Abstract
By revealing the contradiction of the requirements for "made in China 2025" talents demand with the current teaching status of Mechanical manufacturing technology, the paper pointed out the necessity of ideological and political education in the course of mechanical manufacturing technology. Consequently, based on the improved analytic hierarchy process, a course evaluation method is suggested to measure the teaching effect of mechanical manufacturing technology on the building morality and cultivating people. A level model with three layers is firstly constructed with consideration of teaching attitude, teaching content, teaching method and teaching effect. The weights of indexes at all levels can be determined by achieving the optimal transfer matrices so that a relatively perfect course evaluation system is established reasonably. It is significant to carry out the reform of classroom teaching in order to realize the value guidance for students.
Introduction
In the era of the "Made in China 2025" initiative, the manufacturing sector requires engineers who possess more than just technical proficiency. There is a critical need for professionals with strong professional ethics, social responsibility, and a "craftsman spirit." However, core engineering courses like Mechanical Manufacturing Technology are often perceived as dry and disconnected from broader social values.
While the Chinese Ministry of Education has mandated the integration of "building morality and cultivating people" into all curricula, the lack of standardized, scientific methods to measure these efforts remains a significant hurdle. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a quantitative evaluation framework using an Improved Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to measure the effectiveness of ideological and political integration in technical education.
The Evaluation Framework
The authors developed a structured, three-tier hierarchical model to move beyond subjective assessment. This model categorizes the complex goals of moral cultivation into measurable indices:
- Layer 1 (Target): The overall course evaluation ($A$).
- Layer 2 (Categories): Four primary pillars—Teaching Attitude ($B_1$), Teaching Content ($B_2$), Teaching Method ($B_3$), and Teaching Effect ($B_4$).
- Layer 3 (Factors): Thirteen specific sub-factors ($C_{1,1}$ through $C_{4,3}$) that provide granular metrics, such as "Political Direction," "Craftsman Spirit," and "Ability to Solve Problems."
Methodology: Improved AHP
Standard AHP is a common decision-making tool, but it can be prone to subjectivity and inconsistency in judgment matrices. To improve objectivity, the authors employed an Improved AHP utilizing optimal transfer matrices. This mathematical refinement ensures that the weights assigned to various indices are consistent and reflect a more rigorous consensus on their relative importance.
Beyond the mathematical model, the paper outlines practical "mining rules" for educators. These rules help professors identify ideological elements within a technical syllabus, such as using historical manufacturing achievements to instill national pride or analyzing safety accidents to teach professional responsibility.
Results and Weight Analysis
The primary result of this study is the determination of specific weights for each evaluation index. These weights allow institutions to calculate a comprehensive score for a course by summing the weighted performance of individual factors.
Key insights from the weight distribution include:
- The Importance of Pedagogy: Teaching Attitude ($B_1$) and Teaching Method ($B_3$) both received the highest weights (0.3625) at the category level. This suggests that how a teacher engages with students is just as critical for moral cultivation as the technical content itself.
- Dominant Sub-factors: Within the teaching method category, "Activating Subject Atmosphere" ($w_{2,9}$) emerged as a dominant factor with a weight of 0.7311, highlighting the necessity of a dynamic and engaging classroom environment for effective value guidance.
- Political and Professional Alignment: "Political Direction" ($w_{1,1}$) holds significant weight (0.3625) within the attitude category, aligning with the mandate to integrate national values into engineering education.
Conclusion
This research provides a robust, quantitative roadmap for engineering departments to evaluate their success in "building morality and cultivating people." By applying the Improved AHP, the authors have created a system that balances technical knowledge with professional ethics. While the model currently relies on expert judgment for its initial matrices, it sets the stage for more standardized, data-driven improvements in engineering pedagogy, ensuring that technical education serves both the industry and society at large.
Summary updated