursuit of suboptimal or unnecessary projects.

While existing research provides tools for generating requirements, there is a significant gap in methodologies for evaluating specific construction schemes. Traditional models often treat "necessity"—the fundamental question of whether the equipment is actually required for combat—as just another variable alongside cost and speed. This paper proposes a hybrid decision-making framework combining the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) to prioritize necessity and ensure robust project selection.

The "Necessity First" Logical Framework

The core innovation of this research is the "Necessity First" logic gate. Unlike standard multi-criteria decision-making models that weight all factors simultaneously, this framework establishes necessity as the primary filter.

Figure 2: The logical framework for equipment construction project evaluation, highlighting the necessity gatekeeper.

As shown in the logic framework, a project must first satisfy combat requirements and urgency. If a "non-equipment" solution—such as improved tactical training or organizational changes—can meet the need, the project evaluation ends immediately. This prevents the development of costly hardware when simpler alternatives exist. Only after passing this gate are factors like technical feasibility, rate of progress, and cost considered.

Evaluation Index System and Weighting

The researchers developed a multi-level index system to quantify project viability. The system is divided into four primary categories: Necessity (C), Technical Feasibility (B1), Rate of Progress (B2), and Cost (B3). These are further refined into nine secondary indicators, including the defense industrial base, talent reserves, and economic affordability.

To determine the relative importance of these indicators, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) was employed. AHP allows for the conversion of expert intuition into mathematical weights.

Figure 5: Weight allocation for primary and secondary indicators using the Analytic Hierarchy Process.

In this weighting scheme, Necessity (C) is assigned a weight of 1, acting as a multiplier for the other categories. Technical Feasibility (0.4) is prioritized over the Rate of Progress (0.3) and Cost (0.3), reflecting the high-stakes nature of equipment development where technical failure can render a project useless regardless of its cost or speed.

Mathematical Modeling: Improved GRA

The model utilizes Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) to rank competing schemes. GRA is particularly effective in scenarios with "grey" information—uncertainty or incomplete data typical of early-stage planning. The authors improved the standard grey correlation coefficient formula by normalizing "optimal" reference values to 1. Since the scoring system is "the-bigger-the-better" (where higher scores indicate better performance), this simplification makes the calculation more efficient for decision-support software.

Instance Analysis and Results

The model's effectiveness was validated through an instance analysis of an anti-tank equipment construction project. Twelve experts scored five alternative schemes using a qualitative-to-quantitative scale ranging from "Poor" to "Excellent."

The results identified Scheme 5 as the optimal choice with a final score of 62.19, followed by Scheme 4 at 54.88. Notably, Scheme 5 did not lead in every individual sub-category. However, its consistent performance across high-priority metrics—specifically Necessity and Technical Feasibility—allowed the AHP-GRA hybrid model to identify it as the most robust overall option. This demonstrates the model's ability to provide a clear mathematical basis for selection even when differences between alternatives are subtle.

Conclusion

By integrating AHP and GRA with a "Necessity First" logic, this framework provides a rigorous tool for equipment project evaluation. It effectively handles the subjectivity of expert judgment and the uncertainty of early planning while ensuring that resources are only allocated to projects that meet critical combat needs. Future work may involve incorporating dynamic data feeds to account for rapidly changing battlefield environments, further refining the model's predictive power.

Summary updated

Abstract

The evaluation of equipment construction project schemes is an important part of equipment development. On the basis of summarizing the characteristics of equipment construction project schemes evaluation, the corresponding evaluation index system and evaluation logic framework are constructed, and the evaluation mathematical model is constructed. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and grey relational analysis are introduced into the model analysis. The model is derived and solved, and the formula of grey correlation coefficient is improved. Finally, the effectiveness of the model is verified by an example analysis, and the optimization of the construction project scheme is realized.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022evaluation,
  author = {Xuangong Zhang and Xin Gao and Menglong Wang},
  title = {{Evaluation of Equipment Construction Project Schemes Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process and Grey Relational Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-038-1\_44},
}
Figure